Decoding the Copy Conundrum: Do Copies Trigger Magecraft in Magic: The Gathering?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is it depends. A copy of a spell itself does not automatically trigger magecraft. Magecraft abilities trigger when you cast or copy an instant or sorcery spell. However, many effects that create copies also allow you to cast those copies, and casting the copy will indeed trigger magecraft. The distinction lies in whether the copy is simply created, or created and then cast. Let’s delve deeper into this nuanced interaction.
Understanding Magecraft and Copies
Magecraft is a triggered ability found on certain permanents, most often creatures. Its basic functionality is that whenever you cast or copy an instant or sorcery spell, the magecraft ability triggers, resulting in a defined effect (such as +1/+1 counters, dealing damage, etc.). It’s a powerful mechanic that rewards you for playing spells, particularly in decks built around instant and sorcery synergies.
The concept of “copying” in Magic can be confusing. Essentially, it means creating a duplicate of a spell or ability. This duplicate goes onto the stack and will resolve unless countered. The key thing to remember is that simply creating a copy does not count as casting a spell. If an effect only creates a copy, magecraft does not trigger. The caveat is that if the effect gives you the opportunity to cast that copy, and you do so, magecraft will trigger.
Consider a card like Isochron Scepter. It lets you copy an exiled instant card and then cast the copy. The copy alone doesn’t trigger magecraft, but casting that copy does. This highlights the importance of reading the card carefully to understand the full sequence of events.
The Stack: Where Copies Live
The stack is a crucial element of Magic’s rules. It’s where spells and abilities wait to resolve. When you cast a spell or activate an ability, it goes on the stack. Players can then respond by casting more spells or activating more abilities, adding them to the stack on top of what’s already there. The last thing put on the stack resolves first, then the next, and so on.
When a card is copied, the copy is placed directly onto the stack. This copy is treated as a separate spell. When a card is cast, the act of casting places it on the stack.
Why the Distinction Matters
Understanding this distinction is vital for deckbuilding and gameplay. Knowing when magecraft will and won’t trigger allows you to maximize the value of your creatures and accurately predict the outcome of your plays. It also informs your decisions about when to use specific cards and how to respond to your opponent’s actions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Copies and Magecraft
Here are 15 common questions regarding copies and magecraft, with clear and concise answers:
1. Does copying a spell trigger prowess?
No. Prowess triggers when you cast a noncreature spell. Copying a spell simply creates a copy on the stack. Because that card was not cast, prowess will not be triggered.
2. Does copying a spell trigger storm?
No. The storm ability triggers when you cast a spell. While a copy of a spell with storm will also have the storm ability, copying a spell will not cause the storm ability to trigger.
3. Does replicate count as casting?
No. Replicate allows you to create copies of a spell, but it doesn’t count as casting those copies. You cast the original spell, and paying the replicate cost creates the copies. Casting the original spell will trigger abilities such as magecraft, but the copies created by the replicate ability will not.
4. Does Isochron Scepter trigger magecraft twice?
No. While Isochron Scepter says both “copy” and “cast,” it only triggers magecraft once. The Scepter instructs you to copy a card and then allows you to cast the copy. Only the act of casting the copy will trigger the magecraft ability.
5. Do copies count as spells?
Yes. A copy of a spell is considered a spell itself, even though it doesn’t have a physical card associated with it. However, it’s crucial to remember that copies are created differently than cast spells, so they don’t trigger abilities that only trigger from casting.
6. Is a copy considered a token?
No. A copy of a permanent spell may become a token as it resolves (for example, if you copy a creature spell). But the copy on the stack itself is not a token. A copy is made, then if its a permanent card that permanent becomes a token.
7. What happens if you copy an Adventure spell?
If you copy an Adventure spell, the copy is exiled as it resolves and ceases to exist. You cannot then cast it as a creature.
8. Does Magecraft stack?
Yes! If an effect creates multiple copies of an instant or sorcery spell, magecraft abilities will trigger once for each copy created, provided the original spell was cast or the effect allows the copies to be cast.
9. Does Magecraft go on the stack?
No. Magecraft is a triggered ability. When the trigger condition (casting or copying an instant or sorcery spell) is met, the magecraft ability goes on the stack.
10. Do copies have mana value (CMC)?
Yes, copies of spells generally retain the mana value (CMC) of the original spell. The mana cost is considered a copiable value.
11. Do copies trigger Rhystic Study?
No. Rhystic Study triggers when a player casts a spell. If a spell is copied without being cast, Rhystic Study will not trigger.
12. Who controls a copy of a spell?
A copy of a spell is controlled by the player under whose control it was put onto the stack.
13. Can you cast a copy at instant speed?
Whether you can cast a copy at instant speed depends on the copy’s original characteristics and the rules for the spell you are copying. If the original spell was an instant, yes. If the copy requires you to cast it, and you want to cast it on your opponent’s turn, it has to be an instant.
14. If I cast a spell with convoke, does that trigger magecraft?
Yes, convoke allows you to tap creatures to pay for a spell’s mana cost, but it is still casting the spell. So magecraft will trigger.
15. If I create a copy of a permanent like a creature or enchantment, does magecraft trigger?
No. Magecraft only triggers when you cast or copy instant or sorcery spells. Copying a permanent is irrelevant to magecraft.
Magic: The Gathering is not just a game; it’s a complex system of rules and interactions. Understanding these rules, like the nuances of magecraft and copying, is key to mastering the game and finding new avenues for creative gameplay. For insights into the educational aspects of gaming, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.