Do You Add Proficiency to Improvised Weapons in 5E D&D?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is: it depends. You only add your proficiency bonus to an attack roll with an improvised weapon if the Game Master (GM) deems the improvised weapon similar enough to a weapon with which you are proficient. If the GM decides the object is unlike any weapon you’re proficient with, you do not add your proficiency bonus to the attack roll.
This ruling emphasizes the flexible and improvisational nature of Dungeons & Dragons, placing the ultimate decision in the GM’s hands. Let’s delve deeper into the nuances of improvised weapons in 5th Edition (5E) D&D.
Understanding Improvised Weapons
What Constitutes an Improvised Weapon?
An improvised weapon is defined as any object you can wield in one or two hands, such as a broken bottle, a stool, a chandelier, or even a particularly grumpy badger. The core principle is that it’s not a weapon designed for combat.
When Does an Improvised Weapon Become a “Real” Weapon?
This is where the GM’s judgment is crucial. The Player’s Handbook (PHB) states that “often, an improvised weapon is similar to an actual weapon and can be treated as such. For example, a table leg is akin to a club.”
If the GM agrees with this assessment, a character proficient with clubs could use the table leg and add their proficiency bonus to their attack roll. However, if the item is dissimilar or particularly unwieldy (imagine trying to use a slinky as a whip), proficiency would not apply.
Damage and Other Considerations
If you use an item that bears no resemblance to a weapon, it typically deals 1d4 damage. The DM assigns a damage type that’s appropriate for the object (bludgeoning for a chair, piercing for a shard of glass, etc.). If you hurl a melee weapon that lacks the thrown property, it also inflicts 1d4 damage.
This encourages creative solutions while preventing players from consistently outperforming dedicated weapon users with random objects.
Proficiency with Weapons in 5E
What Does Weapon Proficiency Actually Mean?
Proficiency with a weapon (like a longsword, shortbow, or dagger) means you’ve received training and understand how to effectively wield it. This translates into a +2 to +6 bonus (depending on your level) to your attack rolls.
Who Needs Weapon Proficiencies?
Classes like Fighters, Barbarians, Paladins, and Rangers are typically proficient with a broad range of weapons. Wizards and Sorcerers, on the other hand, might only be proficient with a few simple weapons.
How Do You Acquire New Weapon Proficiencies?
You can gain new weapon proficiencies through your class features, your race, your background, or through specific feats. Talk to your DM about options if you want to expand your character’s repertoire.
Practical Examples of Improvised Weapon Use
Scenario 1: The Tavern Brawl
A group of adventurers is caught in a heated tavern brawl. The Fighter grabs a sturdy wooden chair and swings it at an opponent.
- GM Ruling: The GM decides the chair is similar enough to a greatclub.
- Outcome: The Fighter can add their proficiency bonus (assuming they are proficient with greatclubs) to the attack roll. The damage could reasonably be the same as a greatclub (1d8 bludgeoning) or, at the GM’s discretion, the standard improvised weapon damage (1d4).
Scenario 2: The Desperate Escape
A Wizard, trapped in a cell, grabs a handful of straw and tries to fling it into the guard’s eyes.
- GM Ruling: The GM decides that straw is not similar to any weapon.
- Outcome: The Wizard cannot add their proficiency bonus to the attack roll. The damage, if any, would be minimal (probably just a distraction).
Scenario 3: The Ingenious Rogue
A Rogue, hiding in the shadows, throws a vial of alchemist’s fire at a group of enemies.
- GM Ruling: The GM rules that the alchemist’s fire is not similar to any regular weapon, but it is a special item with its own properties.
- Outcome: The Rogue doesn’t add their proficiency bonus to the attack roll for throwing the vial, but instead relies on the rules for alchemist’s fire, which typically specify a Dexterity saving throw for the target and deal fire damage on a failed save.
Fine-Tuning the Rules: GM Considerations
Favoring Creativity
While the rules provide a baseline, GMs should be willing to reward creative uses of improvised weapons. A clever player who comes up with an ingenious application should be encouraged, even if it means bending the rules slightly. This can foster a more engaging and dynamic game.
Consistency is Key
It’s crucial for GMs to maintain consistency in their rulings. If a table leg is considered similar to a club in one session, it should generally be treated the same way in subsequent sessions unless circumstances significantly change.
Damage Adjustment
GMs can adjust the damage dealt by improvised weapons based on their size, weight, and potential for harm. A heavy iron bar could reasonably deal more damage than a flimsy wooden spoon.
Maximizing Improvised Weapon Use
Character Concepts
Embrace the concept! A character who specializes in improvised weapons can be incredibly fun and versatile. Consider a Rogue who uses their surroundings to their advantage, or a Barbarian who simply smashes everything in sight.
