Can You Exile a Suspended Card? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short and direct answer is: Yes, a suspended card can be exiled. However, the nuances surrounding this simple statement are complex and involve understanding the mechanics of the suspend keyword in Magic: The Gathering (MTG). While suspending a card itself puts it into exile, the question is generally asked about what happens to a suspended card already in exile. Therefore, let’s dive deep into when and how you can further exile a card that is already suspended.
Understanding Suspend and Exile
Before addressing the complexities, it’s essential to grasp the basics. The suspend keyword represents three abilities in MTG:
- Exiling from Hand: It allows you to exile a card from your hand with time counters by paying its suspend cost, instead of casting it.
- Time Counter Removal: At the beginning of your upkeep, you remove a time counter.
- Casting When Last Counter Removed: When the last time counter is removed, you may cast the card for free without paying its mana cost.
Exile, on the other hand, is a zone in MTG where cards are typically removed from the game and are often harder to interact with than cards in the graveyard.
Now, onto the core question – can you further exile a suspended card? Yes, you absolutely can. A suspended card is a card in exile, and just like any card in exile, it can be targeted by effects that exile cards. This might seem redundant, but there are scenarios where this action is relevant:
- Targeted Exile Effects: Cards like [[Swords to Plowshares]] or [[Path to Exile]] don’t care if a card is suspended or not, they just exile the targeted card.
- Zone Manipulation: Some effects allow you to move cards from exile to other zones, and then could exile it again after that.
- Specific Card Interactions: Certain cards may have specific abilities that trigger upon a card being exiled, regardless of its previous status.
Therefore, the correct perspective is not if you can exile a suspended card, but how the suspend and exile rules interact.
Key Considerations
Understanding the difference between the suspend ability and the card itself is critical. Suspending a card from your hand is not casting the card nor an activated ability. It’s a special action, meaning that it cannot be countered and doesn’t use the stack. Once the card is suspended and in the exile zone, it behaves as any other card in that zone, except for the unique trigger of removing time counters at the start of each turn to eventually be cast, unless otherwise manipulated.
The act of exiling a suspended card doesn’t remove its time counters or remove the special suspend status. Rather it is moving the card to exile once again. The suspend triggers are not affected by being exiled again. It can be exiled numerous times, and will still continue its normal suspend sequence.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the complex rules surrounding suspend and exile in MTG:
1. Does Suspending a card cast it?
No. Suspending a card is a special action, not casting. You exile the card from your hand with time counters on it. You only cast the card when the last time counter is removed.
2. Can you counter a card that’s being suspended?
No. The act of suspending a card doesn’t use the stack. Therefore, it cannot be countered by cards like [[Counterspell]] or [[Stifle]]. The removal of time counters, however, does use the stack.
3. Does a suspended card count as a permanent?
No. A permanent exists only on the battlefield. A suspended card is in exile, not on the battlefield.
4. Can you cascade into a card and suspend it?
No. Cascade allows you to cast a card, it doesn’t allow you to suspend it. Suspend is a special action that can be taken when you would cast a card from your hand. You cannot cascade into a card and then suspend it.
5. Can you use Flashback on suspended cards?
No. You can only suspend a card from your hand. Giving a card in your graveyard flashback does not change the fact that it cannot be suspended from the graveyard.
6. Can you remove time counters from a suspended card using other cards?
Yes. Certain cards like [[Jhoira’s Timebug]] and [[Fury Charm]] can add or remove time counters from suspended cards.
7. If my card is exiled again, do the time counters get reset?
No. Exiling a suspended card again doesn’t reset or remove the time counters already on it. It just moves it to exile, where it retains those counters.
8. Do creatures cast from suspend have summoning sickness?
Yes, they do. However, they also gain haste until the end of turn, meaning they can attack and tap as if they didn’t have summoning sickness.
9. Does exiling a card remove counters?
No. Exiling a card simply moves it to the exile zone. It does not remove any type of counters.
10. Can you proliferate suspended card counters?
No. Proliferate only allows you to add counters to permanents or players. A suspended card is not a permanent.
11. Can you target a suspended card with exile effects?
Yes. A suspended card is just a face up card in exile with time counters on it. You can target it with exile spells as you would any other card in exile.
12. Can a suspended card that was exiled again be cast if the last time counter is removed?
Yes. As long as the card is still in the exile zone when the last time counter is removed, the suspend trigger will allow you to cast the spell.
13. If a card with suspend has multiple exile effects that move it in and out of exile, does the suspend resolve?
Yes, as long as the card is in exile when it is time to remove the last time counter, and the card has not been moved to another zone, the suspend trigger will activate.
14. What happens if a suspended card is countered after the last counter is removed?
If the ability to cast the suspended card is countered, the card will remain in exile.
15. Is suspending a card the same as putting it into exile?
Yes and no. The act of suspending a card moves it to exile, but it is not just “putting it into exile”. Suspending is a special action that has its own rules associated with the act, where just putting a card into exile doesn’t have these special rules.
Conclusion
While the rules surrounding suspend and exile can seem intricate, understanding that a suspended card is a card in exile simplifies many of the interactions. You can exile a suspended card further, target it with cards that affect the exile zone, and the card will otherwise still follow its suspend process even if it was exiled more than once. Grasping these nuances can significantly improve your gameplay and strategic decision-making in MTG.