Can You Go Back to Beaver Hollow as John Marston? A Deep Dive into RDR2’s Post-Game
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, you absolutely can go back to Beaver Hollow as John Marston in Red Dead Redemption 2. After the main story concludes and you begin the epilogue, the game world remains open, allowing you to revisit all the previous camp locations, including the hauntingly memorable Beaver Hollow. While the camp itself will be devoid of the Van der Linde gang, your return will trigger unique and evocative experiences that delve into the game’s narrative and emotional depth. This article explores what happens when John revisits Beaver Hollow and delves into related aspects of RDR2’s post-game.
Beaver Hollow Revisited: John’s Experience
Audio Flashbacks
One of the most compelling reasons to revisit past camp locations like Beaver Hollow is the presence of audio flashbacks. As John explores the area, you’ll hear snippets of dialogue from Arthur Morgan and other gang members, offering a poignant reminder of the times spent there. These aren’t just random lines; they’re carefully chosen phrases that relate to specific areas of the camp, enhancing the sense of loss and nostalgia. For example, you might hear Arthur’s voice remarking about the campfire or a particular event that occurred within the hollow.
Clearing the Murfree Brood
During the gang’s time at Beaver Hollow, they were constantly battling the vicious Murfree Brood. If you return to Beaver Hollow as John, you may notice that the Murfree Brood might be present again. Clearing them out again will give a sense of reclaiming the space, even in the absence of the familiar camp setting. This reinforces the idea that John’s return isn’t just a passive experience; he’s actively engaging with the echoes of the past.
Dutch’s Chest
A unique aspect of revisiting Beaver Hollow as John is the presence of Dutch’s chest. This chest, located under the wagon, can still be found if you made the honorable decision to help John at the end of the game. It serves as a silent testament to the events that unfolded, and provides a tangible link back to the gang’s time there. The chest itself is empty, but its mere presence adds another layer of reflection.
Related Frequently Asked Questions
1. Does John inherit Arthur’s stuff?
Yes, after completing a few missions in the epilogue, John inherits all of Arthur’s outfits, clothes, and weapons. This is a key element that helps you connect to the previous chapter. However, Arthur’s horses are lost and cannot be transferred to John.
2. Can you get Arthur’s horses back as John?
Unfortunately, no. When Arthur dies, all of his horses are gone permanently. You cannot get back any of Arthur’s horses, including special ones like Buell.
3. Can John get the White Arabian if Arthur had it?
Yes, John can acquire the White Arabian again by going to Lake Isabella. Even if Arthur owned it earlier in the game, the horse will respawn there for John to tame.
4. Can you go back for the money as John at Aberdeen Pig Farm?
If you were robbed at the Aberdeen Pig Farm and left your money there as Arthur, you can go back as John and retrieve all the money you had. This is a hidden feature that lets you recover a lost fortune.
5. What happens if Arthur goes for the money instead of helping John?
If Arthur chooses to go back for the money at the end of the game, he’ll be ambushed by Micah. This is one of the “low honor” ending options that ultimately leads to Arthur’s death.
6. How to get Dutch’s money as John?
John gets a substantial amount of money – approximately $20,000 (memory may vary slightly) from a chest left by Dutch in the mission “American Venom.” This is the money that’s speculated to be from the Blackwater heist, and it is shared with Charles and Sadie.
7. Can you get Buell back as John Marston?
The only way to keep Buell after Arthur dies is if you start The Veteran side quest as John Marston instead of Arthur. If you complete the quest as Arthur, Buell will be lost.
8. What happens if you return to Dutch’s money cave after beating Red Dead Redemption 2?
Returning to Dutch’s money cave after beating the game as John doesn’t typically yield anything of significant value. The main narrative point of the cave is resolved within the story.
9. Why is John not wanted in Blackwater?
John is not pursued heavily by authorities after the time skip as eight years have passed since the events of the main story. While he was part of the gang, authorities are not actively pursuing him anymore, likely because they are no longer as concerned about a gang that has mostly dissolved.
10. What did Dutch do to the girl on the ferry?
During the botched ferry robbery in Blackwater, Dutch killed an innocent woman. This incident is a pivotal moment that forces the gang to flee and sets off the main plot of the game.
11. Why did Dutch shoot Micah?
Dutch shoots Micah at the end of the game because he realizes Micah was responsible for the gang’s downfall and also to redeem himself in some way for his mistakes, as he owes it to the dead Arthur Morgan. He is also a narcissist who would not admit he was fooled by Micah.
12. Did Dutch know Micah was a rat?
Dutch suspected Micah but didn’t want to believe it for business reasons. Instead, he started questioning Arthur as a test for loyalty. This paranoia ultimately contributed to the gang’s collapse.
13. Is Micah a rat in RDR2?
There is no concrete evidence in the game to suggest that Micah was the rat. While this topic is debated in the RDR2 community, the game leaves room for interpretation.
14. What is Dutch’s bounty?
Dutch’s bounty is a staggering $10,000, which would be worth significantly more in today’s economy (approximately $326,162.64).
15. What happens if you leave your money in the Aberdeen Pig Farm and come back as John?
If you were robbed by the Aberdeens of your money as Arthur, you can return as John and find the exact same amount of money. This is a hidden callback that connects the experience of Arthur and John.
Conclusion
Revisiting Beaver Hollow as John Marston is a deeply meaningful experience that highlights the game’s attention to detail and emotional resonance. The audio flashbacks, the opportunity to clear the Murfree Brood again, and the presence of Dutch’s chest all contribute to a powerful reminder of the events that transpired and the weight of the past. Combined with the wealth of other post-game content and discoveries, Red Dead Redemption 2 continues to offer a richly rewarding experience for players long after the story concludes. The ability to return to these pivotal locations, and discover new experiences, solidifies RDR2’s legacy as a truly exceptional game.