The Fate of Miriel: Can You Revive Pope Turtle in Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question on many Tarnished minds, especially those with a penchant for accidentally (or intentionally) smiting helpful NPCs: Can you revive Pope Turtle, also known as Miriel, Pastor of Vows, in Elden Ring? The unfortunate truth is a resounding no. Once you’ve struck down this gentle giant, there’s no turning back. Celestial Dew, absolution at the Church of Vows, console commands – none of it will bring Miriel back from the great beyond. You’re stuck with the bell bearing and a lingering sense of guilt.
The Consequences of Turtleicide
Killing Miriel isn’t just a moral quandary; it has gameplay consequences. While you gain Miriel’s Bell Bearing, allowing you to purchase their sorceries and incantations from the Twin Maiden Husks at the Roundtable Hold, you lose their invaluable lore and friendly presence. Miriel serves as a key source of information regarding the history of the Elden Ring, the Shattering, and the motivations of various characters. Their absence leaves a void in the narrative experience.
Why Can’t Miriel Be Revived?
Elden Ring’s mechanics for NPC revival are selective and often tied to specific questlines or character conditions. Absolution, gained by using Celestial Dew at the Church of Vows, primarily resets NPC hostility. It won’t resurrect NPCs who have been killed outright. Miriel’s death is treated as a definitive event.
The Allure and Tragedy of Miriel
Miriel, often affectionately dubbed “Turtle Pope” by the community, represents a unique aspect of Elden Ring’s design. They offer guidance, lore, and a safe haven for learning about magic. Their peaceful nature and willingness to share knowledge make them a beloved figure. This is why killing them carries such a heavy weight.
The Guilt Trip: More Than Just a Bell Bearing
It is not about the lost access to spells or any other items, the reason why killing Miriel carries so much weight is because Miriel is defenseless and Miriel is kind. The game is designed to make you feel awful about committing such an act.
Lessons Learned: NPC Interactions in Elden Ring
Miriel’s fate serves as a cautionary tale about the weight of player choice in Elden Ring. While the game offers freedom to interact with the world and its inhabitants as you see fit, there are often irreversible consequences. Consider the value of each NPC interaction, and be mindful of the potential ramifications of your actions.
FAQs About NPC Revival and Miriel’s Fate
1. Can Celestial Dew revive dead NPCs?
No. Celestial Dew and absolution at the Church of Vows primarily reset NPC hostility. They don’t bring dead NPCs back to life.
2. Does absolution revive dead NPCs?
No. Absolution restores your relationship with NPCs you’ve angered, allowing you to resume quests or trade with them. It doesn’t resurrect deceased characters. The rare cases where NPCs like Sellen appear to be revived are tied to specific quest mechanics.
3. What happens if you kill Pope Turtle in Elden Ring?
You receive Miriel’s Bell Bearing, which allows you to purchase their sorceries and incantations from the Twin Maiden Husks at the Roundtable Hold. You also acquire a small amount of turtleneck meat. However, you lose access to Miriel’s lore and their friendly presence, and the gaming community would mock you endlessly.
4. How do you revive a dead NPC in Elden Ring? (Generally)
Generally, you cannot revive dead NPCs in Elden Ring through in-game mechanics like Celestial Dew or absolution. Certain questlines might have specific mechanisms that appear to revive a character, but these are scripted events rather than general revival methods. PC players might attempt console commands, but this is outside the intended game experience.
5. Where is the Church of Vows?
The Church of Vows is located on the eastern side of Liurnia of the Lakes. You can reach it via a teleporter in the Raya Lucaria Academy or by traversing the landscape.
6. What does Celestial Dew do?
Celestial Dew is used at the Church of Vows to request absolution, resetting the hostility of NPCs you’ve angered.
7. Can you undo killing an NPC in Elden Ring?
With very rare exceptions, no. Once an NPC is dead, they are dead for the rest of the playthrough. Absolution only resolves hostility, not death.
8. What is the sin of absolution in Elden Ring?
The “sin” isn’t a formal mechanic but refers to any action that angers an NPC, preventing you from interacting with them normally. Absolution allows you to restore that relationship.
9. What do you get for killing Turtle Pope?
Miriel’s Bell Bearing and some turtleneck meat. Mostly, you get a really bad feeling and the shame from the collective shunning of the Elden Ring community.
10. Where did Pope Turtle go?
If you haven’t killed them, Miriel, Pastor of Vows is located at the Church of Vows in eastern Liurnia of the Lakes.
11. Can you revive Boc?
No. Once Boc is killed, he is permanently gone. Using Celestial Dew will not bring him back. This is true whether you kill him yourself or he dies after giving him a Larval Tear.
12. How do you revive Sellen?
Reviving Sellen is a complex process tied to her specific questline. It involves progressing her quest, siding with either her or Jerren, and interacting with her physical form. However, simply praying at the Church of Vows may bring her back to normal.
13. Is Elden Ring in purgatory?
While the Lands Between are a fantastical realm, the game’s themes of corruption, death, and rebirth evoke a sense of purgatory. The shattered Elden Ring and the struggles of the characters contribute to this atmosphere.
14. Do NPCs forgive you in Elden Ring?
Yes, most hostile NPCs can “forgive” you after using Celestial Dew at the Church of Vows and requesting absolution. This allows you to resume their questlines or services.
15. What happens if I give Boc a Larval Tear?
Giving Boc a Larval Tear will irreversibly doom him to death. He moves to Rennala, Queen of the Full Moon, to be reborn as a human, but ultimately dies in the attempt.
The Weight of Choice: Living with Your Decisions
Elden Ring, like many games, presents players with moral choices that have lasting consequences. The inability to revive Miriel serves as a stark reminder that actions have repercussions. The guilt, the loss of lore, and the missed opportunity for further interactions are all part of the game’s design, encouraging players to consider their choices carefully. It reinforces the idea that the world of Elden Ring is not a playground for consequence-free mayhem.
Further Exploration of Game Design and Learning
The intricate design of Elden Ring and its consequences provides a rich environment for exploring concepts related to game design, player agency, and learning. To delve deeper into these topics, consider exploring the resources offered by the Games Learning Society, an organization dedicated to understanding and advancing the field of games-based learning. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org for more information.