Can You Put Books in a Grindstone in Minecraft? Unveiling the Enchanting Truth
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is no, you cannot directly put books into a grindstone to extract enchantments in vanilla Minecraft. Grindstones are primarily used for repairing items, removing enchantments (except curses), and serving as a villager job site block. While that initial statement may seem definitive, the world of Minecraft is one of nuances and alternative solutions. Let’s delve deeper into how enchantments work with grindstones and explore your options.
The Grindstone’s Role in Enchanting
The grindstone is a valuable tool, but its enchanting-related functionality is mostly destructive. When you place an enchanted item (tool, weapon, or armor) into the grindstone, it removes the enchantments. The item is then returned in a non-enchanted state, and you receive a small amount of experience points based on the enchantments that were removed. Crucially, the enchantments are lost; they are not transferred to a book or any other item. The grindstone does not create enchanted books.
Repairing and Removing Enchantments: A Delicate Balance
A key function of the grindstone is repairing items. By placing two identical items (e.g., two iron swords) into the input slots, the grindstone combines them, resulting in a single item with increased durability. This repaired item also loses any enchantments it had. This creates a strategic choice: Do you want a fully repaired item without enchantments, or do you want to keep the enchantments and repair the item using an anvil, which costs experience points?
Alternative Methods for Enchantment Manipulation
Since grindstones don’t allow for the transfer of enchantments to books, you’ll need to explore other methods if you’re looking to move enchantments around or preserve them:
- Enchanting Table: The standard method for applying enchantments. By using lapis lazuli and experience levels, you can randomly enchant items placed in the enchanting table. Note that you don’t get to pick the specific enchantment. The Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) recognizes the educational potential of Minecraft and its complex systems like enchanting, which can teach players about resource management, probability, and strategic planning.
- Anvil: Anvils are critical for combining enchanted items or applying enchanted books to items. If you have an enchanted book (obtained through fishing, trading, or loot), you can use an anvil to transfer the enchantment to a suitable item. You can also combine two items of the same type to merge their enchantments, if the enchantments are compatible.
- Trading with Villagers: Villager trading is a reliable source of enchanted books. Librarian villagers are known to offer a wide variety of enchanted books in exchange for emeralds. This is a great way to target specific enchantments that you need.
- Fishing: While less reliable than trading, fishing can yield enchanted books as treasure. You’ll need a fishing rod with the Luck of the Sea enchantment to increase your chances of finding treasure items.
The Allure of Mending
The mention of Mending in the source article highlights a particularly sought-after enchantment. Mending is unique because it uses experience orbs collected by the player to repair the enchanted item. This makes it incredibly valuable for tools and armor that you use frequently.
Since Mending cannot be obtained directly from an enchanting table, you must rely on:
- Fishing: As mentioned above, fishing is one way to acquire Mending books.
- Trading with Villagers: Librarian villagers may offer Mending books.
- Looting Structures: Mending books can sometimes be found as loot in chests within various structures, such as dungeons, mineshafts, and temples.
FAQs: Enchanting and Grindstones Demystified
Here are some frequently asked questions that address common misconceptions and provide further clarification on the mechanics of enchanting and grindstones in Minecraft:
1. Can I use a grindstone to duplicate enchantments?
No, grindstones cannot be used to duplicate enchantments. The enchantment is removed entirely when an item is placed in the grindstone.
2. If I put an enchanted item in a grindstone, will I get the enchanted book back?
No, you will not receive an enchanted book. The grindstone destroys the enchantment and provides a small amount of experience.
3. Does the grindstone remove curses?
Yes, a grindstone removes enchantments from items, except for curses. Curses, such as Curse of Binding or Curse of Vanishing, will remain on the item even after using the grindstone.
4. Can I put two different items in a grindstone to combine their enchantments?
No, you can only put one item at a time into a grindstone. You cannot combine enchantments using a grindstone. Use an anvil for that.
5. Is using a grindstone better than an anvil for repairing items?
It depends on your priorities. A grindstone is free and repairs items, but it removes enchantments. An anvil costs experience but allows you to retain enchantments and even add new ones.
6. How many bookshelves do I need for level 30 enchantments?
You need 15 bookshelves placed around the enchanting table to reach the highest enchantment levels.
7. What is the ideal placement of bookshelves around an enchanting table?
The ideal placement is a 5×5 square with the enchanting table in the middle, leaving a one-block gap between the table and the bookshelves.
8. Can I put anything between the bookshelves and the enchanting table?
No, you should not place any blocks (torches, carpets, etc.) between the bookshelves and the enchanting table. This will reduce the effectiveness of the bookshelves.
9. Does adding more than 15 bookshelves improve enchantments?
No, 15 bookshelves is the maximum needed for level 30 enchantments. Adding more bookshelves will not provide any additional benefit.
10. What is the best way to get Mending enchantments?
The best ways to get Mending enchantments are through fishing, trading with librarian villagers, or looting structures. Mending cannot be obtained directly from an enchanting table.
11. Can I disenchant an item and learn the enchantment?
No, you cannot “learn” an enchantment by disenchanting an item. The enchantment is simply removed and lost.
12. What happens if I put an enchanted book in a grindstone?
Putting an enchanted book into a grindstone will simply destroy the book and not provide any benefit. It will not return any experience.
13. Why does a grindstone have two input slots?
The two input slots are for repairing items by combining two of the same type. One item is sacrificed to repair the other.
14. Can I use a grindstone to remove a specific enchantment from an item?
No, a grindstone removes all enchantments from an item (except curses). You cannot target a specific enchantment for removal.
15. What are the best enchantments to have on tools and armor?
The best enchantments vary depending on your playstyle and the specific tool or armor. However, some highly desirable enchantments include:
- Tools: Efficiency, Fortune/Silk Touch (depending on the resource), Unbreaking, Mending.
- Armor: Protection (all types), Unbreaking, Mending, Thorns.
- Weapons: Sharpness, Smite/Bane of Arthropods (depending on the target), Unbreaking, Mending.
Final Thoughts
While the grindstone serves a valuable purpose in repairing items and removing unwanted enchantments, it’s not a tool for transferring or duplicating enchantments. To manipulate enchantments effectively, focus on utilizing enchanting tables, anvils, villager trading, and fishing. Mastering these methods will give you greater control over your gear and enhance your Minecraft experience. Remember the importance of learning and adapting in Minecraft, as highlighted by the Games Learning Society.