Table of Contents

Natural Attacks: Are They Light Weapons in Pathfinder? A Definitive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers Do natural attacks count as light weapons? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The short, somewhat unsatisfying answer is no, natural attacks are generally not considered light weapons in Pathfinder. While an initial reading might suggest otherwise, a deeper dive into the rules and developer clarifications reveals a more nuanced picture. Let’s unravel the complexities of natural attacks and their relationship to weapon categories.

Understanding Natural Attacks

What Exactly is a Natural Attack?

In Pathfinder, a natural attack is an attack made by a creature without wielding a manufactured weapon. Claws, bites, slams, gores, stings – these are all examples of natural attacks. These attacks are inherent to the creature and part of its physiology. It’s important to distinguish them from unarmed strikes, which are distinct actions representing blows delivered with fists or other body parts.

Primary vs. Secondary Attacks

Natural attacks are further divided into primary and secondary attacks. Primary attacks are made using the creature’s full base attack bonus (BAB) and add the creature’s full Strength bonus to damage rolls. Secondary attacks are made at a -5 penalty to the attack roll and only add half the creature’s Strength bonus to damage. The designation of whether a natural attack is primary or secondary is usually specified in the creature’s stat block. Typically, a creature’s most powerful or signature attacks are designated as primary.

Natural Attacks and Weapon Categories: The Disconnect

While natural attacks are indeed considered weapons in the broad sense that they are used to inflict damage, they do not neatly fit into the simple, martial, or exotic weapon categories. This means feats or class features that grant proficiency in a specific type of weapon (e.g., “Weapon Focus (Longsword)”) do not apply to natural attacks. Natural weapons are their own distinct thing.

Why the Confusion About Light Weapons?

The confusion stems from a few areas:

Developer Statements: Early developer comments suggested that natural attacks are treated like light weapons in some respects, but this wasn’t explicitly codified in the core rules.
Unarmed Strikes vs. Natural Attacks: There might be a confusion between natural weapons and unarmed strikes.
Spell Combat: Certain spells (like in the Magus class) require the usage of a light weapon to cast while fighting.

The Case Against Natural Attacks as Light Weapons

Here’s why natural attacks aren’t generally treated as light weapons:

No Explicit Rule: There’s no definitive rule stating natural attacks are light weapons. While early statements from the design team hinted at this, those hints have been clarified over time.
Two-Weapon Fighting: The rules for two-weapon fighting do not directly apply to natural attacks. Creatures with multiple natural attacks do not take penalties as if fighting with two light weapons. Instead, the rules for multiple natural attacks apply.
Proficiency: You don’t gain proficiency with natural attacks in the same way you gain proficiency with simple or martial weapons. Your creature type grants you the ability to use these natural attacks.
Interaction with Feats: Feats that specifically target light weapons (e.g., Weapon Finesse for light weapons) usually do not apply to natural attacks, unless the feat specifically states that it does.

How Natural Attacks Do Work

Multiple Natural Attacks: Creatures with multiple natural attacks can use them all in the same round, following specific rules for applying BAB and Strength bonuses.
Combining Natural and Manufactured Weapons: Creatures can combine natural attacks with manufactured weapon attacks, but this comes with penalties. Generally, the manufactured weapon is used at full BAB, and then all natural attacks are treated as secondary attacks.
Improving Natural Attacks: Feats and abilities can improve natural attacks, enhancing their damage, critical threat range, or other aspects.

The Takeaway

While the initial understanding of natural attacks might lead one to believe they are light weapons, a more in-depth analysis reveals that they occupy a unique space in the Pathfinder ruleset. They are weapons, but not simple, martial, or light weapons. Understanding this distinction is critical for accurately building and playing characters and creatures with natural attacks. It also highlights the importance of checking with your DM, and the GamesLearningSociety.org, should ambiguities be identified.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Natural Attacks

Here are some frequently asked questions to clarify the intricacies of natural attacks in Pathfinder:

Are natural weapons considered weapons? Yes, natural weapons are considered weapons in Pathfinder. They are used to inflict damage, just like manufactured weapons.
Do natural weapons count as simple or martial weapons? No, natural weapons do not count as simple or martial weapons. They are their own distinct category.
Do natural weapons count for two-weapon fighting? No, the standard two-weapon fighting rules and feats do not directly apply to natural weapons. The rules for multiple natural attacks dictate how these attacks are made in combat.
Can I use Weapon Finesse with a natural attack? Generally, no, you cannot use Weapon Finesse with a natural attack unless a specific ability or feat allows you to. Weapon Finesse typically applies to light weapons, and natural attacks aren’t classified as such.
If I have claws, can I use them to make iterative attacks? Creatures with natural attacks use their base attack bonus (BAB) to determine how many attacks they get each round. If a creature only has claws, that weapon functions as a primary natural weapon and is done at the creatures full BAB.
Can a Monk use natural weapons as part of a flurry of blows? In the original Pathfinder rules, a monk with natural weapons cannot use such weapons as part of a flurry of blows, nor can he make natural attacks in addition to his flurry of blows attacks. The Unchained Monk variant, however, removes this restriction.
Do natural attacks count as melee weapons? Yes, natural attacks generally count as melee weapons since they are used in close combat. You could, in theory, have a natural weapon that was ranged.
Can I take Weapon Focus (Claws)? Yes, you can take the feat Weapon Focus for a specific natural weapon type, like claws. This grants you a +1 bonus on attack rolls with that specific natural attack.
If I have a bite attack and a claw attack, which is primary and which is secondary? The creature’s stat block will specify which natural attacks are primary and which are secondary. If it’s not specified, usually the primary natural attack with be done at your highest base attack bonus.
How does Improved Natural Attack work? Improved Natural Attack increases the damage dice of a specific natural attack. For example, it might increase a claw attack from 1d4 to 1d6.
Can I combine a manufactured weapon attack with my natural attacks? Yes, you can combine a manufactured weapon attack with your natural attacks. Typically, you would attack with your manufactured weapon at your full BAB, and then all your natural attacks would be treated as secondary attacks (made at a -5 penalty, and with only half your Strength bonus added to damage).
What is the difference between natural attacks and unarmed strikes? Natural attacks are inherent to a creature, like claws or bites. Unarmed strikes are deliberate attacks made with fists, feet, or other body parts. Unarmed strikes are also a specific weapon class.
Are humans considered weapons? While this is a philosophical (and sometimes legal) question, in Pathfinder terms, no, a human is not considered a weapon. But courts in several states, like Texas, Ohio, and Kentucky, have determined the human body to be a deadly weapon under certain circumstances.
If I’m grappling, can I use natural attacks? Yes, some natural attacks can be used while grappling. This depends on the specific natural attack and whether you have a free hand (or comparable appendage) to use it. Usually it is considered a penalty to the attack.
Where can I learn more about game design and mechanics? Organizations like the Games Learning Society provide resources, research, and communities for exploring the intersection of games and education. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to delve deeper into the world of game-based learning and design.