Do You Need to Play Dark Souls Before Dark Souls 2? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question for any newcomer eyeing the unforgiving world of FromSoftware’s Dark Souls series is almost always: do I need to play these games in order? Specifically, do you need to brave the trials of Dark Souls before venturing into the perilous lands of Dark Souls 2? The short answer is no, you don’t need to play Dark Souls before Dark Souls 2. However, like many things in the Souls universe, the answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no.
While the storylines are largely independent, experiencing Dark Souls first enriches your Dark Souls 2 experience and gives you context. Dark Souls 2 is a distinct entry, often described as an “expanded universe” type of experience within the larger Souls narrative. It operates on its own terms, with different characters, locations, and a largely self-contained story. Therefore, you can jump straight into Dark Souls 2 without feeling completely lost.
That being said, understanding the underlying lore, recurring themes, and the general vibe of the Souls universe will definitely make your journey through Dark Souls 2 more rewarding. You’ll pick up on subtle nods to the original, appreciate the similarities in gameplay mechanics, and better understand the broader context of the undead curse and the cycle of fire and dark. The Games Learning Society studies how games provide learning experiences, and the Souls series definitely teaches players persistence, problem-solving, and pattern recognition.
In essence, while not a prerequisite, playing Dark Souls first provides a valuable foundation for understanding and appreciating the unique world of Dark Souls 2. Think of it as watching the first movie in a series before the sequel. You can enjoy the sequel on its own, but you’ll likely appreciate it more if you’ve seen the original.
The Benefits of Playing Dark Souls First
Here’s why playing Dark Souls before Dark Souls 2 can be advantageous:
- Understanding the Lore: While the narratives are mostly separate, Dark Souls establishes the fundamental lore of the world, including the nature of the undead curse, the significance of the First Flame, and the motivations of the gods and lords who shaped the world.
- Familiarity with Gameplay Mechanics: Both games share core gameplay mechanics such as combat, exploration, and character progression. Playing Dark Souls familiarizes you with these mechanics, making the learning curve in Dark Souls 2 less steep.
- Appreciating the World and Atmosphere: Dark Souls creates a distinct and immersive atmosphere, characterized by its bleak beauty, oppressive sense of dread, and enigmatic characters. Experiencing this atmosphere in the first game allows you to better appreciate the similarities and differences in Dark Souls 2.
- Recognizing Recurring Themes: The Souls series is known for its recurring themes, such as the cyclical nature of history, the burden of choice, and the futility of ambition. Playing Dark Souls introduces you to these themes, allowing you to better understand their significance in Dark Souls 2.
Why Dark Souls 2 Can Stand on Its Own
Despite the benefits of playing Dark Souls first, Dark Souls 2 is designed to be accessible to newcomers. Here’s why it can be enjoyed as a standalone experience:
- Independent Storyline: Dark Souls 2 features a completely new storyline, set in a different land and populated by new characters. You don’t need to know anything about the events of Dark Souls to understand what’s happening in Dark Souls 2.
- Different Director, Different Vision: Dark Souls 2 was directed by a different team than Dark Souls. This resulted in a game that feels distinct in terms of its world design, combat mechanics, and overall tone.
- New Mechanics: Dark Souls 2 introduces its own unique mechanics, such as the Adaptability stat, which affects your character’s agility and invincibility frames during rolls. These mechanics are explained within the game, so you don’t need prior knowledge to understand them.
- A Fresh Start: For some players, starting with Dark Souls 2 can be a refreshing experience. It allows you to approach the Souls series with fresh eyes, without being burdened by expectations based on the first game.
Making the Choice: Which Game First?
Ultimately, the decision of whether to play Dark Souls before Dark Souls 2 is a matter of personal preference. If you’re new to the series and unsure where to start, consider the following:
- If you prioritize continuity and a deeper understanding of the lore: Start with Dark Souls.
- If you want a more accessible entry point and don’t mind missing some context: Start with Dark Souls 2.
- If you’re looking for a challenging but fair experience: Both games offer plenty of challenge, but Dark Souls is generally considered to be more balanced.
