Table of Contents

Can You Double Double Strike? Unpacking the Mechanics of Combat in Magic: The Gathering

Quick answer

This page answers Can you double double strike? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

In the thrilling world of Magic: The Gathering (MTG), understanding the intricacies of combat is key to victory. One question that often arises is: Can you “double double strike”? The short answer is no, multiple instances of double strike on a single creature are redundant. This means that giving a creature with double strike the ability again doesn’t provide any additional benefit. A creature with double strike already deals combat damage in both the first-strike combat damage step and the regular combat damage step. Adding more instances of the ability doesn’t make it attack a third or fourth time.

This article will dive deeper into the mechanics of double strike, explore how it interacts with other abilities, and address common questions to ensure a comprehensive understanding of this powerful keyword. This should help both novice and seasoned players navigate the complexities of MTG combat.

Understanding Double Strike in MTG

What is Double Strike?

Double strike is an evergreen keyword ability in MTG, meaning it appears frequently across different sets and is fundamental to the game’s design. A creature with double strike deals combat damage twice during each combat phase:

First Combat Damage Step: It deals combat damage alongside creatures with first strike.
Second (Regular) Combat Damage Step: It deals combat damage again with creatures that don’t have either first strike or double strike.

Essentially, double strike grants a creature two opportunities to deal damage in a single combat phase, making it a potent offensive and defensive ability. It enhances combat effectiveness by potentially overwhelming blockers or swiftly eliminating threats.

Why Redundancy Matters

The rule regarding redundant abilities, such as multiple instances of double strike, is crucial for maintaining the game’s balance and preventing exponential power scaling. If stacking double strike were allowed, it would create scenarios where creatures could deal an excessive amount of damage in a single turn, disrupting gameplay and potentially leading to unfun or unfair outcomes.

Imagine a creature with two power that somehow gained four instances of double strike. If stacking were allowed, it could theoretically deal eight damage in a single combat, which would be exceedingly powerful. Redundancy rules prevent such scenarios.

Double Strike vs. First Strike

Many players wonder about the relationship between double strike and first strike. While both abilities affect when combat damage is dealt, they are distinct:

First Strike: Creatures with first strike deal combat damage before creatures without it.
Double Strike: Creatures with double strike deal combat damage both in the first strike combat damage step and the regular combat damage step.

A creature with both first strike and double strike effectively just has double strike, as the first strike component becomes redundant. Double strike encompasses the functionality of first strike and adds an additional damage dealing opportunity.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Double Strike

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the mechanics and interactions of double strike in MTG:

Does giving a creature with double strike first strike do anything? No. As mentioned earlier, if a creature already has double strike, adding first strike is redundant. The creature will still deal damage twice – once in the first combat damage step and again in the regular combat damage step.
If a creature with double strike is blocked, and the blocker dies in the first combat damage step, does the double strike creature deal damage to the player? Not unless the creature also has trample. By default, once a creature is blocked, it remains blocked for the entire combat, even if the blocking creature is destroyed. Trample allows excess damage to be dealt to the defending player after assigning lethal damage to all blockers.
How does double strike interact with deathtouch? Deathtouch means any amount of damage a creature deals is enough to destroy the damaged creature. If a creature with double strike has deathtouch, it will deal lethal damage in both combat damage steps. If a creature with double strike blocks a creature with deathtouch it will deal damage during the first combat damage step, before the deathtouch creature can return fire.
Does double strike give two poison counters if a creature has infect? Yes. If a creature with double strike and infect deals combat damage to a player, the player receives poison counters equal to the damage dealt in each combat damage step. A 1/1 creature with both abilities would give the defending player 1 poison counter in the first combat damage step, and then another in the regular combat damage step, for a total of two poison counters.
Can double strike work during a “fight” spell? Yes, but only in a limited sense. First strike and double strike only modify combat damage steps; a “fight” spell does not create combat damage steps (C.R. 701.12). If a creature with double strike fights another creature, damage is dealt simultaneously, but deathtouch will still work.
Does double strike work with trample? Yes. Trample allows a creature to deal excess damage to the defending player after assigning lethal damage to its blockers. If a creature with double strike has trample, it can deal damage to blockers in the first combat damage step and then deal any remaining damage to the player.
Does double strike trigger “when this creature deals combat damage” abilities twice? Yes. Because double strike results in damage being dealt in two separate combat damage steps, triggered abilities that activate upon dealing combat damage will trigger twice.
Can a creature have both toxic 1 and double strike? How would that work? Absolutely! Toxic and double strike work very well together. If a creature with double strike and toxic 1 deals combat damage to a player, that player receives one poison counter during the first combat damage step and another poison counter during the regular combat damage step, for a total of two poison counters.
If an indestructible creature blocks a creature with double strike and deathtouch, what happens? The indestructible creature survives. Indestructible means a creature cannot be destroyed by damage or effects that say “destroy”. The deathtouch damage from the double strike creature will not destroy the indestructible creature, so it lives.
Does double strike work while blocking? Yes. Double strike is effective both when attacking and blocking. A creature with double strike that blocks another creature will deal damage in both the first strike and regular combat damage steps.
If I proliferate toxic counters, can I proliferate them again? Yes. Proliferate allows you to add an additional counter of any kind already on permanents and/or players. You can proliferate as many times as you can pay the cost, and it works effectively with toxic counters.
If a creature with double strike is equipped with a Sword of X and Y, does the sword’s ability trigger twice? Yes. If the equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, the sword’s ability triggers. With double strike, this happens twice, so the ability triggers twice.
How does double strike work against multiple blockers? A creature with double strike must assign at least lethal damage to the first blocker in the declared blocking order before assigning any damage to subsequent blockers in the first combat damage step. Any remaining damage can be divided among the remaining blockers, again ensuring lethal damage is assigned in order. This process is repeated during the regular combat damage step.
Is double strike only effective when attacking? No. Double strike is equally effective when blocking. A creature with double strike will deal damage in both combat damage steps regardless of whether it’s attacking or defending.
If a creature has multiple instances of Toxic, will they stack? Yes, toxic does stack. If a creature has multiple instances of toxic, let’s say toxic 1 and toxic 2, and it deals combat damage to a player, they get a total of 3 poison counters because of the two toxic abilities.

Conclusion

While you can’t “double double strike,” understanding how double strike functions and interacts with other abilities is critical for success in MTG. This powerful keyword can significantly impact combat outcomes, and mastering its nuances can give you a competitive edge. Continue to explore the intricate rules and strategies of Magic: The Gathering. Consider exploring resources like the Games Learning Society, accessible at GamesLearningSociety.org, to further enhance your understanding of game mechanics and strategic thinking. With the right knowledge, you can effectively wield double strike and dominate the battlefield. Happy dueling!