Feats and Abilities
Some feats and class abilities can enhance improvised weapon use. The Tavern Brawler feat, for example, makes you more proficient with improvised weapons and unarmed strikes.
Communicate with Your DM
Discuss your character concept and your intentions with your DM. This will help ensure that your vision aligns with their campaign setting and their interpretation of the rules. Collaboration is key!
Adding Proficiency Bonus: A Summary
Adding proficiency to improvised weapon attacks in 5E is not automatic. It hinges on the GM’s determination of whether the improvised weapon closely resembles a weapon with which the character is already proficient. When in doubt, consult with your DM and embrace the opportunity to add flavor and creativity to your gameplay.
To learn more about game design and educational uses of games, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. If I’m proficient with a shortsword, can I add my proficiency bonus when attacking with a shard of broken glass?
Answer: Probably not. A shard of broken glass is unlikely to be considered similar enough to a shortsword to warrant adding your proficiency bonus. It would likely be treated as a standard improvised weapon dealing 1d4 piercing damage, and you wouldn’t add proficiency.
2. Does the Tavern Brawler feat automatically grant me proficiency with all improvised weapons?
Answer: No, the Tavern Brawler feat doesn’t grant universal proficiency. It makes you proficient with unarmed strikes and allows you to use a bonus action to grapple a creature after hitting it with an unarmed strike or an improvised weapon attack. It doesn’t change the rules about adding your proficiency bonus to the attack roll.
3. Can I use Sneak Attack with an improvised weapon as a Rogue?
Answer: Yes, if you meet the usual conditions for Sneak Attack (advantage on the attack roll or an ally adjacent to the target) and the GM allows you to add your proficiency bonus to the attack roll because the improvised weapon is similar to a weapon with which you’re proficient.
4. What ability score modifier do I use when attacking with an improvised weapon?
Answer: It depends. For melee attacks, you typically use Strength. For ranged attacks (throwing the improvised weapon), you use Dexterity. However, some improvised weapons might lend themselves to different ability scores at the GM’s discretion.
5. Can I dual-wield improvised weapons?
Answer: Yes, but only if they meet the requirements for dual-wielding. Typically, this means they must be light weapons. The GM decides if an improvised weapon counts as light. If they are not light, you would need the Dual Wielder feat.
6. Does the damage type of an improvised weapon always depend on the object used?
Answer: Yes, the DM will assign a damage type appropriate to the object. A wooden chair will likely deal bludgeoning damage, while a piece of broken glass would deal piercing damage.
7. If I throw a melee weapon that doesn’t have the “thrown” property, what happens?
Answer: It becomes an improvised weapon, dealing 1d4 damage of a type appropriate for the item. You also don’t add proficiency unless the GM rules otherwise.
8. Can I apply Divine Smite with an improvised weapon as a Paladin?
Answer: You can only use Divine Smite if you hit a creature with a melee weapon attack. This gets tricky with improvised weapons. A DM may rule using a table leg or other object as weapon allows Divine Smite. However, using an enemy as an improvised weapon doesn’t allow Divine Smite.
9. How does the “improvised tool” rule interact with improvised weapons?
Answer: There isn’t a direct interaction. “Improvised tool” typically applies to skill checks, not attack rolls. While both involve using objects in unconventional ways, they are governed by separate rules.
10. Can I use a shield as an improvised weapon?
Answer: Yes, you can, although the DM will likely make a ruling on the shield’s damage, and you might lose the AC bonus granted by the shield while you’re using it as a weapon.
11. Does the Magic Initiate feat allow me to cast spells through improvised weapons?
Answer: No, the Magic Initiate feat allows you to learn cantrips and a 1st-level spell from another class’s spell list. It doesn’t have any impact on improvised weapon use.
12. How does the Lucky feat interact with improvised weapon attacks?
Answer: The Lucky feat allows you to reroll an attack roll, ability check, or saving throw. If you’re unhappy with the result of your improvised weapon attack roll, you can use Lucky to try again.
13. If I’m proficient with unarmed strikes, does that make me proficient with all improvised weapons?
Answer: No. Unarmed strikes are distinct from improvised weapons. Proficiency in unarmed strikes typically means you can use your fists, elbows, knees, and feet effectively. It doesn’t extend to other objects.
14. Can I combine the Grappler feat with improvised weapon attacks?
Answer: The Grappler feat imposes disadvantage on attack rolls against creatures other than the one you’re grappling. While it technically doesn’t prevent you from making improvised weapon attacks, it makes them less effective.
15. How can I convince my DM to be more lenient with improvised weapon rulings?
Answer: Communicate your ideas clearly and showcase your character’s creativity. Provide logical arguments for why a particular object should be considered similar to a weapon you’re proficient with. Ultimately, it depends on your DM’s style and the campaign’s tone.