Can You Discard 0 Cards? A Deep Dive into Card Game Mechanics
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The seemingly simple act of discarding cards lies at the heart of many popular trading card games, including Magic: The Gathering (MTG) and Yu-Gi-Oh!. The question of whether you can discard 0 cards, or an empty hand, often arises, leading to confusion and debate. Let’s tackle this question head-on and explore the nuances of discarding in these games.
The Short Answer: Yes, You Can Discard 0 Cards
Yes, you absolutely can discard a hand of zero cards in both Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh!. While it may seem counterintuitive, the rules of both games allow for the action of discarding, even when your hand is empty. This often arises with card effects that instruct you to discard your hand, regardless of its size. It’s important to distinguish between the action of discarding and what happens when you discard; a key distinction lies in how triggered effects respond.
Discarding in Magic: The Gathering
How Discarding Works in MTG
In Magic: The Gathering, rule 701.8a states, “To discard a card, move it from its owner’s hand to that player’s graveyard.” This definition is very important, and is why you can discard an empty hand, even though there are no cards involved.
701.8b adds, “By default, effects that cause a player to discard a card allow the affected player to choose which card to discard. Some effects, however, require a random discard or allow another player to choose which card is discarded.”
So, what happens when you have no cards? The game still recognizes the act of discarding as an action. When an effect requires you to discard your hand, you are still fulfilling the effect, even if your hand is empty.
Empty Hand Discards and Triggers
It’s essential to note how discarding an empty hand interacts with triggered abilities. While you can discard an empty hand, discard triggers (like Feast of Sanity) only activate if a card is actually moved from your hand to the graveyard. If your hand is empty, no card is being discarded, thus those kinds of triggers don’t work. In essence, the game acknowledges that you are discarding a hand with 0 cards, even though no cards move to the graveyard.
Reforge the Soul Example
The card Reforge the Soul is an excellent illustration of this concept. It instructs you to discard your hand and then draw seven new cards. Whether you have cards in your hand or not, you must discard it, then you draw seven.
Can you discard at any time?
You cannot discard a card at any time. You always discard down to your hand limit at the end of the turn, so if your hand limit is 5, and you finish your turn with 6 cards in your grip, you are forced to discard a card.
Discarding in Yu-Gi-Oh!
How Discarding Works in Yu-Gi-Oh!
In Yu-Gi-Oh!, discarding is described as removing cards from the hand. The primary times you discard is during the End Phase due to the hand size limit, or when a card effect tells you to. You cannot discard from the field, you can only “send” cards to the graveyard.
Similar to MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh! acknowledges the action of discarding, even when your hand is empty. If a card effect instructs you to discard your hand, you must do so, regardless of the number of cards you hold.
Empty Hand Discards
Just like in MTG, discarding your empty hand still happens in Yu-Gi-Oh!. If an effect requires you to discard all of your hand, you still perform the action, and resolve any consequences of that. If you have no cards in hand, you are discarding 0 cards.
Empty Hand and Drawing
Even if your hand is empty, the rules still apply, and you only draw one card during your draw step. If you don’t have any cards, and you have to discard your hand, the only thing you are discarding is 0 cards.
Discarding vs Sending
It’s crucial to differentiate between discarding and “sending” cards to the graveyard. In Yu-Gi-Oh!, the term “discard” is specific to cards in your hand. Effects like Foolish Burial, which sends a card from the deck to the graveyard, is not a form of discard.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What exactly does it mean to discard a card in MTG?
In MTG, to discard a card means to move it from your hand to your graveyard.
2. Can a trigger activate if you discard an empty hand in Magic: The Gathering?
No. Most discard triggers require a card to move to the graveyard. If your hand is empty, no card is moved to the graveyard, and therefore the triggered ability will not work.
3. What does “discard your hand” mean in MTG if your hand is empty?
“Discard your hand” means you perform the action of discarding, but nothing goes to your graveyard if it is empty.
4. How does Reforge the Soul in MTG interact with an empty hand?
When Reforge the Soul requires you to discard your hand, you must still do it, even if you have no cards in hand. Then you draw seven.
5. What is the ruling around discarding cards in Yugioh?
In Yu-Gi-Oh!, discarding means to remove cards from your hand, usually at the end of the turn, when your hand exceeds its limit, or due to a card effect.
6. Can you discard a card from your field in Yu-Gi-Oh!?
No, you cannot “discard” cards from the field in Yu-Gi-Oh!. Cards on the field are sent, not discarded.
7. What’s the difference between “discard” and “send” in Yu-Gi-Oh!?
“Discard” refers to moving a card from your hand to the graveyard, while “send” is used for cards from the field or deck.
8. If you have no cards in hand in Yu-Gi-Oh!, do you still draw one during the draw step?
Yes, even with no cards in hand, you still draw one card during your draw step in Yu-Gi-Oh!.
9. Can you “go out” in Rummy without discarding if all your cards are matched?
Yes, if all of your remaining cards are matched, you can lay them down without discarding on your last turn.
10. Can you discard a playable card to “go out” in Phase 10?
Yes, to “go out” in Phase 10, you must get rid of all of your cards, by discarding or “hitting” on an existing phase.
11. Can you discard a card even if you have no cards in hand?
The difference is that “sacrifice a creature” is more like “discard a card'”. You can’t discard a card if you have no cards in hand, because it specifies a card. But if it says discard your hand, it’s functionally the same as sacrifice/destroy all creatures.
12. What is the 0 life rule in Magic: The Gathering?
If a player has 0 or less life in MTG, that player loses the game as a state-based action.
13. What is Rule 0 in Magic: The Gathering?
Rule 0 in MTG allows players to modify the official rules of the game with the agreement of everyone involved.
14. Why is 60 cards the deck limit in Yu-Gi-Oh!?
The 60 card limit was put in place after a player entered a tournament with a 2222 card deck, trying to waste time.
15. Are “Number” monsters in Yu-Gi-Oh! indestructible?
“Number” monsters on the field cannot be destroyed by card effects, and cannot be destroyed by battle except with another “Number” monster. However, they can still be sent to the graveyard.
Conclusion
The ability to discard an empty hand in both Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh! is a fascinating aspect of card game mechanics. While it may seem illogical, it allows the game to function seamlessly, particularly when dealing with card effects that require you to discard your entire hand. By understanding the distinction between the act of discarding and the actual moving of cards, players can make more informed decisions and gain a deeper appreciation for the intricacies of these games.