Can You Detect Invisibility with Detect Magic?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer, and perhaps surprisingly for some, is no, Detect Magic cannot directly detect an invisible creature. While both spells deal with magical phenomena, they function in fundamentally different ways. Detect Magic is designed to sense the presence of magic, not the effects of specific spells like invisibility. This distinction is crucial in understanding how to interact with and counter the elusive nature of invisible foes within the world of D&D.
The Limitations of Detect Magic
What Detect Magic Actually Does
Detect Magic is a 1st-level divination spell that allows you to sense the presence of magic within a 30-foot radius. If magic is detected, you can use an action to perceive a faint aura around any visible creature or object that is imbued with magic and learn its school of magic. This spell is excellent for identifying magical items, determining if a location is magically warded, or discerning the school of a spell being cast. However, it hinges on visibility. An invisible creature, by its nature, is not visible and therefore falls outside the scope of Detect Magic‘s primary function.
Why It Doesn’t Detect Invisibility
The invisibility effect is a spell that changes the way a creature interacts with light, making it impossible to see visually. Detect Magic doesn’t bypass the visual absence of the creature. It detects magical energies, not their outcomes on visible light spectrum. It is a subtle distinction but a very important one. Since the creature is not visible, the faint aura that the spell would perceive cannot be applied. Think of it as using a metal detector—it will find the metal, but it won’t tell you where the dirt is that conceals it. The Detect Magic spell will only see the magical objects/effects that can be perceived.
Instantaneous Spells and Magic Items
Moreover, Detect Magic does not detect the lingering residue of magic from instantaneous spells, or magic items. So even if a creature just became invisible via a spell, the spell itself isn’t detectable anymore. The magical energy was used, and it’s gone. Likewise, a vampire or other undead is often not detectable, though they may have been created by magic, because there is no ongoing magic to sense. This highlights how Detect Magic looks for active magical presences rather than the effects of past magic.
Illusions
While Detect Magic can sense the presence of illusions, it does not reveal their true nature. You would know that something magical is present, but you wouldn’t be able to tell if it’s a real object or a deceptive illusion. This makes Detect Magic a useful tool for identifying potential deception but ultimately requires further investigation.
How to Truly Detect Invisibility
If Detect Magic can’t cut it, what can? Here are some reliable ways to detect an invisible creature:
-
See Invisibility: The second level spell See Invisibility is specifically designed to reveal invisible creatures and objects, and it is the most effective method. However, the range is only 10 feet.
-
Senses: You can rely on other senses. You can still smell, hear, taste, or touch an invisible creature. You might hear their footsteps or feel the brush of their passing.
-
Blindsight: Creatures with blindsight can perceive their surroundings without relying on sight, and they can perceive invisible creatures effectively within the range of their blindsight.
-
Tracking: Invisible creatures can leave behind tracks that can be followed.
-
Spells that reveal invisible creatures: Some spells, such as Fairy Fire can illuminate the invisible creature, making it visible, and also provide advantage on attacks. Also, spells like Fireball would cause an invisible creature to become visible if targeted.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can Detect Magic see through walls?
Detect Magic can penetrate most barriers, but it is blocked by 1 foot of stone, 1 inch of common metal, a thin sheet of lead, or 3 feet of wood or dirt. This means a strategically placed barrier can prevent the spell from detecting magic beyond it.
2. Does Detect Magic detect a person concentrating on a spell?
No. Detect Magic does not detect spellcasters even if they are concentrating on a spell. The spell detects the presence of magic effects, not the act of spellcasting.
3. Can you use Identify on a person?
Yes, you can. The spell Identify allows you to learn about the magical properties of a creature.
4. Can See Invisibility be made permanent?
Yes, the See Invisibility spell can be made permanent with a permanency spell in some homebrew or houseruled games. It is not a standard feature in official 5e rules, though.
5. Does See Invisibility see through illusions?
No, See Invisibility does not reveal illusions or enable you to see through opaque objects. It is specifically for revealing creatures that are under the invisibility condition.
6. If an invisible creature takes the Hide action, can you still attack it?
Yes, an invisible creature that has not taken the hide action is still detectable through sound, smell, and touch. If you know its general location, you can attack the invisible target, but with disadvantage on the attack roll.
7. Does holding concentration on a spell break invisibility?
No. Concentrating on a spell does not count as casting a spell, so it will not break invisibility. This allows a caster to remain invisible while maintaining an ongoing spell.
8. Does casting a spell break invisibility?
Yes. Casting any spell will break your invisibility, except if the invisibility is achieved through a race trait, like the firbolg.
9. Does attacking break invisibility?
Yes, attacking breaks invisibility.
10. Can you use Dispel Magic on invisibility?
Yes, and no, depending on your definition. While you can’t dispel the invisibility effect per se, because it isn’t an ongoing effect, you can break invisibility by using a spell like Dispel Magic or Counterspell, since casting a spell ends the invisibility effect.
11. Do you have disadvantage when attacking an invisible creature if you know where it is?
Yes, you have disadvantage on the attack roll. However, it’s not an automatic miss.
12. Does Detect Magic detect undead?
No. Detect Magic does not detect undead because they are not actively maintained by magic. They are no longer under the influence of the magic that might have created them. The magic was instantaneous and does not remain.
13. Can you see yourself when invisible?
No. The Invisibility spell does not grant any special sense that would allow you to see yourself while invisible.
14. Does the Invisibility spell have any benefits for the target?
Yes. Besides the obvious advantage of being unseen, the target also has advantage on attack rolls if the opponent cannot see them.
15. What race in 5e can go invisible?
Several races have abilities related to invisibility: Duergar Dwarves and Tieflings of the Glasya bloodline can cast Invisibility at level 5, and Firbolgs can use Hidden Step to become invisible from level 1.
Conclusion
While Detect Magic is a useful tool for sensing the presence of magical energy, it is not effective at detecting invisible creatures. To counter invisibility, you need to rely on spells like See Invisibility, your senses, blindsight, or careful tracking. Understanding the limitations of spells like Detect Magic is essential for any D&D player, and mastering detection methods will greatly improve your ability to deal with hidden threats. Remember, the magic of invisibility lies not in its total absence but in the challenges it presents to perception.