Can You Upgrade Black Knight Weapons Past 5?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short, definitive answer is no, you cannot upgrade Black Knight weapons past +5. This applies to all Black Knight weapons, including the Black Knight Sword, Black Knight Halberd, Black Knight Greatsword, and Black Knight Greataxe. These powerful weapons, coveted by many players in the Dark Souls series, are categorized as special weapons with unique upgrade paths. This limitation is a fundamental aspect of their design and balancing within the game.
Understanding Special Weapon Upgrades
Twinkling Titanite and Its Limitations
The key factor that dictates the upgrade cap for Black Knight weapons is their reliance on Twinkling Titanite for reinforcement. Unlike standard weapons that use Titanite Shards, Large Titanite Shards, Titanite Chunks, and Titanite Slabs, weapons that require Twinkling Titanite cannot be upgraded beyond +5. This design choice was intentional to balance these powerful weapons, preventing them from becoming excessively dominant in the game.
Think of Twinkling Titanite weapons as having a unique upgrade path. While they may only reach +5, each level is equivalent to approximately two levels on a standard weapon. Thus, a Black Knight weapon at +5 can be considered roughly equivalent to a +10 standard weapon in terms of raw power. This design decision ensures these weapons remain powerful, but are not allowed to outpace standard weapons that are fully upgraded.
The Special Nature of Black Knight Weapons
Black Knight weapons are inherently unique and powerful, often boasting high base damage and unique movesets. Their status as special weapons further signifies that they will not follow the regular upgrade path. The restriction to +5 reflects their pre-tempered strength and potential, meaning that, unlike other weapons, they do not need further tempering. It allows the game to maintain a level of balancing and encourages experimentation with other weapons.
The +5 cap for Black Knight weapons should not be seen as a weakness but as an integral part of their design. They are meant to be formidable from early to mid-game, providing a significant boost in power to players lucky enough to obtain them. While standard weapons have the potential to surpass them at the absolute peak of upgrading, it’s rare that you will achieve the maximum level on standard weapons before your Black Knight reaches the same relative level.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can Black Knight weapons be upgraded using anything other than Twinkling Titanite?
No. Black Knight weapons exclusively use Twinkling Titanite for upgrades. You cannot use any other materials, such as regular Titanite Shards or Chunks, to reinforce them.
2. Are Black Knight weapons considered “end-game” weapons despite only reaching +5?
While they are incredibly powerful and viable throughout the game, they are not explicitly considered “end-game” in the sense that they surpass fully upgraded standard weapons. However, their early-to-mid-game dominance is significant. At +5, they can compete with many late-game weapons up until the very last areas, and have excellent damage output throughout your playthrough.
3. Can I infuse or buff Black Knight weapons?
No. Black Knight weapons cannot be infused with elemental or other buffs, nor can they be buffed with consumables. This is another balancing mechanism to prevent them from becoming overpowered. The raw damage output and unique movesets are intended to be their defining traits.
4. Is it worth investing in upgrading Black Knight weapons if they can’t go past +5?
Absolutely. The +5 max upgrade is not a drawback but a design feature. The damage increase you get from each Twinkling Titanite upgrade is significant, and they are very powerful for the majority of the game. It’s still worthwhile to spend your resources on upgrading them to +5.
5. Do Black Knight weapons scale with stats like Strength or Dexterity?
Yes, but their scaling is typically lower than that of standard weapons. While they do gain damage from stat scaling, most of their power comes from their high base damage. This makes them effective even for characters who don’t heavily invest in specific damage-scaling stats.
6. Why do some players still use Black Knight weapons in the late game?
Despite not reaching +15 like standard weapons, Black Knight weapons have excellent base damage, unique movesets, and the convenience of maxing out early. In the hands of skilled players, their unique properties can be more effective than sheer damage. For example, the Black Knight Halberd has one of the highest reach attacks in the game.
7. Are all Black Knight weapons equally powerful?
No. The Black Knight Halberd is often considered the most powerful due to its long reach, high damage output, and strong moveset. However, the Black Knight Sword and other Black Knight weapons also have their own unique strengths and can be effective in different scenarios.
8. Is there any way to increase the damage of Black Knight weapons beyond upgrades?
Other than your own damage increasing stats, no. You cannot further increase the damage of these weapons beyond their +5 upgrade level, so other stat and item buffs are your only source of additional damage.
9. Does the Black Knight weapon’s upgrade path resemble a +10 regular weapon?
The general consensus is that a +5 Black Knight weapon is approximately equivalent to a +10 standard weapon. However, it’s not a like-for-like comparison, as each weapon is unique, but it is a good frame of reference.
10. Where do I find Twinkling Titanite to upgrade Black Knight weapons?
Twinkling Titanite is a relatively rare material found in various locations throughout the game, usually in areas with more difficult enemies or near bosses. Certain merchants will also eventually sell them in unlimited quantities. This means that upgrading them will be a resource management exercise.
11. Do Black Knight weapons have any special effects besides their high damage?
Each Black Knight weapon boasts a unique moveset, often with powerful strikes that can stagger or knock down enemies. This helps with gameplay by disrupting enemies and opening them up for more damage.
12. How do I obtain Black Knight weapons?
Black Knight weapons are dropped by specific Black Knight enemies throughout the game. They are often rare drops, meaning you may need to farm specific locations to obtain them.
13. Does the “plus” level (+5) of Black Knight weapons affect matchmaking?
No. The upgrade level of Black Knight weapons is not calculated in matchmaking, meaning you will be matched as if they are +5 and not a hidden value. Matchmaking generally relies on your soul level and your highest upgraded normal weapon.
14. Can you ascend Black Knight weapons to a different type?
No. Black Knight weapons cannot be ascended to a different type. They are locked to their physical damage type.
15. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using Black Knight weapons?
Advantages: High base damage, strong movesets, early-to-mid-game dominance.
Disadvantages: Limited upgrade cap (+5), cannot be infused or buffed, lower stat scaling.
Conclusion
While Black Knight weapons cannot be upgraded past +5, their inherent power and unique characteristics make them incredibly valuable throughout the game. Understanding their limitations and strengths is key to wielding them effectively. They serve as a significant early-to-mid-game boost in power, but they do not supersede standard weapon fully upgraded in the absolute endgame, providing a balanced gameplay experience that encourages variety and experimentation.