Does Arthur Survive if He Goes with John?

Unfortunately, Arthur Morgan does not survive if he goes with John Marston, as his tuberculosis eventually catches up with him, leading to his death. The circumstances of his death can vary depending on the player’s choices, with a high honor playthrough resulting in a more peaceful death for Arthur.

Understanding the Context

To fully grasp the situation, it’s essential to consider the events leading up to Arthur’s decision to help John. This includes the Van der Linde gang’s activities, the role of Dutch van der Linde, and the pursuit by Pinkerton agents.

The Impact of Player Choice

The player’s decisions throughout the game significantly influence the storyline, including the fate of characters like Arthur and John. Choosing to help John is a pivotal moment that affects the game’s ending and the characters’ outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What happens to Arthur if he goes with John? Arthur uses his final moments to allow John to escape and start a new life with his family, ultimately dying due to his tuberculosis.
2. Does Arthur survive if he goes back for the money? No, Arthur’s survival is not possible, regardless of the player’s choices, due to his terminal illness.
3. Can Arthur’s death be prevented? Unfortunately, there is no cure for tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2, making Arthur’s death inevitable.
4. What can Arthur do that John cannot? Arthur can swim for extended periods, whereas John’s stamina depletes quickly in water, leading to his drowning.
5. Will there be a Red Dead Redemption 3? While there’s no official release date, Rockstar Games has hinted at a potential sequel, possibly arriving around 2026.
6. Why is the RDR2 ending so sad? The ending is sad because, despite the player’s efforts, Arthur Morgan dies, and the story concludes with a sense of loss and finality.
7. Who kills Arthur Morgan? Arthur’s death can be attributed to either Micah Bell or his tuberculosis, depending on the player’s honor level and choices.
8. Can you go to where Arthur died as John? Yes, John can visit Arthur’s grave, which is located on a mountain northeast of Bacchus Bridge, and the grave’s appearance varies based on the player’s honor level.
9. Does John know Micah killed Arthur? It is not explicitly stated whether John knows Micah was directly responsible for Arthur’s death, although he is aware of Micah’s betrayal.
10. Can you get Dutch’s chest as John? If the player chose the honorful option, Dutch’s chest remains in Beaver Hollow, and John can retrieve it.
11. Is John stronger than Arthur in RDR2? While both characters have their strengths, John Marston has an edge in ranged combat and legendary gunslinging abilities.
12. Does John inherit Arthur’s stuff? After completing a few missions in the epilogue, John inherits Arthur’s outfits and weapons, but not his horses.
13. What happens if John goes back to where Arthur died? Visiting significant locations as John can trigger ghostly encounters or other unique events, adding depth to the game’s story.
14. Can you get the rose grey Arabian as Arthur? Yes, the Rose Gray Bay Arabian can be purchased by Arthur for $1,250 at the Blackwater Stable, making it the most expensive horse in the game.
15. How many years pass after Arthur’s death? The epilogue takes place eight years after Arthur’s death, setting the stage for the events of the first Red Dead Redemption game, which occurs just four years later.