Can You Get Micah Without Killing in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, technically you can get Micah Bell out of jail in Strawberry without killing, at least initially. However, progressing through the Red Dead Redemption 2 storyline necessitates completing the “Rescuing Micah” mission, and while you can minimize casualties, avoiding all killing entirely is practically impossible due to the game mechanics and scripted events. Let’s delve into the nuances of this controversial character and explore the possibilities – and limitations – of handling him peacefully.
The Illusion of Choice: Rescuing Micah and its Consequences
The mission “Rescuing Micah” presents a seeming opportunity for a non-lethal approach. The initial objective involves infiltrating the Strawberry jail and freeing Micah. One player even revealed that you can just walk straight into the Sheriff’s office where Micah is being held and blast away the three lawmen inside. The game does provide options for stealth or distraction, and it’s possible to get to Micah’s cell without raising alarms and engaging in a massive shootout. You can sneak around, use the Steam Donkey contraption to cause a diversion, and potentially unlock his cell with minimal confrontation.
However, the escape is where things become problematic. The game’s design funnels you towards a gunfight. Even if you manage a stealthy jailbreak, the subsequent escape from Strawberry is almost guaranteed to trigger a violent confrontation with lawmen. The game throws obstacles in your path, and the sheer number of lawmen makes a truly pacifistic run incredibly difficult, if not impossible, without exploiting glitches or mods.
Moreover, even if you managed to get Micah out without landing a single shot, you’re not off the hook. Keeping the playthrough going you will have to make the same decision eventually. Micah is essential to the plot.
The Inevitable Confrontations
The core issue lies in the mission structure. Rockstar Games designed the mission with shootouts in mind. While creative players might find ways to circumvent some confrontations, the game’s AI and scripted events often force Arthur into situations where violence seems the only option. Lawmen will aggressively pursue you, and their aim is remarkably accurate. Attempting to flee without firing back is a challenge in itself, and even successful escapes often rely on using your horse’s speed and agility rather than avoiding conflict altogether.
Micah’s Character and the Narrative
Micah is intentionally written as a character the player is meant to dislike. He is violent, treacherous, and ultimately responsible for the downfall of the Van der Linde gang. The game subtly encourages you to engage with him antagonistically. While this doesn’t necessitate killing him prematurely, it highlights the narrative’s bias towards a confrontational relationship. Therefore, the game doesn’t reward or encourage a pacifistic approach to Micah.
Delaying the Inevitable: The Consequences of Postponing
While you must eventually rescue Micah to progress the story, you can delay the mission for a considerable amount of time. This allows you to explore the world, complete side missions, and build relationships with other gang members before facing the consequences of Micah’s return. Some players even choose to save the mission until just before the gang moves to their second hideout.
A World Without Micah?
What if Arthur never rescued Micah? This scenario radically alters the trajectory of the game. Arthur might find his Mary Gillis and settle somewhere dry, avoiding the TB he would get later on. The absence of Micah would likely prevent the events that lead to John Marston being hunted by Agent Ross. The Van der Linde gang would remain intact, and the events of the game might never unfold the way they do. However, this is purely speculative, as the game’s narrative is firmly anchored to Micah’s presence.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Micah Bell
Here are some frequently asked questions about Micah Bell in Red Dead Redemption 2:
1. Is saving Micah optional in Red Dead Redemption 2?
No, saving Micah is not optional if you want to complete the main storyline of Red Dead Redemption 2. The “Rescuing Micah” mission is a mandatory part of the narrative progression.
2. Can you fight Micah in RDR2?
Yes, you can fight Micah multiple times throughout Red Dead Redemption 2. The most significant confrontation occurs during the final mission, “American Venom,” where Arthur, or later John, has the opportunity to confront and potentially defeat Micah. Depending on your play style and honor level, the outcome of these encounters may vary.
3. Could Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick?
Yes, many players believe that Arthur could have definitively beaten Micah if he hadn’t contracted tuberculosis. Arthur was physically stronger and a more skilled gunslinger, but the illness significantly weakened him, giving Micah an advantage in their final confrontation.
4. Why does Arthur hate Micah?
Arthur hates Micah because Micah is a traitor. He sold information about the Van der Linde gang’s movements to the Pinkertons, leading to their downfall. Micah’s actions directly contributed to the gang’s disintegration and the deaths of several members.
5. Can you loot Micah’s body?
Yes, you can loot Micah’s body after the final confrontation in “American Venom.” You can retrieve one of his revolvers from his corpse, specifically, Micah’s Revolver, but only one is retrievable.
6. Can you take Micah’s guns?
Only one of Micah’s revolvers can be acquired after completing “American Venom” in Epilogue 2. You must return to the top of Mount Hagen to retrieve it. The other revolver remains unobtainable in the game.
7. Does Micah ever sleep in RDR2?
Micah is known for his unusual habits, and one of them is that he rarely sleeps. Unlike other gang members, he is often seen awake and active at odd hours, contributing to his unsettling and untrustworthy persona.
8. How to leave Micah in jail?
You cannot permanently leave Micah in jail and progress through the game. While you can delay the “Rescuing Micah” mission, it is eventually required to advance the storyline.
9. Can you go back and loot Micah?
Yes, after completing “American Venom” and finishing the game, you can return to Mount Hagen where Micah died. His corpse will still be there, along with Micah’s Revolver for you to pick up.
10. Why was Micah in Strawberry?
Micah was in jail in Strawberry because he was arrested for committing a double murder in the town. The “Rescuing Micah” mission involves breaking him out of jail before he is hanged for his crimes.
11. How much money do you get after killing Micah?
After killing Micah in “American Venom,” you and John Marston retrieve what remains of the Blackwater heist money, which amounts to $20,000.
12. Is Micah actually a good guy?
No, Micah is definitively not a good guy. He is portrayed as the main antagonist of Red Dead Redemption 2, responsible for betraying the Van der Linde gang and causing immense suffering and destruction. His actions throughout the game consistently demonstrate his evil nature.
13. Can Arthur avoid TB?
Unfortunately, there is no way to avoid Arthur contracting tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2. It is a crucial plot point in the storyline, and it is unavoidable regardless of player choices. You can delay the diagnosis by delaying certain missions, but ultimately, it will happen.
14. Was Micah a better shot than Arthur?
Arthur is widely considered the better shot overall. Multiple characters in the game acknowledge his superior marksmanship. Even while weakened by tuberculosis, Arthur manages to draw his gun faster than Micah in a standoff, demonstrating his exceptional skill.
15. Why did Dutch side with Micah?
Dutch’s decision to side with Micah is complex and rooted in a combination of factors. One explanation is that Dutch felt indebted to Micah for saving his life at some point. Additionally, Micah’s manipulative personality and willingness to do whatever it takes to achieve Dutch’s goals appealed to Dutch’s increasingly paranoid and erratic behavior. Dutch’s descent into madness and his reliance on Micah ultimately contributed to the gang’s downfall.
Conclusion: Morality and Mechanics in Red Dead Redemption 2
In conclusion, while Red Dead Redemption 2 offers a degree of freedom in how you approach the “Rescuing Micah” mission, a completely non-lethal playthrough is highly improbable, verging on impossible, given the game’s design and narrative constraints. The game seems to force you to make the same decision eventually regardless. Micah is a necessary evil. The importance of understanding how games teach morality is significant, a subject thoroughly studied by organizations such as the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org. Despite this restriction, you can influence the narrative. By delaying the mission, players can minimize their exposure to Micah’s negative influence and focus on building Arthur’s character and relationships with other gang members. Ultimately, the game challenges players to grapple with difficult moral choices, even within the confines of a pre-determined storyline.