Demystifying Copied Spells: Does a Copy Have a Converted Mana Cost (CMC)?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether a copied spell has a Converted Mana Cost (CMC) is a common point of confusion in the world of Magic: The Gathering. The short and definitive answer is yes, a copied spell does have a CMC. The CMC of a copied spell is the same as the CMC of the original spell it was copied from. This holds true whether the copy is of a card, spell, or permanent. Let’s delve deeper into this concept and address the frequently asked questions that surround it.
Understanding Converted Mana Cost (CMC)
Before diving into the specifics of copied spells, it’s essential to establish a solid understanding of what Converted Mana Cost (CMC) means. The CMC is a numerical representation of the total mana required to cast a spell. It’s calculated by summing the values of all mana symbols in the mana cost, regardless of color. For example:
- A card with a mana cost of {2}{U} has a CMC of 3.
- A card with a mana cost of {G}{G} has a CMC of 2.
- A card with a mana cost of {X}{R} has a CMC that depends on the value chosen for X when the spell is cast. If X is 3, the CMC is 4.
The Role of Copy Effects
Copy effects in Magic: The Gathering can arise from various sources. These effects create duplicates of spells, permanents, or even entire abilities. When something is copied, it generally takes on the characteristics of the original. These characteristics can include:
- Mana cost
- Colors
- Types
- Abilities
- Text
Therefore, if a spell or permanent with a specific mana cost is copied, the resulting copy will inherit that mana cost. This means that the CMC of the copy is identical to the CMC of the original. It’s important to remember that while the CMC is copied, some things, like counters, are not.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here’s a detailed list of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) that expand on the concept of copied spells and their CMC:
1. Do Copied Tokens Have CMC?
If a token is created as a copy of another permanent or card, it inherits all the copyable characteristics of the original, including its mana cost. Therefore, such a token does have a CMC, which is the same as the CMC of what it’s copying. However, tokens that are not copies (e.g., tokens created by spells like “Raise the Alarm”) usually have a CMC of 0, unless stated otherwise.
2. Does a Copy of a Spell Count as Casting a Spell?
This is a crucial distinction. Copies of spells are generally not considered to be “cast.” This means that effects or abilities that trigger when a spell is cast, such as cascade or enchantments like Rhystic Study, will not trigger when a spell is copied.
3. Does Overload Change CMC?
Overload does not change a spell’s CMC. It only alters the cost you pay to cast the spell. The CMC remains the same, regardless of whether you pay the normal mana cost or the overload cost.
4. Does a Copied Spell Have a Mana Cost?
Yes, a copied spell has a mana cost. As we established, the mana cost is a copyable value. This is distinct from paying the mana cost. When you copy a spell, you’re replicating its essence, including its inherent mana cost. You are essentially playing the spell again without having to pay its mana cost again.
5. Does Commander Tax Count as CMC?
No, Commander Tax is an additional cost, not part of the spell’s mana cost. A spell’s CMC is determined by the symbols printed on the card or the characteristics of the object being copied, and it does not change due to additional costs like Commander Tax.
6. Can You Kick a Copy of a Spell?
Kicker costs don’t change a spell’s mana cost or mana value. If you copy a kicked spell, the copy will also be kicked. The additional kicker costs are not copied as a cost of the copy, but the status of the spell as being “kicked” is copied.
7. Does Copying Spells Cost Money (In-Game or Real Life)?
In Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), copying a spell into a Wizard’s Spellbook often involves a cost. This can represent the materials and time needed to understand and replicate the spell. In the context of Magic: The Gathering, the “cost” refers to any additional effects or requirements associated with creating the copy, not necessarily a literal monetary expense.
8. Do You Have to Pay Additional Costs for Copied Spells?
The answer is nuanced. Generally, you don’t pay additional costs for copied spells. The copy inherits the characteristics of the original spell as it exists on the stack, including whether it was kicked, overloaded, or had modes chosen. However, you can’t choose to pay additional costs for the copy; it simply replicates the original.
9. Does Copying a Creature Spell Count as Creating a Token?
Yes, copying a creature spell becomes a token. When a copy of a permanent spell resolves, it enters the battlefield as a token with the characteristics of the spell. However, it’s important to note that this token isn’t considered “created” for the purposes of triggered abilities that specifically refer to creating tokens.
10. Does Affinity Reduce CMC?
Affinity does not reduce the CMC. Affinity reduces the amount of mana you pay to cast the spell. The CMC remains constant, regardless of any cost reduction effects.
11. Does Flashback Change CMC?
Flashback allows you to cast a spell from your graveyard. However, it does not change the CMC of the spell itself. The CMC is determined by the mana symbols on the card.
12. What Is Cyclonic Rift’s Mana Value?
Cyclonic Rift’s mana value (which is the same as CMC) is always 2, regardless of whether it’s cast for its normal mana cost or its overload cost.
13. Do Copied Spells Cascade?
No. Cascade triggers when a spell is cast. Copies of spells are not cast, so cascade will not trigger.
14. Does Copying a Spell Trigger Storm?
Similar to cascade, the storm ability triggers when a spell is cast. Since copying a spell is not the same as casting it, copying a spell will not trigger the storm ability. However, the copy itself will have the storm ability.
15. Is Playing a Spell the Same as Casting?
While the terms were used interchangeably in the past, “playing” a spell and “casting” a spell are now more precisely defined in Magic: The Gathering rules. Casting a spell involves taking a card from where it is (usually the hand), putting it on the stack, and paying its costs. “Playing” can refer to lands in addition to casting spells from other zones like exile or the graveyard.
Conclusion
Understanding the intricacies of CMC and copy effects is vital for mastering Magic: The Gathering. Remembering that a copied spell inherits the CMC of the original and that copying is distinct from casting will prevent confusion and lead to more informed strategic decisions. Magic is an ever-evolving game with complex interactions. For more insights into the intersection of games and learning, explore resources like the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.