Can You Ninjutsu the Same Creature Twice? A Deep Dive into Magic’s Shadowy Arts

▶

Yes, you can Ninjutsu the same creature multiple times, but not quite in the way you might initially think. The key is understanding that Ninjutsu doesn’t directly target a creature on the battlefield for repeated transformations. Instead, it’s a hand-based ability that swaps an unblocked attacking creature with a Ninja creature card from your hand. Therefore, to “ninjutsu” what was originally the same creature twice, that creature must return to your hand (usually as the result of a successful Ninjutsu activation) and then be put onto the battlefield again, typically by casting it normally or using another ability. Then, if it attacks and goes unblocked once more, only then can you use Ninjutsu on it again.

This nuanced understanding unlocks a fascinating layer of strategic depth when playing with Ninjas in Magic: The Gathering. Let’s delve deeper into the intricacies and explore the numerous related questions that often arise surrounding this elusive mechanic.

Understanding the Ninjutsu Ability

The Ninjutsu ability in Magic: The Gathering is a fascinating mechanic that allows you to deploy Ninja creatures onto the battlefield in a sneaky and unexpected manner. It’s an ability that lives in your hand and triggers when you have an unblocked attacking creature.

How Ninjutsu Works

The core mechanic is simple yet powerful:

1. You have an attacking creature that has gone unblocked.
2. You have a Ninja creature card in your hand with the Ninjutsu ability.
3. You pay the Ninjutsu cost of the Ninja creature card.
4. You reveal the Ninja creature card from your hand.
5. You return the unblocked attacking creature to its owner’s hand.
6. You put the Ninja creature card onto the battlefield, attacking the same player or planeswalker that the original creature was attacking.

It’s vital to remember that the original attacking creature returns to your hand as a part of the cost of activating the ability, which is the main reason a creature would be eligible to be “ninjutsued” again. Also, Ninjutsu is not casting. It’s an ability, so counterspell spells won’t interact with the process directly (they can, however, target abilities that return creatures to the battlefield if that’s how you replay the creature).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Ninjutsu

These FAQs are designed to cover the common questions players have about Ninjutsu, providing a comprehensive guide to this complex mechanic.

1. Can you Ninjutsu multiple times in a single combat phase? Yes, absolutely! If you have multiple unblocked attacking creatures and sufficient mana, you can activate the Ninjutsu ability of different Ninja creatures in your hand for each unblocked creature. Imagine having three unblocked attackers and three Ninja cards in hand – you could potentially deploy all three Ninjas in a single combat phase.

2. Is Ninjutsu an alternate casting cost? No, Ninjutsu is not an alternate casting cost. It’s an ability that puts a creature onto the battlefield directly from your hand by paying a cost and returning an unblocked attacking creature to your hand. This distinction is crucial because effects that interact with casting spells won’t affect the Ninjutsu ability.

3. Can my opponent respond to my Ninjutsu ability? Yes, they can! While they can’t stop you from returning your creature to your hand (that’s part of the cost of the ability and can’t be responded to), once the Ninjutsu ability is activated and on the stack, your opponent has a chance to respond before the Ninja enters the battlefield. They could use instant-speed removal on your initial unblocked attacker in response to the ability.

4. Can I use Ninjutsu at instant speed? Technically, yes. You can activate the Ninjutsu ability any time you have priority, which is generally whenever you could cast an instant spell. This means you can wait until the last possible moment during the combat phase to deploy your Ninja, maximizing surprise and minimizing the chance for your opponent to react preemptively.

5. Does Ninjutsu trigger “when a creature enters the battlefield” effects? Yes, it does. Because the Ninja is entering the battlefield, any triggered abilities that look for creatures entering the battlefield will trigger accordingly. This can be used to your advantage with cards that benefit from new creatures arriving.

6. Does Ninjutsu get around commander tax? No, the Ninjutsu ability does not get around the commander tax if the card you are casting is your commander. However, if you have a different Ninja and bring it into play from your command zone using Ninjutsu, you will have to pay the extra costs.

7. Can I Ninjutsu my commander? Yes, you absolutely can! If your commander is a Ninja creature with a Ninjutsu ability, you can use that ability to bring it onto the battlefield. This is a particularly strong strategy, as it allows you to avoid paying the commander tax initially and deploy your commander at a more opportune moment.

8. Does Ninjutsu count as attacking? Yes and no. The Ninja put onto the battlefield with Ninjutsu is considered an attacking creature, and is attacking the same player or planeswalker the original creature was attacking. However, the Ninjutsu ability itself doesn’t count as declaring an attacker. The key here is that the Ninja is entering the battlefield already designated as an attacker.

9. If a creature has already dealt combat damage, can I Ninjutsu it before the end of combat? Yes, you can. A creature can be Ninjutsued after it has dealt combat damage, as long as it is unblocked at the time you activate the ability. This can be a useful tactic to replace a creature that has served its purpose with a more valuable one, or to deploy a creature that can provide additional utility.

10. Can I Ninjutsu a creature that has First Strike or Double Strike? Yes, you can activate the Ninjutsu ability during the first-strike combat damage step if a creature with First Strike or Double Strike attacks and is unblocked.

11. If I Ninjutsu in a creature with Double Strike, when does it deal combat damage? The Ninja with Double Strike will deal combat damage during both the first combat damage step and the regular combat damage step, effectively dealing twice as much damage.

12. Does Deathtouch work with Ninjutsu? Absolutely! If you Ninjutsu in a creature with Deathtouch, any damage it deals will be lethal to the creature it damages. This can be a devastating combination, allowing you to eliminate key threats with ease.

13. What happens if I Ninjutsu a creature that was enchanted or equipped? When the original attacking creature returns to your hand, any Auras or Equipment attached to it will remain on the battlefield, unattached. They will then be put into their owner’s graveyard, unless the card has some other ability.

14. Can I use Ninjutsu if my opponent has a creature with Defender? The Defender ability only prevents a creature from being declared as an attacker. It does not affect the Ninjutsu ability. If you have a creature with Defender already attacking and unblocked (perhaps due to another effect), you can use Ninjutsu to replace it with a Ninja creature from your hand.

15. Are there infinite Ninjutsu combos? Yes, there are! Combos involving cards like Cloud of Faeries, Palinchron, Great Whale, and Satoru Umezawa can generate infinite mana during combat, enabling you to activate the Ninjutsu ability an infinite number of times. This can lead to game-winning scenarios, as you can repeatedly deploy and reuse Ninja creatures with powerful enter-the-battlefield effects. The possibilities here are endless, leading to a fun an engaging game. If you’re interested in learning more about the intersection of games and learning, check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org to explore innovative approaches to education through gaming.

Mastering the Art of Ninjutsu

The Ninjutsu ability is a powerful tool in Magic: The Gathering, offering strategic depth and allowing for surprise attacks. Understanding its nuances, including the ability to technically “ninjutsu” the same creature multiple times in succession (after returning it to your hand), is crucial for mastering this mechanic. By strategically using Ninjutsu, you can outmaneuver your opponents and secure victory.