Decoding the Counterspell Conundrum: Activated Abilities, Hexproof, and You!
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’re staring down a souped-up creature with hexproof, and it’s activating a nasty ability. Your hand hovers over that tempting counterspell. Can you use it? The answer, like many things in Magic: The Gathering, requires a bit of nuance.
The short answer is no, but with a vital exception. You can’t counter an activated ability with a spell that counters spells because activated abilities are not spells. However, certain spells and abilities can counter activated abilities, regardless of the source creature having hexproof. Hexproof only prevents targeting by spells or abilities your opponents control. If the counterspell doesn’t target the creature, the hexproof is irrelevant.
Let’s break down why and delve into the fascinating rules interactions at play.
Understanding Hexproof and Activated Abilities
The key is to understand exactly what hexproof does and what it doesn’t do.
-
Hexproof: A creature with hexproof “can’t be the target of spells or abilities your opponents control.” This is crucial. It stops your opponent from targeting the permanent (the creature on the battlefield) with spells or abilities.
-
Activated Abilities: These are abilities written in the format “[Cost]: [Effect]”. They reside on permanents and are activated by paying the specified cost. Importantly, activating an ability is not casting a spell. It places an ability on the stack.
-
The Stack: Think of the stack as a queue where spells and abilities wait to resolve. Spells are placed on the stack when they are cast. Activated and triggered abilities are placed on the stack when they trigger or are activated.
-
Targeting: Targeting means specifically choosing a permanent (like a creature), a player, or another object to be affected by a spell or ability. If a spell or ability doesn’t use the word “target” or involve attaching an aura spell to a permanent, it likely isn’t targeting.
Why Countering Activated Abilities Gets Tricky
Regular counterspells (like Counterspell itself, or Cancel) specifically counter spells. Since activated abilities aren’t spells, they’re immune to these effects. However, the plot thickens! There are cards specifically designed to counter abilities.
The Ability-Countering Arsenal
Cards like Stifle, Squelch, Voidslime, Tale’s End, and Summary Dismissal don’t counter spells; they counter abilities. These cards can indeed shut down activated abilities, even those coming from creatures with hexproof. This is because you are countering the ability on the stack and not targeting the creature.
The Hexproof Irrelevance
Because the counterspell for abilities does not target the creature, hexproof is irrelevant. The counterspell targets the ability on the stack and the hexproof on the creature is useless.
Navigating the Rules Labyrinth: FAQs
To further clarify this interaction and related scenarios, here are some frequently asked questions:
FAQ 1: Can I counter a creature spell with hexproof?
Yes. When a creature card is cast, it is a creature spell on the stack. Hexproof only applies to permanents on the battlefield. Counterspells targeting spells will work perfectly fine on a creature spell, hexproof or not.
FAQ 2: Does hexproof protect against board wipes?
No. Board wipes, like Wrath of God or Damnation, typically don’t target individual creatures. They affect all creatures on the battlefield. Since they don’t target, hexproof offers no protection.
FAQ 3: If my opponent casts a spell that says “Target player sacrifices a creature,” can they make me sacrifice my hexproof creature?
Yes. The spell targets the player, not the creature. The player is then instructed to choose a creature to sacrifice. Hexproof is irrelevant in this situation.
FAQ 4: Can I buff my own hexproof creature with auras and equipment?
Yes! Hexproof only prevents your opponents from targeting your permanent. You are free to target your own hexproof creatures with spells and abilities you control.
FAQ 5: Does hexproof stop Deathtouch?
No. Deathtouch is a static ability that modifies the rules of combat damage. It doesn’t target. If a creature with deathtouch deals damage to a creature with hexproof, the hexproof creature is destroyed.
FAQ 6: What’s the difference between hexproof and shroud?
Hexproof prevents your opponents from targeting the permanent. Shroud prevents anyone, including you, from targeting the permanent. Shroud is almost never better than hexproof.
FAQ 7: Does hexproof protect against triggered abilities?
Generally, no. Triggered abilities (abilities that trigger when a certain condition is met) usually don’t target. If a triggered ability doesn’t target, hexproof provides no protection.
FAQ 8: Can I use a planeswalker ability to remove a loyalty counter from a planeswalker my opponent controls with hexproof?
No. Planeswalker abilities are abilities and if you activate a planeswalker’s ability that targets something your opponent controls, but it has hexproof, it will not work. You can’t target objects with hexproof that you do not control, just like any other ability in the game.
FAQ 9: Does hexproof stop mutate?
The creature with hexproof can be targeted with mutate.
FAQ 10: Can you counter suspended spells?
While your opponent can’t counter the suspend ability with a card like Stifle, removing time counters is an ability that uses the stack. Remember, you can only cast a suspended card when its last time counter is removed, so if that ability is countered, the card will remain in exile.
FAQ 11: Does protection from color stop board wipes?
No. Protection doesn’t protect from things with that color identity.
FAQ 12: Is shroud ever better than Hexproof?
No. With shroud you can’t do something like casting a spell to enchant or attach an equipment to the creature, even if you control that creature. Hexproof only penalizes your opponent.
FAQ 13: Does destroy all work on Hexproof?
Yes. It doesn’t specify particular cards therefore it does not have a target, therfore hexproof or protection are useless.
FAQ 14: Does destroy all creatures work on indestructible?
No. Creatures with indestructible are impervious to any effects that normally destroy creatures.
FAQ 15: Is Deathtouch a triggered ability?
No, deathtouch is not a triggered ability.
Mastering the Interaction
Successfully navigating these rules interactions is crucial for strategic gameplay. Understanding that hexproof is about targeting and that activated abilities aren’t spells allows you to formulate effective counter strategies. Don’t rely solely on standard counterspells; consider including ability-countering options in your deck to handle pesky activated abilities, especially from creatures with hexproof.
Remember that the beauty of Magic lies in its intricate rules and interactions. Continuous learning and careful reading of card text will elevate your game to the next level. Consider exploring resources like the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org for further insights into game mechanics and strategy. They offer valuable perspectives on how games can be used for educational purposes, and understanding complex game rules like those in Magic: The Gathering is a great mental exercise!