- If you’re drawn to a specific world or aesthetic: Choose the game that appeals to you the most visually and thematically.
No matter which game you choose to start with, be prepared for a challenging but rewarding experience. The Souls series is known for its difficulty, but also for its deep gameplay, rich lore, and unforgettable atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Dark Souls and Dark Souls 2
Here are some common questions players have about the order in which to play Dark Souls and Dark Souls 2:
Is Dark Souls 2 a sequel to Dark Souls?
Yes, Dark Souls 2 is a sequel to Dark Souls, though the connection is more thematic and mechanical than direct narrative continuation. It expands upon the lore and world established in the first game but features its own self-contained story.
Is Dark Souls 2 harder than Dark Souls 1?
Many players find Dark Souls 2 harder than Dark Souls due to its different enemy placement, aggressive AI, and the inclusion of the Adaptability stat, which affects your character’s agility. However, difficulty is subjective and depends on your playstyle and experience.
Is Dark Souls 2 a good starting point for the series?
Yes, Dark Souls 2 can be a decent starting point. It offers a relatively self-contained experience, allowing newcomers to ease into the series’ challenging gameplay and intricate world.
Are Dark Souls 1 and 2 connected in terms of story?
While set in the same universe, the stories of Dark Souls and Dark Souls 2 are largely separate. Dark Souls 2 takes place in a different kingdom, with its own set of characters and conflicts. However, there are thematic connections and references to the events of Dark Souls.
How are Dark Souls and Dark Souls 2 connected in terms of lore?
The lord souls from Dark Souls are a driving factor in the story of both games.
Is Dark Souls 2 as good as Dark Souls 1?
Whether Dark Souls 2 is as good as Dark Souls is a matter of opinion. Some players prefer the original’s more focused world design and tighter combat, while others appreciate Dark Souls 2‘s expanded mechanics, build variety, and improved PvP. Both games are highly regarded within the Souls community.
Is DS2 a prequel to DS1?
No, Dark Souls 2 is not a prequel. It is set many years after the events of Dark Souls, in a different kingdom and with a different cast of characters.
Why is Dark Souls 2 so different from Dark Souls 1?
Dark Souls 2 was directed by a different team than Dark Souls. Hidetaka Miyazaki, who directed Demon’s Souls and Dark Souls, served as a supervisor on Dark Souls 2 but was largely hands-off, allowing the new team to pursue their own vision for the game.
Does it matter if I start with Dark Souls 3?
Similar to Dark Souls 2, starting with Dark Souls 3 is possible, but you’ll miss some of the lore and context established in the earlier games. However, Dark Souls 3 is considered more directly connected to the first Dark Souls than Dark Souls 2 is.
Is Dark Souls 2 easier than Dark Souls 3?
Some players find Dark Souls 2 harder than Dark Souls 3, while others find it easier. Dark Souls 2 has different enemy placements and a greater emphasis on ganking, while Dark Souls 3 has faster-paced combat and more challenging bosses.
What is the main goal of Dark Souls 2?
The main goal of Dark Souls 2 is for the protagonist, known as the Bearer of the Curse, to break the undead curse by traveling to the kingdom of Drangleic and acquiring the four Great Souls from powerful Old Ones.
Are all 3 Dark Souls games connected in terms of story?
The three Dark Souls games take place in the same world but are largely standalone stories. Each game features its own characters, locations, and conflicts, though there are thematic connections and references to the events of previous games.
How many endings does Dark Souls 2 have?
Dark Souls 2 has two endings.
Is Dark Souls 2 as bad as everyone says?
No, Dark Souls 2 is not as bad as some people claim. While it has its flaws, such as its occasionally awkward level design and inconsistent enemy AI, it also offers many strengths, including its intricate world, diverse build options, and excellent PvP. Many of the complaints arise from comparing it unfavorably to the other games in the series.
Why didn’t Miyazaki work on Dark Souls 2 as director?
Miyazaki was busy working on Bloodborne during the development of Dark Souls 2. He served as a supervisor but allowed the new team to take the lead and pursue their own vision for the game.