Table of Contents

Can You Legendary Resist a Counterspell? Unraveling the Magic

Quick answer

This page answers Can you legendary resist a counterspell? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

No, you cannot use Legendary Resistance against a Counterspell in the standard rules of Dungeons and Dragons 5th Edition. Counterspell requires an Ability Check, not a Saving Throw. Legendary Resistance specifically allows a creature to succeed on a failed saving throw. Since Counterspell doesn’t force a save, Legendary Resistance cannot be applied. However, some homebrew rules may change this interaction.

Understanding Counterspell and Legendary Resistance Mechanics

Let’s delve into the core mechanics of both Counterspell and Legendary Resistance to understand why they interact (or rather, don’t interact) the way they do. Misunderstanding the interaction of these spells can cause lots of confusion at the table, which is something that any dungeon master would prefer to avoid.

Counterspell: Nullifying Magic

Counterspell is a 3rd-level spell with the power to disrupt another creature’s spellcasting. When a creature within 60 feet casts a spell, you can use your reaction to attempt to counter it. Critically, it requires an Intelligence (Arcana) check, not a saving throw. The DC of this check is 10 + the spell’s level being countered. If the check succeeds, the target’s spell fails, wasting their spell slot.

The key here is the ability check. Ability checks rely on a character’s aptitude and skills, modified by a d20 roll. There is no saving throw involved on the casting creatures behalf. Counterspell doesn’t inherently target the creature casting the spell, it targets the spell itself.

Legendary Resistance: A Boss’s Lifeline

Legendary Resistance is a feature available to many powerful monsters and creatures, often bosses in D&D campaigns. It allows the monster to choose to automatically succeed on a saving throw that it would otherwise fail. A creature typically has a limited number of uses of this feature per day, usually 3.

Saving throws are different from ability checks. A saving throw is a roll made by a creature to resist an effect. This will normally be to avoid the effect of a spell, to resist being moved, or to resist being frightened. These saves are based around the six main ability scores; Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma. For example, a dragon may be forced to make a Dexterity saving throw to avoid the effect of a fireball spell.

The Disconnect: Ability Checks vs. Saving Throws

Legendary Resistance is only triggered by failed saving throws. Since Counterspell invokes an ability check from the counterspeller and doesn’t force a saving throw on the caster, Legendary Resistance is irrelevant. The monster has no save to automatically succeed on when faced with a Counterspell.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Counterspell and Legendary Resistance

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the intricacies of Counterspell, Legendary Resistance, and related game mechanics:

What can Legendary Resistance be used on?

Legendary Resistance allows a monster to automatically succeed on a failed saving throw. This includes saves against spells, effects, and conditions like being charmed, frightened, paralyzed, or banished. Legendary Resistance is an essential part of many of the powerful boss characters in D&D 5e.
Can a legendary action be counterspelled?

No, a legendary action itself cannot be directly counterspelled. However, if a legendary action involves casting a spell, that spell can be targeted by Counterspell. The same logic applies to stopping their innate spellcasting.
What is the new Counterspell rule?

There is no “new” Counterspell rule in the core rules of D&D 5e, but some DMs use homebrew variations. Some of these include the target making a Constitution Saving Throw or Counterspell wasting the spell slot but not preventing the spell, only delaying it. Make sure to discuss with your DM if they make any changes to the vanilla version of a spell!
Can a stunned creature use legendary resistance?

Yes, a stunned creature can use Legendary Resistance if they are forced to make a saving throw. Being stunned prevents a creature from taking actions and reactions, but Legendary Resistance doesn’t require either.
How many times can legendary resistance be used?

A creature with Legendary Resistance typically has three uses per day. The creature expends a use whenever they choose to automatically succeed on a failed saving throw.
Can you use legendary resistance while paralyzed?

Yes, you can use Legendary Resistance while paralyzed. Paralysis causes automatic failures on Strength and Dexterity saving throws. Legendary Resistance allows you to turn that automatic failure into a success.
How do you beat Counterspell?

There are multiple strategies:
- Baiting: Force the opponent to use their Counterspell on a less important spell.
- Outnumbering: Cast multiple spells to overwhelm their reaction.
- Strategic Positioning: Cast spells from beyond the 60-foot range.
- Silence: Use effects that prevent speech or spellcasting.
- Counterspell: Use Counterspell on the Counterspell!
Can you counterspell twice?

No. A character only gets one reaction per round. Counterspelling the original spell uses the reaction, preventing a second Counterspell on the countering Counterspell.
What is legendary resistance 5e intended for?

Legendary Resistance is intended to give DMs control over the outcomes of critical saving throws for important monsters. It prevents powerful effects, like banishment or instant death, from prematurely ending an encounter.
Does Shapechange give you legendary actions?

No. Shapechange does not grant you legendary actions or lair actions. You gain the physical statistics of the new form but not its special actions or features like Legendary Resistance.
Can you use a legendary action to dash?

Some monsters have a legendary action that allows them to move, often a dash or similar effect. This is frequently seen with monsters that have low innate mobility.
Can you use legendary resistance on scrying?

Yes. If a creature fails its Wisdom saving throw against the Scrying spell, it can expend a use of Legendary Resistance to automatically succeed on the save and avoid being scryed upon.
How many legendary actions should a boss have?

A boss typically has three legendary actions that it can use at the end of another creature’s turn. These actions allow the boss to remain active and influential even when it’s not their turn.
Can I counterspell a counterspell on my spell?

Yes, you can counterspell a counterspell that is targeting your spell. It would require you to use your reaction to cast Counterspell. However, you cannot counterspell a counterspell on a spell you are currently casting.
Can Silvery Barbs bypass legendary resistance?

No, Silvery Barbs cannot bypass Legendary Resistance. Legendary Resistance turns a failed saving throw into a success, regardless of any other effects.

Strategic Implications for Players and DMs

Understanding the nuances of Counterspell and Legendary Resistance is crucial for both players and Dungeon Masters.

For Players: Knowing that Counterspell doesn’t trigger Legendary Resistance allows for more strategic spellcasting. Players can focus on spells that target other vulnerabilities, such as abilities that require attack rolls rather than saving throws, or spells that inflict conditions that hinder a creature’s actions. Players should also be aware of their opponents reaction economy, as it can only use one per round.
For DMs: DMs can use Legendary Resistance to control the flow of combat and prevent a single spell from derailing a carefully planned encounter. Using it intelligently can create challenging and memorable boss battles. DMs should remember that Legendary Resistance is there to make the encounter more fun, not more frustrating.

Further Exploration of Game Mechanics

D&D’s rules are intricate, and understanding them often requires further exploration. Resources like the Player’s Handbook, Dungeon Master’s Guide, and official errata are valuable tools. Also, communities dedicated to D&D strategy and rules discussions can offer insights and clarifications. The Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) offers a wealth of information on the educational aspects of gaming and how game mechanics influence learning.

Mastering the Magic

While Legendary Resistance can’t directly stop Counterspell, understanding the limits and possibilities of both spells allows for strategic gameplay and exciting encounters. By knowing the rules and leveraging creative tactics, players and DMs can make the most of their D&D adventures.