Should You Steal the Feather in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether or not to steal the Fwooper Feather for Garreth Weasley from Professor Sharp’s office is a common dilemma for players of Hogwarts Legacy. The short answer is this: It doesn’t actually matter to the overall story whether you steal the feather or not. The consequences are minimal and don’t impact your progression, the game’s ending, or your character’s relationships. However, there is one compelling reason to steal it. The choice primarily boils down to experiencing a specific, amusing cutscene. Let’s delve deeper into the nuances of this seemingly significant decision.
The Impact of Your Choice
No Real Consequences
As the game makes clear, there are no tangible consequences for either choice. If you opt not to steal the feather, Garreth will be a little disappointed but quickly recovers, stating he’ll “work something else out.” The lesson proceeds as normal, and life at Hogwarts continues without any changes. If you do steal the feather, Professor Sharp will scold you, and again, the lesson will continue without any impact on the overall story.
The Amusing Cutscene
The key difference lies in the cutscene you unlock by stealing the feather. This small piece of content adds a moment of levity and character development, showcasing Garreth’s eccentric personality. It’s a humorous interlude that many players find enjoyable and worth experiencing. Therefore, from a purely entertainment point of view, stealing the feather is recommended for players looking for a more complete experience. If you’re someone who likes to see all there is to see and don’t mind a little rule-breaking, then stealing the feather is likely the option you should choose.
Exploring the Moral Ambiguity
While stealing the feather doesn’t affect the game’s progression, it does present a minor moral quandary. Do you succumb to the request of a fellow student, potentially risking trouble with a professor? This decision allows players to engage in some role-playing. If your character is a rule-follower, they might opt not to steal the feather. Conversely, a more mischievous or adventurous character might gladly assist Garreth. The lack of genuine repercussions makes it a low-stakes way to personalize your experience.
Stealing vs. Not Stealing: A Summary
- Stealing the Feather:
- You see an amusing cutscene.
- Professor Sharp scolds you.
- No other consequences.
- Suits players wanting a more complete experience.
- Not Stealing the Feather:
- Garreth is slightly disappointed.
- No other consequences.
- Suits players wanting to play a more moral character.
Ultimately, the choice is yours. It allows you to express your character’s personality and doesn’t affect your gameplay. It also shows that, like real life, sometimes actions have negligible consequences in the grand scheme of things. The decision really comes down to whether you wish to view the unique cutscene provided by choosing to steal the feather.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
To further guide you, here are 15 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) related to choices and consequences in Hogwarts Legacy:
1. Does Stealing the Feather Affect My Relationship with Garreth?
No, the decision to steal the feather does not significantly alter your relationship with Garreth. Regardless of your choice, he remains a supporting character with similar interactions throughout the game.
2. Can I Get Expelled From Hogwarts For Stealing the Feather?
No, stealing the feather does not lead to any expulsions or serious consequences. Your actions in this specific instance have minimal impact on the overall gameplay.
3. Does Stealing the Feather Affect My House Points?
No, stealing the feather does not impact your House Points or your standing within your Hogwarts House. This choice has no bearing on your academic performance in the game.
4. Should I Turn in Sebastian?
The decision to turn in Sebastian has a major impact on gameplay. Turning him in means you will lose him as an interactable character and not get the chance to learn the Unforgivable Curses from him. If you wish to learn these curses, you should not turn him in. However, his absence from the end game and epilogue is a consequence of not turning him in.
5. Does Turning In Sebastian Affect the Ending?
Yes, turning in Sebastian affects the ending by removing him from the final quests and epilogue. His place in the “In the Shadow of Friendship” questline will be taken by Ominis Gaunt.
6. Can You Get the Killing Curse If You Turn Sebastian In?
No, you cannot learn Avada Kedavra from Sebastian if you turn him in. If you wish to learn this curse, you must choose not to turn him in after his confrontation with his uncle. However, you can still access the curse via the Dark Arts Battle Arena if you have the Deluxe Edition or the Dark Arts Pack DLC, regardless of your choice regarding Sebastian.
7. Should I Be Honest with Professor Weasley?
Lying to Professor Weasley has no effect on the game. This decision is purely for role-playing, allowing players to choose options that align with their character’s personality, without any real consequences.
8. What Happens If I Tell Everyone the Truth?
Telling everyone the truth, in relation to Sebastian, does not impact the overall story or your friendship. This decision primarily impacts your dialogue with Sebastian and the conversations you have with other characters.
9. Can You Stop Sebastian from Killing His Uncle?
No, you cannot stop Sebastian from killing his uncle. This event is scripted and occurs regardless of your actions. Your choice comes later, whether to turn him in or not after the killing has occurred.
10. Should I Lie to Professor Sharp?
Lying to Professor Sharp, like the other similar options, has no impact on the game. He will reprimand you, while owning up to your actions earns a commendation from him. However, the incident is never brought up again.
11. Should I Keep the Astrolabe?
Choosing to keep the Astrolabe or demanding a reward does not affect your rewards. You will receive the same rewards regardless of your choice.
12. Can I Romance Sebastian?
No, there are no romance options available in Hogwarts Legacy.
13. Is There a Shiny Unicorn?
Yes, there is a shiny Unicorn in Hogwarts Legacy that is a brown, almost gold-like color. This creature is found only in a specific den, with one unicorn spawning at a time.
14. Should I Pick Natty or Sebastian?
Your choice between Natty and Sebastian is largely inconsequential to the main story. It mainly affects the conversations you have on the trip to Hogsmeade.
15. Can I Get Expelled From Hogwarts?
While the game references potential expulsion, there are no options to be permanently expelled from Hogwarts in Hogwarts Legacy. It’s a bit of a red herring.
Final Thoughts
The decision to steal the feather in Hogwarts Legacy comes down to personal preference and a desire to see all the small, entertaining moments that the game offers. It has no lasting impact on the story, but it does provide a bit of humor and character development. Considering this, stealing the feather is recommended for those wishing to experience the amusing cutscene. Make your choices based on your own role-playing goals, and enjoy the journey at Hogwarts.