Unveiling the Secrets of First Strike and Double Strike in Card Games
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Does double strike stack with first strike? Simply put, no. Multiple instances of double strike or first strike on a creature are redundant. If a creature has both first strike and double strike, it effectively just functions as a creature with double strike. The game rules don’t differentiate between a creature with “first strike and double strike” and one with just “double strike”. It all boils down to the combat damage steps.
Understanding Combat Damage Steps
The core of the matter lies in how combat damage is resolved. In a standard combat scenario, creatures without first strike or double strike deal damage simultaneously in a single combat damage step. However, creatures with first strike or double strike introduce an initial combat damage step where only they (and other creatures with these abilities) deal damage.
A creature with first strike deals its damage in this first combat damage step. If it survives and is still in combat, it deals damage again in the regular combat damage step alongside creatures without these abilities.
A creature with double strike, on the other hand, is a combat powerhouse. It deals damage in both the first strike combat damage step and the regular combat damage step. Having first strike in addition to double strike provides no additional benefit, because the double strike already covers both combat damage steps. You can think of the creature with double strike as already including first strike as part of its functionality.
Why Doesn’t it Stack?
The rules of the game, specifically the comprehensive rules, define how these abilities function (C.R. 702.4e, 702.7d). Redundancy is a common theme in card games. For example, giving a creature flying multiple times doesn’t make it more evasive. Similarly, granting multiple instances of first strike or double strike doesn’t create additional combat damage steps or amplify the effect. The presence of double strike essentially supersedes the need for first strike.
Strategic Implications
While having both abilities doesn’t offer a mechanical advantage, understanding how they interact is crucial for strategic decision-making. Knowing that double strike effectively encompasses first strike allows you to focus on other abilities that synergize well with it, such as trample, lifelink, or deathtouch. This strategic thinking aligns with many of the principles explored by the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org, emphasizing the cognitive benefits of strategic game play.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the nuances of first strike and double strike:
What happens if a creature has both first strike and double strike?
As explained, it functions as if it only had double strike. The first strike ability is essentially redundant.
Does double strike count as two attacks for triggered abilities?
No. An ability that triggers “whenever this creature attacks” will only trigger once, when the creature is declared as an attacker. Double strike causes damage in two separate combat damage steps, but it’s still considered a single attack.
How does double strike interact with trample?
A creature with double strike and trample can assign combat damage to the defending player in both combat damage steps. If the creature destroys the blocker in the first strike damage step, all remaining damage in that step can be assigned to the defending player. The same applies in the regular combat damage step.
Does deathtouch work with double strike?
Yes. A creature with double strike and deathtouch is incredibly potent. It can potentially kill two creatures in combat, one in each combat damage step. Any damage dealt by a creature with deathtouch is considered lethal damage, so even a single point of damage is sufficient to destroy a creature.
Does lifelink work with double strike?
Absolutely. A creature with double strike and lifelink will grant you life twice – once for the damage dealt in the first strike combat damage step and again for the damage dealt in the regular combat damage step. This can result in a significant life gain advantage.
How does indestructible interact with first strike and double strike?
An indestructible creature cannot be destroyed by damage. If an indestructible creature blocks a creature with first strike or double strike, the indestructible creature will still take damage in the first strike combat damage step (and possibly the regular combat damage step). However, it won’t be destroyed as a result of that damage.
If my creature with first strike deals lethal damage to a blocker, does the blocker still deal damage to my creature?
No. If a creature with first strike deals lethal damage to a blocker in the first strike combat damage step, the blocker is destroyed before it has a chance to deal damage in the regular combat damage step. Your creature will survive unscathed.
Can first strike block double strike?
If a creature with first strike blocks a creature with double strike, the first strike creature deals its damage in the first strike combat damage step. If that damage is lethal, the double strike creature is destroyed before it can deal damage in the regular combat damage step. If the first strike damage is not lethal, both creatures will deal damage to each other in the regular combat damage step.
How does double strike interact with fight spells?
First strike and double strike only affect combat damage. Damage dealt during a fight spell, such as “Prey Upon,” is considered non-combat damage. Therefore, these abilities have no effect in a fight scenario.
Does double strike give two instances of a triggered ability that triggers on dealing combat damage?
Yes, a triggered ability that triggers “when this creature deals combat damage” will trigger twice for a creature with double strike, once in each combat damage step where it deals damage. This is because it is dealing combat damage in two separate instances.
Does infect work with double strike to apply double poison counters?
Yes. Infect replaces damage with poison counters. A creature with double strike and infect will deal poison counters twice, once in each combat damage step.
Does first strike beat trample?
If your opponent attacks with a creature with trample and you block with a creature with first strike, your creature deals damage first. If your creature’s damage is lethal, the attacking creature is destroyed before it can deal any damage (trample or otherwise) to you or your creature.
Does hexproof stop deathtouch?
No. Hexproof prevents a creature from being the target of spells or abilities your opponents control. Deathtouch doesn’t target; it’s a static ability that makes any damage dealt by the creature lethal. Therefore, hexproof does not protect a creature from deathtouch.
What happens if two creatures with deathtouch block each other?
If two creatures with deathtouch block each other, they will both deal lethal damage to each other simultaneously (during their combat damage step) and both will be destroyed.
If a creature has double strike and I cast a spell to give it first strike, what happens?
Nothing changes. The creature continues to function as a creature with only double strike, as explained previously. The addition of first strike is redundant and has no additional effect.
#
This thorough breakdown should give you a solid understanding of how first strike and double strike interact, empowering you to make informed decisions in your card games. Remember, mastery of these mechanics is key to strategic success!