Do You Become Elder in Fallout 4? The Truth About Ruling the Brotherhood
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Unfortunately, the answer is a resounding no, you cannot become Elder of the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 4. While the game presents many choices and opportunities for leadership within other factions, seizing control of the Brotherhood is simply not an option Bethesda built into the game. Evidence suggests it was considered during development, with unused voice lines of Paladin Danse hinting at such a possibility, but it was ultimately cut from the final product. Attempting to eliminate Elder Maxson simply results in the entire Brotherhood becoming hostile toward you. So, while you can certainly influence the Brotherhood’s fate, you’ll never sit in the Elder’s chair.
Understanding the Brotherhood’s Structure and Limitations
The Brotherhood of Steel operates under a strict hierarchical structure, built on military discipline and unwavering loyalty. The position of Elder is not simply up for grabs; it’s earned through years of service, demonstrated commitment to the Brotherhood’s ideals, and often, bloodline. As an outsider, even one who proves their worth by completing numerous missions for the Brotherhood, you’ll always be viewed with a degree of suspicion. The game mechanics reflect this ingrained distrust, preventing you from ascending to the ultimate position of power.
Exploring Alternative Power Dynamics
While you can’t become Elder, it is important to understand how you can gain access to certain rewards. After you join the Brotherhood of Steel, you can gain access to a Power Armor located on the Prydwen airship. You can only use the Power Armor once you have been given the rank of Knight by Elder Maxson, leader of the Brotherhood of Steel. Also, Final Judgement is one of the strongest weapons in Fallout 4, but it’s unfortunately also one of the hardest unique weapons to acquire. You can only get Final Judgment by looting the corpse of Elder Maxson during The Nuclear Option, Airship Down, Ad Victoriam, and Rockets’ Red Glare.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Brotherhood of Steel and Elder Maxson
Here are 15 of the most frequently asked questions regarding the Brotherhood of Steel and Elder Maxson in Fallout 4, providing additional insight into this powerful faction:
1. What is the best ending in Fallout 4?
The “best” ending is subjective and depends on your roleplaying preferences. Many consider the Minutemen ending to be the most morally sound, allowing for the most peaceful and collaborative rebuilding of the Commonwealth. An ideal scenario, according to some, would involve the Institute supporting the Minutemen, fostering technological advancement alongside community development.
2. How do I replace Elder Maxson?
As previously stated, you cannot replace Elder Maxson within the game’s mechanics. There are no options, quests, or dialogue choices that allow you to usurp his position and take control of the Brotherhood.
3. What happens if you join the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 4?
Joining the Brotherhood of Steel grants you access to the Prydwen, their airship headquarters, and provides you with quests, armor, and weapons. You’ll rise through their ranks, completing missions and fighting for their ideals. However, be prepared to make morally ambiguous choices as their goals often clash with those of other factions.
4. Is Paladin Danse really a synth?
Yes, Paladin Danse is revealed to be a synth during the quest “Blind Betrayal.” This revelation forces you to make a difficult decision, highlighting the Brotherhood’s deep-seated distrust of synths.
5. What is the best faction to join in Fallout 4?
The Minutemen are often considered the “good” faction, focused on protecting settlements and establishing a sense of order in the Commonwealth. However, each faction offers unique benefits and drawbacks, making the choice a matter of personal preference.
6. Is Elder Maxson in Fallout 3?
Yes, Elder Arthur Maxson appears as a young squire in Fallout 3, located within the Citadel. This allows you to witness his evolution from a promising young soldier to the formidable leader he becomes in Fallout 4.
7. Can you overthrow Elder Maxson?
Again, no, you cannot overthrow Elder Maxson. The game does not provide any mechanics for doing so, and attempting to kill him will simply turn the Brotherhood hostile.
8. How do you get the Elder Maxson weapon?
You can acquire Final Judgement, Elder Maxson’s unique Gatling Laser, by looting his corpse after defeating him during specific endgame questlines (“The Nuclear Option,” “Airship Down,” “Ad Victoriam,” and “Rockets’ Red Glare”).
