Can You Turn In the Serial Killer in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, you absolutely can turn in the serial killer, Edmund Lowry Jr., in Red Dead Redemption 2. After finding the clues and confronting him at his lair, you have the option to hogtie him and transport him to the Sheriff’s office in Valentine. Successfully delivering him alive will trigger a unique scene and a small reward. However, be warned, things rarely go as planned in the Wild West!
The American Dreams Serial Killer Quest: A Deep Dive
The “American Dreams” stranger mission is one of the most chilling and memorable encounters in Red Dead Redemption 2. It involves hunting down a serial killer, Edmund Lowry Jr., by piecing together clues left at gruesome murder scenes scattered across the map. This quest is available fairly early in the game, adding a dark twist to your adventures in the Old West.
Finding the Clues: Piecing Together the Puzzle
The quest begins by discovering the first murder scene. There are three specific locations where you’ll find these disturbing tableaus, each containing a clue to the killer’s identity and whereabouts.
- First Location: South of Valentine, near the railway tracks. Look for a dismembered body arranged with rocks. Examine the head and find a piece of a map.
- Second Location: West of Strawberry, near the edge of the map. This scene is equally gruesome and contains another piece of the map.
- Third Location: Just south of Wallace Station. Completing the map will reveal the location of the killer’s hideout.
Confronting Edmund Lowry Jr. at Lucky’s Cabin
Once you’ve collected all three map pieces, they will combine to reveal the location of Lucky’s Cabin, southwest of Valentine. Upon entering, you’ll find a disturbing scene – a basement filled with the remnants of his victims. Prepare yourself, because Edmund Lowry Jr. will ambush you.
The Choice: Capture or Kill?
After subduing Edmund Lowry Jr., you have a crucial choice: kill him or hogtie him. While killing him on the spot is the easier option, the more rewarding route (in terms of unique experience) is to capture him alive.
Turning Him In at Valentine
If you choose to capture him, carefully hogtie Edmund Lowry Jr. and place him on your horse. Ride him back to the Sheriff’s office in Valentine. Be cautious during the ride, as he may struggle and attempt to escape. Once you arrive, you can hand him over to the Sheriff.
The Reward and the Aftermath
Turning in Edmund Lowry Jr. alive will trigger a cutscene. He’ll initially appear docile, but he quickly reveals his true nature and attacks the Sheriff. You’ll be forced to kill him to save the Sheriff’s life. The reward for capturing (and ultimately killing) him is around $20. While the monetary reward isn’t substantial, the unique experience and the satisfaction of bringing a killer to justice make it worthwhile.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About the RDR2 Serial Killer
1. How much money do you get for turning in the serial killer in RDR2?
The reward for capturing and turning in (and then saving the Sheriff from) Edmund Lowry Jr. is approximately $20. The Sheriff will leave a small money clip on his desk as a thank you.
2. Can you do the serial killer mission as John Marston?
Yes, you can complete the “American Dreams” serial killer mission as John Marston in the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 2. The clues and the killer’s hideout remain accessible, allowing John to experience this chilling side quest. You can check “Stranger Missions with John Marston” series on YouTube to see how it goes.
3. Where is the serial killer’s cabin located in RDR2?
The serial killer’s cabin, known as Lucky’s Cabin, is located southwest of Valentine. If you haven’t discovered it yet, it won’t be named on your map until you get close.
4. Is the “American Dreams” mission the scariest mission in RDR2?
Many players consider the “American Dreams” mission to be one of the creepiest in Red Dead Redemption 2, due to its gruesome nature and the disturbing reveal of the killer’s basement. However, missions like “A Fine Night For It” (the Murfree Brood encounter) and “The Saint Denis Vampire” are also contenders for the title.
5. What is found in the killer’s basement in RDR2?
The basement of Lucky’s Cabin is filled with horrifying evidence of Edmund Lowry Jr.’s crimes. You’ll find murder weapons, dismembered body parts, polished skulls, and other gruesome remains of his victims.
6. Who is the secret killer in RDR2?
The serial killer in Red Dead Redemption 2 is Edmund Lowry Jr. He targets random individuals and leaves their dismembered bodies at various locations, arranged in disturbing displays.
7. Can you kidnap other NPCs in RDR2?
Yes, you can hogtie and “kidnap” other NPCs in Red Dead Redemption 2 using your lasso. However, doing so will be considered a crime and will likely result in a bounty on your head, especially if you are caught by law enforcement or witnesses.
8. How do you get rid of a bounty in RDR2?
The easiest way to get rid of a bounty in Red Dead Redemption 2 is to pay it off at a Post Office. You can also try to avoid law enforcement and wait for the bounty to expire, but this is a riskier approach.
9. Can you visit Arthur’s grave as John Marston?
Yes, you can visit Arthur Morgan’s grave as John Marston after the epilogue. It is located on a hilltop northeast of Bacchus Bridge. The epitaph on the grave will reflect Arthur’s honor level during his playthrough.
10. Can you finish Arthur’s unfinished missions as John?
Yes, John Marston can complete most of the Stranger Missions that Arthur Morgan started, with a few exceptions (such as missions involving Mary Linton). This allows players to experience the full breadth of the game’s content even after Arthur’s death.
11. What is the most profitable activity in RDR2?
There are several ways to make good money in Red Dead Redemption 2. Some of the most profitable activities include completing story missions, robbing trains and stagecoaches, selling horses, and hunting legendary animals. However, remember that some activities come with the risk of attracting unwanted attention from the law.
12. Is it worth it to aim for 100% completion in RDR2?
Achieving 100% completion in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a significant undertaking that requires a substantial time investment. While the in-game rewards aren’t particularly significant, many players find the challenge and sense of accomplishment to be rewarding in itself.
13. What are some things players should avoid doing in RDR2?
Some things players might want to avoid include:
- Ignoring treasure maps
- Skipping Legendary Hunts
- Ignoring bounties
- Forgetting to clean weapons
- Ignoring camp members
14. Can you find the Blackwater money in RDR2?
While you don’t actively “find” the Blackwater money through exploration, John Marston comes across a chest containing a portion of it during the final story mission, “American Venom.” His share is $20,000, more than enough for a fresh start.
15. Who betrayed Arthur in RDR2?
Micah Bell is the primary betrayer in Red Dead Redemption 2. He acted as an informant for the Pinkertons, ultimately leading to the downfall of the Van der Linde gang.
Understanding the intricacies of missions like “American Dreams” and the consequences of your choices, such as capturing or killing the serial killer, adds depth to the Red Dead Redemption 2 experience. Whether you’re chasing justice or simply seeking a unique encounter, this side quest is one you won’t soon forget. For more information on the educational and community aspects of gaming, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.