Can You Counter Storm Copies? A Deep Dive into Magic: The Gathering’s Most Explosive Mechanic
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is no, you cannot directly counter storm copies themselves. Once the storm triggered ability resolves, the copies are placed directly onto the stack, and they aren’t “cast.” This distinction is crucial in understanding how storm works and why it is such a powerful, and often frustrating, mechanic in Magic: The Gathering (MTG). These copies are not spells being played; they are created by the storm trigger and simply exist on the stack, waiting to resolve. Therefore, traditional counterspells like Counterspell or Mana Leak won’t stop them. You can not target copies on the stack with those counterspells, simply because it is a copy and it is not cast like a normal spell.
However, the situation is not entirely hopeless. While you can’t counter the copies directly, you can interact with the storm mechanic and its individual parts in specific ways to mitigate the damage. Let’s delve into the intricacies of the storm mechanic, how it works, and the best strategies to deal with it.
Understanding the Storm Mechanic
Storm is a triggered ability that generates copies of a spell when it is cast. The number of copies created is equal to the number of spells that were cast prior to the spell with storm during that turn. This is why storm decks are usually about chaining several cheap spells, usually cantrips, before casting their game-winning spell.
Here’s a breakdown:
- The Initial Cast: When a spell with storm is cast, the storm trigger goes onto the stack. This is a separate entity from the spell itself.
- The Trigger Resolves: When the storm trigger resolves, it creates copies of the original spell. These copies are placed directly onto the stack.
- The Copies: These copies are not cast, they are just there. They inherit the properties of the original spell, but they are not considered new spells being played.
- Resolution: The stack then resolves from top to bottom, one at a time. Each copy resolves individually, with each copy being able to target a different target, if applicable.
The core of the problem is that the copies are not “cast,” they are created by a trigger. This means that they bypass the normal rules regarding spells and cannot be countered with spells that specifically target “spells”.
How to Actually Interact with Storm
So, if you cannot counter the storm copies themselves, how can you deal with a storm deck? There are a few methods, focusing on the storm trigger and other vulnerabilities.
Countering the Storm Trigger
This is the most crucial aspect of interacting with storm. Because the storm ability is a triggered ability, it is vulnerable to effects that can counter triggers, such as:
- Stifle
- Trickbind
- Disallow
- Flusterstorm
By countering the storm trigger, you prevent the creation of any copies. This stops the wave of copies dead in its tracks and prevents the entire storm turn from going off. This is the most effective way to stop the copies from ever reaching the stack. This is because by countering the trigger, you counter the process that creates the copies. The original spell may resolve, but its damage will be minimal if it is a card like grapeshot, since the damage is tied to the copies.
Disrupting the Setup
Storm decks rely on casting a high number of spells in a single turn to maximize the number of copies generated by their storm card. Therefore:
- Hand Disruption: Cards like Thoughtseize or Duress can help you remove key setup spells from your opponent’s hand, hindering their ability to generate a storm count.
- Resource Denial: Mana denial strategies (e.g., land destruction or taxing effects) can hinder the storm player’s ability to cast multiple spells in a single turn and limit the number of spells they can cast.
- Fast Clock: Storm decks usually don’t have a strong board presence in the early turns. If you can apply aggressive pressure early on, you can race them before they can generate a lethal storm turn.
Specific Card Interactions
Certain cards, such as the following, can disrupt storm:
- Rule of Law and similar effects: These cards limit the number of spells a player can cast each turn, significantly hindering the storm player’s ability to build a high enough storm count for a lethal turn.
- Grafdigger’s Cage and similar effects: These limit graveyard interactions, hindering some of the recursion that some storm decks use to generate the high spell count.
- Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite and other hate creatures: These can be hard to remove, creating a tempo swing.
It’s crucial to remember that you must target the trigger, not the copies themselves. Timing is everything, and a good understanding of how the stack works is needed to effectively play against storm.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions related to storm copies and how to counter them, to help you deepen your understanding of the mechanic:
1. What is the difference between countering a spell and countering a triggered ability?
A counterspell targets a spell on the stack, which can be any spell that was “cast”. A triggered ability is an ability that triggers when a condition is met. Storm is a triggered ability. You must use specific cards like Stifle to counter the trigger of an ability, not spells.
2. Can you counter the original spell with storm?
Yes, you can counter the original spell with storm, which will not prevent the copies being created, assuming the storm triggered ability resolves. Even if you counter the original spell with Counterspell the storm trigger will still resolve and create copies.
3. Does a storm count include the storm spell itself?
No, the storm count does not include the storm spell itself. The storm trigger counts spells cast before the spell with storm.
4. If a storm spell is copied, does the copy have storm?
Yes, a copy of a spell with storm will also have the storm ability, but making a copy will not cause the storm trigger to trigger again, since it is not cast.
5. Why is Grapeshot banned in pauper?
Grapeshot is banned in Pauper because it was the most efficient kill card for storm decks, making the strategy too powerful and difficult to defend against, without many answers outside of stifle effects.
6. Can you respond to the storm trigger?
Yes, the storm trigger goes on the stack as a triggered ability and can be responded to with effects like Stifle.
7. Do storm copies count as spells being cast?
No, storm copies are not cast. They are placed directly onto the stack. Therefore, they don’t trigger other effects that rely on spells being cast and also do not increase storm count for other spells.
8. Does copying a spell increase the storm count?
No, copying a spell does not increase the storm count. Only casting spells increases the storm count.
9. Can you use Stifle on a storm trigger?
Yes, Stifle can target the storm triggered ability to prevent the creation of the copies. This is the most effective method of dealing with storm.
10. If you counter the storm trigger with stifle, does the original spell still resolve?
Yes, if you counter the storm trigger with stifle, the original spell will still resolve, but no copies will be created.
11. Can you counter a suspended card?
While you can’t counter the suspend ability, you can counter the ability that brings the suspended card back into play once its time counters are removed.
12. Does a Miracle card have a triggered ability?
Yes, the Miracle ability is linked to a triggered ability. Specifically, a static ability linked to a triggered ability.
13. Can you counter a cycling ability?
Cycling can be countered by effects that counter triggered abilities, like Trickbind, because cycling is a triggered ability.
14. Does Eye of the Storm trigger the “cast” mechanic?
Yes, spells cast during the resolution of Eye of the Storm’s triggered ability are considered to be cast.
15. Are copied spells cast?
No, copied spells are not cast, therefore they will not be counted by other spells with storm.
Conclusion
While you cannot directly counter storm copies, understanding the nuances of the mechanic and its interactions with other cards allows you to implement strategic countermeasures. By focusing on disrupting the storm trigger and setup, and utilizing specific card interactions, you can better navigate the challenging situations that storm decks present. Mastering these aspects of MTG will help you become a better player, especially in dealing with a difficult and explosive mechanic.