Can You Get Arthur’s Revolver as John in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question on every Red Dead Redemption 2 player’s mind after the heartbreaking conclusion of Arthur Morgan’s story: Can you get Arthur’s revolver as John? The short answer is yes, you do inherit Arthur’s guns, including his revolvers, when you transition to playing as John Marston in the epilogue. However, there are nuances to this inheritance, and it’s not always as straightforward as simply finding everything neatly packed in your saddlebag. Let’s dive into the details of how this works and what you can expect as you step into John’s boots.
What Happens to Arthur’s Gear After Chapter 6?
Upon reaching the epilogue, you’ll automatically retrieve Arthur’s weapons, outfits, Kit items, Trinkets, Talismans, Valuables, and Documents. This ensures that your hard-earned arsenal and carefully curated wardrobe don’t vanish into thin air. The game understands the investment players make in acquiring these items, and provides a way for them to continue using them as John.
However, there’s a crucial caveat: Arthur’s money, food, and consumables are gone. This narrative choice aligns with the storyline, highlighting the Marston family’s financial struggles and the need to rebuild their lives. It creates a sense of realism and forces players to start afresh in certain aspects, reflecting the challenges John faces. Also, Arthur’s horses are lost and John will start with new horses.
Understanding the Inheritance System
The inheritance system is designed to provide a sense of continuity while also resetting certain aspects of the game. Here’s a breakdown:
- Weapons: All the guns Arthur collected, including his revolvers, repeaters, rifles, shotguns, and rare weapons, are transferred to John.
- Outfits: Every outfit Arthur owned, from the Gunslinger Outfit to custom-created ensembles, will be available in John’s wardrobe.
- Kit Items: Items like binoculars, fishing rod, and hunting equipment are carried over.
- Trinkets and Talismans: These valuable items with permanent stat boosts will remain active, providing John with the same advantages Arthur enjoyed.
- Character Progress: Known recipes and completed challenges are preserved, allowing you to continue crafting and progressing through the game’s various activities. However, core stat progress is reduced to 6/8 bars again.
John’s Revolvers vs. Arthur’s Revolvers
While John inherits Arthur’s revolvers, it’s important to note that John Marston also has a distinct “signature weapon”: John’s Cattleman Revolver. This revolver has a unique appearance, featuring a dark grey frame and a light bone grip. It’s a subtle detail that helps to differentiate John from Arthur, even when they’re wielding the same weapon types.
You might even be able to acquire two of John’s Cattleman Revolvers by disarming an O’Driscoll during a shootout, leading the disarmed enemy to John, and then picking up the dropped revolver after a brief struggle. This exploit allows you to dual-wield John’s signature revolver for added firepower.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions about transferring items and progress from Arthur to John in Red Dead Redemption 2:
1. Do I lose all my progress when Arthur dies?
No, you don’t lose all your progress. You retain your weapons, outfits, kit items, trinkets, talismans, valuables, documents, known recipes, and completed challenges. Only money, food, and consumables are lost. Also, all Arthur’s horses are lost.
2. Can I keep Buell after Arthur dies?
Yes, you can keep Buell, but only if you complete the last part of Hamish’s mission after Chapter 6, as John. If you complete the mission as Arthur, Buell will be lost along with all of Arthur’s other horses.
3. What happens to Arthur’s camp when I switch to John?
Arthur’s camp is permanently gone. John establishes his own life and base of operations, which centers around Beecher’s Hope.
4. Does Arthur’s honor level carry over to John?
Yes, Arthur’s honor level carries over to John. However, it might fluctuate depending on your actions as John in the epilogue.
5. What is the best revolver to give to John before the end?
This is subjective, but many players consider the Schofield Revolver to be the best all-around revolver in the game. Equipping Arthur with a customized Schofield before the transition ensures John starts with a powerful and versatile sidearm.
6. Can I customize Arthur’s revolvers and have those customizations carry over to John?
Yes, any customizations you make to Arthur’s revolvers, such as engravings, metal finishes, and grip upgrades, will carry over to John.
7. Does Arthur’s satchel inventory carry over to John?
Yes, the contents of Arthur’s satchel, including tonics, crafting materials, and valuables, are transferred to John.
8. Can I get Arthur’s horse as John?
Unfortunately, no. Arthur’s horse(s) are gone after the main story.
9. Is there a way to replay Arthur’s missions as John?
No, you cannot replay Arthur’s missions as John. However, you can replay missions through the Story menu, but you will be playing as Arthur during those replays.
10. What is John Marston’s signature weapon?
John Marston’s signature weapon is his Cattleman Revolver. It’s a distinct variation of the standard Cattleman Revolver, featuring a dark grey frame and a light bone grip.
11. How do I unlock the Double-Action Revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2?
You can unlock the Double-Action Revolver by completing a treasure hunt in GTA Online and linking your Red Dead Redemption 2 account to your Social Club account. After completing Chapter 2, you’ll find the revolver in your inventory.
12. What is the rarest revolver in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Flaco’s Revolver is a unique Cattleman Revolver obtained by defeating Flaco Hernandez and his Del Lobos gang during “The Noblest Of Man, And A Woman”. It features delicate engravings and a carved ivory handle.
13. Does Arthur’s clothing style influence John’s appearance?
Yes, the outfits Arthur owned become available in John’s wardrobe. You can dress John in Arthur’s outfits, allowing you to maintain a similar aesthetic if desired.
14. Can I get Micah’s Revolver as John?
No, you cannot get Micah’s Revolver to keep as John in the normal course of the game. You might use it during a mission, but you cannot add it to your permanent inventory.
15. Does Arthur have a canon revolver?
Arthur does not have a defined “canon” revolver. Players can choose their preferred sidearm, although the Cattleman Revolver is the first weapon Arthur wields and is a common choice. Ultimately, it is up to the player.
Conclusion
Stepping into John Marston’s boots after Arthur’s tragic end is a bittersweet experience. While the loss of Arthur’s horse and some resources stings, knowing that you retain his hard-earned weapons, including his revolvers, and outfits provides a sense of continuity and closure. Remember to make the most of your time with Arthur, customizing his gear and mastering your favorite weapons, as these choices will influence your experience as John. The game allows you to carry over not just equipment, but a piece of Arthur himself, into the epilogue, offering a fitting tribute to a beloved character.
Red Dead Redemption 2 offers a rich environment for studying game-based learning. For those interested in the academic aspects of gaming, be sure to visit the Games Learning Society to learn more about the intersection of education and video games. You can find them at GamesLearningSociety.org.