Do Copies Count as Spells? A Deep Dive into Magic: The Gathering Rules
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, copies are indeed spells. However, the crucial distinction lies in whether they are cast. A copy of a spell is a spell in its own right, possessing all the characteristics of the original, but it generally enters the stack without being cast. This “not cast” status is a significant delimiter, impacting a wide range of abilities, triggers, and interactions within the game of Magic: The Gathering. Let’s unpack this complex rule.
Understanding the Stack and Spell Resolution
To truly grasp the significance of copies, it’s essential to understand the stack. The stack is a game zone where spells and abilities wait to resolve. When you cast a spell, it goes onto the stack. Players can respond to spells on the stack by casting instants or activating abilities. Once all players pass priority in succession, the topmost spell or ability on the stack resolves, doing what it says. Copies of spells are placed directly onto the stack without being cast, bypassing the normal casting process.
This difference is paramount. Many effects in Magic trigger specifically when a spell is cast. Since copies are typically not cast, these triggers are not activated. This distinction is the foundation for understanding how copies interact (or don’t interact) with various game mechanics.
Implications of “Not Cast”: Key Interactions
The “not cast” rule drastically alters how copies interact with various game mechanics. Let’s explore a few key examples:
- Cascade: Cascade triggers when you cast a spell. A copied spell entering the stack will not trigger Cascade.
- Storm: Storm triggers when you cast a spell. A copied spell will have the storm ability but copying the spell will not make storm trigger.
- Prowess: Prowess triggers when you cast a noncreature spell. Copying a spell will not trigger prowess.
- “When you cast…” Triggers: Abilities that trigger “when you cast” a spell, such as those found on specific legendary creatures or enchantments, will not trigger when a copy enters the stack.
- Mana Costs: Because copies aren’t cast, you don’t pay mana for them. This can be highly advantageous, allowing you to duplicate powerful spells without additional mana expenditure.
- Cards like Swarm Intelligence: Enchantments like Swarm Intelligence will not trigger when a spell is copied.
- Cards like Apex of Power or Approach of the Second Sun: Spells that have bonus effects when cast will not have those bonus effects when they are copied.
The Exceptions: When Copies Are Cast
While most copies enter the stack without being cast, certain cards and abilities can create copies that are cast. A prominent example of this is Eye of the Storm.
- Eye of the Storm: This enchantment exiles instants and sorceries that are cast. Then, whenever a player casts a spell, they get to cast copies of all the cards exiled by Eye of the Storm. These copies are cast, meaning they will trigger abilities that look for spells being cast.
Understanding these exceptions is crucial for navigating complex game states and maximizing the effectiveness of your strategy.
Strategic Applications of Copying Spells
Copying spells is a powerful strategy in Magic. It allows you to:
- Amplify Effects: Double the impact of a powerful spell for devastating results.
- Overwhelm Opponents: Flood the board with multiple copies of a creature or overwhelming spell.
- Exploit Triggers: Create multiple triggers from a single source by copying a spell with relevant abilities.
- Bypass Mana Restrictions: Cast expensive spells without paying their full mana cost.
Knowing when and how to copy spells effectively is a skill that separates novice players from seasoned veterans.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does copying an instant count as casting a spell?
No, copying an instant does not count as casting a spell. The copy is placed directly on the stack, bypassing the casting process.
2. Does replicate count as a cast?
No, replicate itself does not count as casting a spell. Replicate creates copies of a spell that has already been cast.
3. Does copying a spell count for storm?
A copy of a spell with storm will have storm, but copying the spell will not make storm trigger.
4. Do copied spells count for prowess?
No, copied spells do not trigger prowess because they are not cast.
5. What counts as a replicate?
In Magic, replicate is a keyword ability that allows you to pay an additional cost to create copies of a spell when you cast it.
6. Does Eye of the Storm cast spells?
Yes, Eye of the Storm allows you to cast copies of exiled spells. These copies are considered cast.
7. Does copying a spell trigger cascade?
No, copying a spell does not trigger cascade. Cascade triggers when a spell is cast, and copies are typically not cast.
8. Can you kick a copied spell?
If a kicked spell is copied, the copy is also kicked. The kicker cost, if paid on the original, is reflected in the copy.
9. Do copied spells trigger Orvar?
No, copied spells do not trigger Orvar, as copies are not considered “cast” for the purpose of any triggers that care.
10. Do copied spells trigger heroic?
Heroic abilities won’t trigger when a copy of a spell is created on the stack.
11. Do copies have mana value?
Yes, copies retain the mana value of the original spell. If the mana cost is able to be copied, the mana value is copied also. If the mana value cannot be copied, the mana value of the copy is 0.
12. What happens if you copy an adventure spell?
If an effect copies an Adventure spell, that copy is exiled as it resolves.
13. Does foretell count as casting a spell?
Yes, when you cast a card you foretold, it counts as casting a spell.
14. Are copied spells played?
Copies of spells are placed on the stack, which means they are played. However, the crucial point is that they are generally not cast. “Played” encompasses a broader range of actions than “cast.”
15. Why is understanding the “not cast” rule important?
Understanding the “not cast” rule is crucial for correctly interpreting game rules and predicting interactions. It’s essential for constructing competitive decks and making informed decisions during gameplay.