Table of Contents

Can You Spare Dettlaff? A Deep Dive into Morality in The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine

Quick answer

This page answers Can you spare Detlaff? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

Yes, you can spare Dettlaff in The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine, but it comes at a significant cost. Dettlaff only lives if you allow him to kill Syanna and then choose not to fight him afterward. This path leads to Geralt being imprisoned. This is a crucial decision with serious consequences for Anna Henrietta, Syanna, and Geralt himself. The morality of this choice is highly debated, and it is essential to understand all the factors involved before making this critical decision.

Understanding the Dettlaff Dilemma

The Blood and Wine expansion for The Witcher 3 presents players with a classic moral quandary. Dettlaff van der Eretein, a powerful higher vampire, becomes embroiled in a conspiracy involving Syanna, Anna Henrietta’s estranged sister. Dettlaff is forced to kill on Syanna’s orders. Understanding the intricacies of their relationship is paramount to making an informed decision about Dettlaff’s fate.

The narrative masterfully weaves together elements of revenge, manipulation, and ultimately, redemption. As Geralt, you must navigate these turbulent waters, weighing the lives of powerful individuals against the backdrop of Toussaint’s political intrigue. Each choice carries significant weight, leading to drastically different endings that challenge the player’s understanding of justice and mercy.

Exploring the Consequences

Choosing to spare Dettlaff inevitably leads to Syanna’s death. When you let Dettlaff kill Syanna, then choose to not fight Dettlaff, Geralt winds up in prison. This outcome leaves Anna Henrietta heartbroken and potentially furious at Geralt for his failure to protect her sister and to bring the killer to justice.

The alternative is to pursue and kill Dettlaff, which opens up two primary ending possibilities: one where both Anna Henrietta and Syanna reconcile and survive, and another where both sisters die. Each ending carries its own set of moral implications, and the “best” outcome is subjective, heavily dependent on the player’s values and perspective. The Games Learning Society provides resources to help players explore narrative choices in video games. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org for more information.

Achieving the “Good” Ending

The path to saving both sisters is arguably the most complex, requiring specific choices throughout the questline. It involves:

Finding Syanna: During ‘The Night of the Long Fangs,’ focus on finding Syanna.
Entering the Land of Fables: Complete the quest ‘Beyond Hill and Dale.’
Acquiring the Ribbon: Crucially, you must obtain the magical ribbon from the Little Flint Girl in the Land of Fables. This ribbon protects Syanna from Dettlaff’s vampire powers.
The Unseen Elder: Instead of immediately finding Syanna, players can choose to visit the Unseen Elder first, providing additional story content.
The Summit: Confronting Syanna about her motives and actions is necessary to set the stage for reconciliation.
Reconciliation: When the ceremony starts, claiming that Syanna is guilty but that they should be shown mercy, will allow the two sisters to finally put the past behind them.
Killing Dettlaff: Even with the ribbon, Dettlaff must still be defeated to ensure the sisters’ safety and bring closure to the events in Toussaint.

The Dangers of Ignoring the Ribbon

Choosing not to obtain the ribbon in ‘Beyond Hill and Dale’ guarantees Syanna’s death at the hands of Dettlaff. While this creates the option to spare Dettlaff, it comes at the cost of Syanna’s life and potential imprisonment for Geralt. If you let Dettlaff kill Syanna, and do not fight Dettlaff, Geralt winds up in prison.

The “Bad” Ending

If Syanna dies during Tesham Mutna at the hands of Dettlaff, then Anna Henrietta will execute Syanna for her crimes. This sets in motion a chain of events leading to a tragic end for both sisters. This dark conclusion underscores the importance of making informed decisions throughout the questline.

Is Sparing Dettlaff the “Right” Choice?

Whether or not sparing Dettlaff is the “right” choice is entirely subjective. Some players argue that Dettlaff, manipulated by Syanna, deserves mercy. They might see him as a victim of circumstance, forced into violence by the actions of others. Others contend that his actions, regardless of the circumstances, warrant punishment. He is still responsible for the deaths he inflicted.

Geralt’s own moral code is often cited in these debates. The Witcher is frequently portrayed as a pragmatist, prioritizing the lesser evil. In this context, some might argue that allowing Dettlaff to escape saves further bloodshed, even if it means sacrificing one life.

Ultimately, the decision rests with the player. The Witcher 3 excels at presenting moral ambiguities, forcing players to confront their own values and beliefs. There is no easy answer, and each choice has its own set of consequences.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some frequently asked questions about Dettlaff and the endings in Blood and Wine:

Is Dettlaff the hardest boss in the game? Dettlaff is often considered one of the toughest bosses in The Witcher 3, especially due to his multiple phases and unpredictable attack patterns.
What level should I be to fight Dettlaff? Dettlaff is recommended for players around level 45 or higher. In New Game Plus, his level can exceed 100.
What is the easiest way to kill Dettlaff? A popular strategy involves using a combination of dodging, rolling, and strong attacks to systematically target his hearts while avoiding his attacks.
Can Regis kill Dettlaff? Regis intervenes and kills Dettlaff for good because only a higher vampire can kill another higher vampire, and Dettlaff’s vampire powers start regenerating him.
How powerful is Dettlaff? Dettlaff is a powerful Higher Vampire with abilities like turning into mist, summoning bats, and immense strength and speed.
What happens if you inform Anna Henrietta about Syanna’s intentions? Informing Anna Henrietta about Syanna’s planned revenge leads to a confrontation where she will send you to Regis, furthering the ‘Be It Ever So Humble’ quest.
Should I tell Anna Henrietta that Syanna is guilty? Yes, claiming Syanna is guilty but deserving of mercy can lead to a reconciliation between the sisters.
What is the “bad” ending in Blood and Wine? The “bad” ending involves both Syanna and Anna Henrietta dying, which occurs if you fail to reconcile them after killing Dettlaff.
What is the Aerondight Sword? The Aerondight is a powerful silver sword obtainable in Blood and Wine by demonstrating the five virtues (compassion, generosity, honor, wisdom, and valor).
What are the virtues needed for the Aerondight Sword? The five virtues are compassion, generosity, honor, wisdom, and valor.
Is it better to save Syanna or find Orianna first? Players who want every bit of extra story content can feed their souls by going to Orianna first, then backtracking to find Syanna rather than seeking out the Unseen Elder when Regis asks Geralt’s plan of action for a final time near the docks.
Can you save Anna Henrietta without killing Dettlaff? No. In order to save Anna Henrietta, Dettlaff has to be killed. Anna and Syanna can either both die or both live. But the only way to get them to both live is to have Syanna meet Detlaff and have given her the ribbon.
What is the hardest monster to kill in The Witcher 3? Opinions vary, but Dettlaff, the Toad Prince, and the Caretaker are often cited as some of the most challenging creatures to defeat.
Is Dettlaff the final boss of Blood and Wine? Dettlaff is one of the final bosses. However, there is one ending in which he isn’t fought.
Is there an advantage of finding Syanna versus going to the Unseen Elder? Instead of immediately finding Syanna, players can choose to visit the Unseen Elder first, providing additional story content.

Deciding Dettlaff’s fate is one of the toughest moral calls The Witcher 3 throws at you. It forces you to think about justice, mercy, and the impact of your choices on the lives of others. Consider your own moral compass and the consequences of each decision to determine the best course of action in this complex and memorable questline. Explore similar games-based learning topics at GamesLearningSociety.org.