9. What are the Fallout 4 factions?
The major factions in Fallout 4 are the Minutemen, the Brotherhood of Steel, the Railroad, and the Institute. Each has distinct ideologies and goals, leading to potential conflict and alliances.
10. Who is the most powerful companion in Fallout 4?
After being transferred into a synthetic body, Curie becomes the strongest companion in the game with the sturdiest health pools and damage outputs.
11. Who are the romance options in Fallout 4?
Fallout 4 offers a variety of romance options, including Preston Garvey, MacCready, Paladin Danse, Cait, Porter Gage, Magnolia, John Hancock, and Piper Wright.
12. Is Nick Valentine a synth?
Yes, Nick Valentine is a Synth, a unique prototype with memories from a pre-War detective. This makes him a valuable ally and a fascinating character to explore the themes of identity and consciousness.
13. Is Deacon a synth?
The truth about Deacon is complicated. Deacon is a liar and a master of disguise. His claims about being a synth are part of his persona, and the truth remains ambiguous.
14. Who is the evilest faction in Fallout 4?
The Institute is often considered the most evil faction due to their ruthless pursuit of technological advancement at the expense of human lives and their disregard for the surface world. The Brotherhood of Steel can also be considered the most evil faction, aside from the Nuka World Raiders.
15. Who should I align with in Fallout 4?
Choosing a faction is a personal choice. The Minutemen represent a neutral and altruistic path, while the Brotherhood of Steel offer power and security, the Railroad champions freedom for synths, and the Institute promises technological marvels. Your decision should reflect your character’s values and goals.
Why No Elder Maxson Takeover? A Speculative Look
Why did Bethesda ultimately decide against allowing players to become the Elder of the Brotherhood of Steel? Several factors could have contributed to this decision:
- Maintaining Faction Identity: Allowing players to drastically alter the leadership of a well-established faction like the Brotherhood could dilute its core identity and create inconsistencies within the game world.
- Complexity of Implementation: Implementing a system where the player could realistically manage the Brotherhood’s vast resources, personnel, and political relationships would be incredibly complex and time-consuming.
- Player Agency vs. Lore Consistency: While player agency is important, allowing a complete takeover might contradict established lore and create narrative problems.
- Focus on Other Leadership Roles: The game already allows players to assume leadership roles within the Minutemen and, to a lesser extent, the other factions through alliances and influence.
The Importance of Choice and Consequence
Even though you can’t become Elder, Fallout 4 excels at providing meaningful choices that have lasting consequences. Your decisions regarding the Brotherhood, particularly concerning Paladin Danse and the fate of the Institute, significantly impact the ending you receive and the overall state of the Commonwealth. The game encourages you to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks of each faction and make choices that align with your personal vision for the future.
Exploring Leadership Through Gaming
The limitations within Fallout 4 can inspire discussions about leadership itself. What qualities make an effective leader? Is it power, compassion, or strategic thinking? These questions, raised implicitly by the game, can be explored further through educational resources like the Games Learning Society, which examines the intersection of gaming, learning, and society. GamesLearningSociety.org provides insights into how games can be used to develop critical thinking skills and explore complex social issues.
The Enduring Appeal of Fallout 4
Despite the limitations on becoming Elder of the Brotherhood, Fallout 4 remains a captivating and immersive experience. The game’s rich world, compelling characters, and branching narrative provide countless hours of enjoyment. The decisions you make, the alliances you forge, and the enemies you vanquish all contribute to a unique and personalized story that resonates long after the credits roll. And perhaps, in future iterations, Bethesda might reconsider allowing players to take on even more ambitious leadership roles. For now, we must settle for shaping the destiny of the Commonwealth from the shadows, knowing that even without the title of Elder, our actions can have a profound impact on the fate of the Brotherhood of Steel.
Fallout 4 provides an opportunity to explore what leadership means. Check out Games Learning Society for other games that teach leadership skills.