Shadow of Mordor or War: Which Middle-earth Saga Should You Play First?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question for any Tolkien enthusiast venturing into the world of video games: Should you begin your journey with Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor (SoM) or dive straight into Middle-earth: Shadow of War (SoW)? The short answer? Play Shadow of Mordor first. While not strictly necessary to understand Shadow of War’s core plot, playing SoM provides crucial context, familiarizes you with the unique Nemesis System, and enriches your overall experience within the world of Mordor. Think of it as watching the first season of a great TV show before diving into season two – you can skip it, but you’ll miss out on character development and plot threads that add depth to the subsequent narrative. Let’s delve deeper into why experiencing Shadow of Mordor beforehand is the optimal path.
The Case for Starting with Shadow of Mordor
- Understanding the Nemesis System: Shadow of Mordor introduces the revolutionary Nemesis System, a dynamic mechanic that sees Orc captains rise through the ranks, develop rivalries with you, and remember past encounters. It’s the heart of the game’s unique appeal. Jumping into Shadow of War without understanding this system is akin to skipping the tutorial of a complex game. You’ll miss out on the organic relationships and personal narratives that make the series so engaging.
- Narrative Foundation: Shadow of Mordor sets the stage for Talion’s story and his bond with the wraith Celebrimbor. It establishes their motivations, introduces key characters, and explores the initial conflict with Sauron’s forces. While Shadow of War summarizes some of these events, experiencing them firsthand in SoM provides a richer, more impactful narrative experience.
- Combat and Gameplay Familiarity: Shadow of Mordor introduces the core combat mechanics, traversal abilities, and stealth tactics that are refined and expanded upon in Shadow of War. Learning the ropes in the first game will give you a smoother transition into the more complex gameplay features of its sequel. You’ll be less overwhelmed by the sheer number of abilities and upgrades available in SoW if you’ve already mastered the basics.
- Appreciation for the Evolution: Playing Shadow of Mordor first allows you to appreciate the significant improvements and additions made in Shadow of War. The expanded world, fortresses to conquer, and enhanced Nemesis System all feel more impactful when you’ve experienced the more streamlined gameplay of the original.
- A More Focused Experience: Shadow of Mordor is a more focused, tightly paced experience compared to the sprawling epic that is Shadow of War. This makes it a good starting point for newcomers who might be intimidated by the scale and complexity of the sequel.
Considering the Alternatives
While I strongly recommend starting with Shadow of Mordor, there are some situations where skipping it might be justifiable:
- Time Constraints: If you’re pressed for time and only want to experience the latest and greatest, Shadow of War can stand alone. However, I still recommend watching a summary of Shadow of Mordor’s plot on YouTube to gain context.
- Gameplay Fatigue: If you’ve recently played a similar open-world action game, jumping into Shadow of War might feel more refreshing than going through another similar experience beforehand.
- Already Familiar with the Lore: If you are incredibly familiar with the lore and stories of Middle-earth, you could jump into Shadow of War without having to know some of the backstory from Shadow of Mordor.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is it necessary to play Shadow of Mordor before Shadow of War?
No, it’s not strictly necessary, but highly recommended. Shadow of War provides some context for the events of Shadow of Mordor, but the experience is richer and more enjoyable if you’ve played the first game.
What’s the main difference between Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of War?
Shadow of War is significantly larger in scope, offering a vastly expanded world, more weapons and abilities, and an enhanced Nemesis System with fortress sieges. It’s essentially a bigger, bolder version of Shadow of Mordor.
Is Shadow of War a direct sequel to Shadow of Mordor?
Yes, Shadow of War directly follows the events of Shadow of Mordor, continuing the story of Talion and Celebrimbor’s struggle against Sauron.
How does Shadow of War fit into the Lord of the Rings timeline?
Both games are set between the events of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, exploring the tumultuous period in Middle-earth’s history as Sauron regains his power.
Is Talion a Nazgûl in Lord of the Rings?
While the game explores dark themes and Talion’s use of Rings of Power, he does not become one of the original nine Nazgûl featured in The Lord of the Rings books. The games explore an alternative “what if” scenario, and should not be considered canon to the original stories.
Which game is harder, Shadow of Mordor or Shadow of War?
Shadow of War generally offers a higher degree of challenge due to its more complex gameplay mechanics, enemy variety, and fortress siege mechanics. However, both games offer adjustable difficulty settings.
Which game is longer, Shadow of Mordor or Shadow of War?
Shadow of War is significantly longer than Shadow of Mordor. Completing the main story and side content in Shadow of War can take 60 hours or more, while Shadow of Mordor typically takes around 30 hours for completionists.
Is the story in Shadow of Mordor/War considered canon?
The games are considered non-canon, meaning they tell an original story within the established world of Middle-earth but introduce new characters and events that deviate from Tolkien’s original works.
Do I need to watch The Lord of the Rings movies before playing?
While not essential, watching the Lord of the Rings movies or reading the books will significantly enhance your understanding of the world, characters, and lore of Middle-earth. It will help you appreciate the context and references within the games.
What are some essential tips for playing Shadow of War?
- Master the combat system. A measured approach is more effective than button-mashing.
- Utilize stealth tactics to eliminate enemies and gain advantages.
- Focus on building your army by dominating Orc captains.
- Exploit enemy weaknesses to defeat them quickly.
- Don’t be afraid to run away from overwhelming encounters.
Can I get banned for cheating in Shadow of War?
Yes, using cheats or hacks can result in a ban from online features and leaderboards.
What is the Shadow War endgame in Shadow of War?
The Shadow War is an endgame sequence where you defend your fortresses against waves of Orc attacks. It’s designed to provide a challenging and replayable experience after completing the main story.
Was Celebrimbor evil in the game?
The game portrays a darker version of Celebrimbor, showing him as a more morally ambiguous figure driven by a desire for power and revenge.
Is Shadow of War a AAA game?
Yes, Shadow of War is a AAA game with high production values, extensive marketing, and a large development team.
What does “the Tark” mean?
Orcs and Orc Captains refer to Talion as “the Tark”, which is a derogatory term for rangers or foreigners, derived from the word “Turk.”
Final Verdict
While you can jump straight into Shadow of War, playing Shadow of Mordor first provides a more complete and satisfying experience. You’ll gain a deeper understanding of the story, master the gameplay mechanics, and appreciate the evolution of the Nemesis System. So, if you have the time, embark on Talion’s journey from the beginning – you won’t regret it.
If you are interested in learning more about the design and theory of video games, you should check out the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. This organization is dedicated to the study of video games and their impact on learning and society.