Does First Strike Count When Creatures Fight?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is no, first strike does not apply when creatures fight. While first strike is a potent ability in combat, allowing a creature to deal damage before others, this benefit doesn’t extend to situations where creatures are forced to fight via spells or abilities. Let’s delve deeper into why this is the case and explore some related nuances of first strike and fighting in card games like Magic: The Gathering.
Understanding First Strike in Combat
First strike is a keyword ability that fundamentally changes how damage is dealt in a standard combat scenario. In a typical combat step, creatures deal damage to each other simultaneously. However, a creature with first strike deals its combat damage in a separate, earlier damage step. This means it can potentially destroy a creature before that creature can deal its own damage.
How First Strike Works:
- First Strike Damage Step: Creatures with first strike deal their combat damage at this point.
- Regular Combat Damage Step: If any creatures without first strike are still alive, they deal their damage at this stage.
This mechanism can be incredibly advantageous, allowing a first strike creature to “trade up” by potentially killing larger creatures that would otherwise deal damage back.
The Fight Mechanic: A Non-Combat Encounter
The “fight” mechanic is distinct from traditional combat. Rather than attacking or blocking, a fight is often triggered by a spell or activated ability that forces two creatures to battle each other. In a fight:
- Each creature deals damage to the other equal to its power.
- This damage is not considered combat damage.
Because this damage is not considered combat damage, abilities that are linked to combat damage, such as first strike, double strike, and trample do not come into effect during a fight. This is an important distinction.
Why First Strike Doesn’t Apply to Fight:
The core reason first strike doesn’t count when creatures fight boils down to the fact that fight interactions are not considered part of the regular combat phase. They are essentially separate instances where damage is dealt. Therefore, first strike’s timing advantage is irrelevant in a fight scenario.
Related Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Deathtouch Work with Fight?
Yes, absolutely. If a creature with deathtouch fights another creature, any amount of damage it deals will be enough to destroy the other creature. Deathtouch applies to all forms of damage, not just combat damage. Therefore, deathtouch is highly effective when a creature fights.
2. What Happens When a Creature with First Strike Blocks?
A creature with first strike will still deal combat damage before creatures without first strike, even when blocking. This allows the blocker to possibly destroy the attacking creature before taking any damage, making first strike a strong defensive tool.
3. Does a Creature with First Strike Deal Damage Twice?
No, first strike does not cause a creature to deal damage twice. It only causes it to deal its normal combat damage in the first damage step before normal damage is dealt.
4. Does First Strike Beat Deathtouch in Combat?
Yes, a creature with first strike can destroy a creature with deathtouch in combat before the deathtouch creature can deal its damage. This can often lead to a beneficial outcome for the first strike creature as it avoids taking damage itself from the deathtouch creature.
5. Does Lifelink Trigger When Creatures Fight?
Yes, lifelink triggers whenever a creature deals damage, regardless of whether it’s combat or non-combat damage. So, if a creature with lifelink fights another creature, its controller gains life equal to the damage dealt.
6. What Happens if a Creature Has Both First Strike and Double Strike?
Having both first strike and double strike means that the creature will deal damage in both the first-strike damage step (because of first strike), and again during the normal damage step (because of double strike). First strike, in this case, is redundant. The double strike is what’s important.
7. If a Creature Has Double Strike, How Many Times Does it Deal Damage?
A creature with double strike deals combat damage twice: once in the first-strike damage step and once in the regular combat damage step.
8. If a Creature Loses Double Strike After First Strike Damage, Does it Still Deal Damage in the Second Step?
No. If a creature loses double strike during the first combat damage step, it will not deal combat damage in the second combat damage step.
9. Does First Strike Work on Multiple Targets?
First strike does not inherently work on multiple targets. First strike only affects when a creature deals its damage. It deals damage to the single creature it is blocking or being blocked by.
10. Can You Block with Multiple Creatures?
Yes, you can block an attacking creature with multiple creatures, although, in a regular combat scenario, the attacking creature’s damage would be divided among the blockers, based on how the player controlling the attacking creature allocates the damage.
11. What Happens If a Creature Has First Strike and Deathtouch?
A creature with both first strike and deathtouch is a potent combination in combat. It will deal damage first and, because of deathtouch, destroy the creature it hits. It would be very difficult for the other creature to deal any damage back.
12. Does First Strike Beat Trample?
If your opponent has a blocker with first strike, and your attacking creature has trample, but not first strike, their creature deals damage first and has the opportunity to destroy yours before it even gets a chance to deal regular or trample damage. If, however, your trampling creature also has first strike, your trampling creature will deal damage first.
13. Do You Get Priority Between First Strike and Normal Damage?
Yes. Players must pass priority before moving to the next step or phase in the game. Therefore, after the first strike combat damage step has resolved, players can cast spells or activate abilities before the normal combat damage step is entered.
14. Does First Strike Work on Spells that Deal 0 Damage?
The keyword First Strike doesn’t apply to spell damage. It is relevant only to combat damage between creatures. Spells can deal damage whether it is 0, or any other number.
15. What Creatures Commonly Have First Strike?
The most common creature types to have first strike are Knights and Soldiers. These creature types are often depicted as being exceptionally skilled or fast, which aligns with the theme of first strike.
Conclusion
In summary, while first strike is a powerful ability in normal combat, it doesn’t apply when creatures are forced to fight. The fight mechanic is separate from combat, meaning that first strike’s timing advantage is not relevant. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for mastering card games and making strategic plays. Remember the specific rules of both combat and the fight mechanic to maximize your success in your next gaming session!