Did Harry Potter Ever Live With Sirius Black?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is no, Harry Potter never lived with Sirius Black. Despite a fervent hope and a near-offer in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, the circumstances of Sirius’s life as a fugitive and, later, his tragic death prevented him from ever taking Harry in as his legal guardian. Their relationship was deeply impactful, yet lived out in snatched moments and hidden communication. While they shared a strong bond, the notion of Harry ever having a permanent home with Sirius remained a heartbreaking “what if” scenario for both the character and the fans.
A Fleeting Hope and Crushing Reality
In Prisoner of Azkaban, the prospect of Harry escaping his life with the Dursleys and living with his godfather, Sirius, was a major plot point. Sirius, wrongly accused of betraying the Potters, finally managed to escape Azkaban. After learning the truth and that Harry was his godson, he offered Harry a chance to live with him once his name was cleared. Harry was understandably thrilled by this prospect, dreaming of finally having a real family. However, Peter Pettigrew’s escape and Lupin’s transformation into a werewolf forced Sirius to remain a fugitive. He was unable to clear his name and could never legally take Harry in.
Their relationship continued in the form of letters and hidden meetings, but never as a cohabiting family. Sirius, though in hiding, remained an important figure in Harry’s life, providing him with crucial information and support. The idea of living together was a constant “almost,” a heartbreaking possibility that was always just out of reach.
Grimmauld Place and Its Complicated Legacy
After Sirius Black’s death in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, his ancestral home, Number 12 Grimmauld Place, was inherited by Harry. Although Harry technically owned the house, he never lived there permanently. The house served as the headquarters for the Order of the Phoenix, a safe house during the war against Voldemort. Harry did spend time at Grimmauld Place, but it was never a place he called home in the way he had hoped to. Instead, it was a strategic location for the resistance and another grim reminder of his lost godfather. After the war, Harry continued to let the Order use it and eventually chose to live elsewhere. The house became emblematic of sacrifice and loss for him, rather than a home with positive memories.
The Role of Dumbledore and Blood Wards
Albus Dumbledore played a crucial role in keeping Harry at the Dursleys. Dumbledore insisted Harry return to the Dursleys each summer due to the protective blood wards established by Lily Potter’s sacrifice. These wards were a powerful defense against Voldemort, and living with Petunia Dursley, Lily’s sister, was the only way they could remain in place. Dumbledore also believed, though controversially, that a more comfortable life would diminish Harry’s resolve to face Voldemort, a cruel manipulation in retrospect. This strategic necessity, combined with the tragic events that kept Sirius a fugitive, effectively prevented Harry from ever having a life with his godfather.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some related questions and answers that further explore this topic:
1. Why Didn’t Dumbledore Let Harry Live With Sirius?
Dumbledore’s primary reason for keeping Harry with the Dursleys was the protection of the blood wards. He believed it was the only way to keep Harry safe from Voldemort’s direct attacks. While this was effective against Voldemort’s physical attacks it wasn’t effective for emotional ones. He also had a controversial belief that a comfortable Harry wouldn’t be as willing to sacrifice himself. This prevented him from ever agreeing to Harry living with Sirius.
2. How Did Sirius Find Out Where Harry Lived?
It is presumed that Hagrid told Sirius where he was taking Harry after their meeting at Godric’s Hollow. Once Sirius knew Harry was in Little Whinging, it is believed he could find him through scent or magical tracking.
3. Did Sirius Leave Anything Else To Harry Besides Grimmauld Place?
Sirius’s will only included Grimmauld Place as he never inherited the Black family fortune. He was written out of the family will, making the house the only inheritance he had to give to his godson. Had he inherited their wealth as well, it’s likely it would have far surpassed Harry’s own wealth.
4. Did Sirius Know That Harry Was a Horcrux?
No, Sirius did not know that Harry was a Horcrux. This was a closely guarded secret known only to Dumbledore and Regulus Black. Sirius was cut off from his family, including his brother, and was unaware of Voldemort’s horcruxes.
5. Why Did Sirius Buy Harry a Firebolt?
Sirius, knowing Harry’s passion for Quidditch and that Harry had lost his beloved Nimbus 2000, bought him a Firebolt as a gesture of his love and support. He did so through a wizarding mail-order system, using Harry’s name and his own vault number at Gringotts.
6. Did Malfoy Know About Sirius?
Yes, Lucius Malfoy knew about Sirius. It was likely that through either eavesdropping or by being deliberately told, Draco Malfoy knew that Sirius could transform into a large black dog. Lucius also appeared to have recognized Sirius in his dog form.
7. How Did The Order of the Phoenix Start Using Grimmauld Place?
The Order of the Phoenix had been using Grimmauld Place before Harry inherited the house because Sirius was living there. They were based there until it was believed that Bellatrix Lestrange would inherit the house after Sirius’s death. However, the house was in fact left to Harry in Sirius’s will. They were based there again after Harry received the house.
8. What Did Harry Do With Grimmauld Place After the War?
After the war, Harry continued to allow the Order of the Phoenix to use Grimmauld Place as a safe house. He did not live there permanently, but kept the property due to its significance in his life and its practicality as a base.
9. How Wealthy Was Harry Compared to Others?
Harry was a millionaire, while the Malfoys were considered billionaires. While not the wealthiest wizard, Harry was still significantly rich from the money his parents left him. According to J.K. Rowling, his net worth is roughly 2.6 million dollars.
10. How Did Sirius Feel About Severus Snape?
Sirius hated Severus Snape due to their long-standing animosity that started during their school years. The rivalry was partially caused by Snape’s open dislike for Gryffindor and his inherent Slytherin nature.
11. Did Bellatrix Regret Killing Sirius?
Bellatrix Lestrange did not regret killing Sirius. She showed no remorse and even taunted Harry about it. She later attacked Tonks, her niece.
12. Who Killed Remus Lupin?
Remus Lupin was killed by Antonin Dolohov during the Battle of Hogwarts. Rowling stated his and Tonks’ deaths were to balance the last-minute reprieve of Arthur Weasley.
13. Did Sirius Really Betray Harry’s Parents?
No, Sirius did not betray Harry’s parents. He was believed to be the Potters’ Secret Keeper but had actually switched with Peter Pettigrew, who was the actual mole.
14. Who Inherited Sirius Black’s House?
Harry Potter inherited Sirius Black’s house, Number 12 Grimmauld Place, after Sirius’s death.
15. Did Harry Ever See Sirius Again?
Yes, Harry saw Sirius again briefly through the Resurrection Stone, along with James and Lily Potter, and Remus Lupin, on May 2, 1998.