Does Fist of Suns Stop Commander Tax? The Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
No, Fist of Suns does NOT stop the Commander Tax. While it allows you to cast spells for {WUBRG}, it only provides an alternative cost. The Commander Tax is an additional cost, and Fist of Suns doesn’t negate or replace those. You’ll still need to pay the extra {2} for each previous time you’ve cast your Commander from the Command Zone this game. Think of it this way: Fist of Suns helps with the base mana cost, but the Commander Tax is tacked on top of whatever casting method you choose.
Understanding Commander Tax and Alternative Costs
The interplay between alternative costs and the Commander Tax can be confusing. Let’s break down the core concepts:
-
Commander Tax: This is an additional cost of {2} for each time you’ve previously cast your Commander from the Command Zone during the game. It’s designed to prevent a Commander from being repeatedly cast at the same low cost.
-
Alternative Costs: These are costs that replace a spell’s usual mana cost. Fist of Suns’ ability is a prime example, allowing you to pay {WUBRG} instead of the spell’s printed mana cost.
The key takeaway is that alternative costs only affect the base cost of the spell. Additional costs, such as the Commander Tax, still apply. Fist of Suns gives you a different way to pay the mana, but it doesn’t eliminate the requirement to pay extra due to the Commander Tax.
Navigating Complex Interactions
Magic: The Gathering is full of intricacies, and interactions between cards can get complex. Understanding the order of operations when casting a spell is crucial for determining how the Commander Tax interacts with alternative costs.
- Announce the Spell: You declare that you are casting a spell and put it on the stack.
- Choose Modes, Targets, and Divisions: If the spell has any modes or requires targets, you choose them at this point.
- Determine Total Cost: This is where things get interesting. The total cost is determined as follows:
- Start with the mana cost or alternative cost (e.g., {WUBRG} from Fist of Suns).
- Add any additional costs (e.g., the Commander Tax).
- Apply any cost reductions or increases.
- Activate Mana Abilities: You activate mana abilities to generate the mana needed to pay the total cost.
- Pay the Total Cost: You pay the total cost in the order specified.
- The Spell Resolves: If all goes well, your spell resolves and does what it’s supposed to do.
Because the Commander Tax is added to the cost after the alternative cost is applied, Fist of Suns will not negate it.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Rooftop Storm ignore Commander Tax?
No. Rooftop Storm provides an alternative cost to cast Zombie spells, but it doesn’t waive additional costs like the Commander Tax. You must still pay the Commander Tax when casting your Zombie Commander from the Command Zone, even if you’re using Rooftop Storm’s ability.
2. Does casting my Commander “without paying its mana cost” avoid the Commander Tax?
No. Casting a spell “without paying its mana cost” simply means you don’t pay the listed mana symbols. It doesn’t eliminate additional costs like the Commander Tax. You must still pay the Commander Tax, even if you’re using an effect that lets you cast your Commander for free.
3. Does Yuriko, the Tiger’s Shadow, bypass Commander Tax?
Yuriko, the Tiger’s Shadow‘s Ninjutsu ability does bypass the Commander Tax. This is because Ninjutsu isn’t casting the Commander; it’s an activated ability that puts the Commander directly onto the battlefield. Since you aren’t casting Yuriko from the Command Zone, the Commander Tax doesn’t apply.
4. Can Powerstones pay for Commander Tax?
Powerstones can only pay for the Commander Tax if your Commander is an Artifact spell. Powerstones produce colorless mana, which can pay for generic mana costs. Since the Commander Tax is a generic mana cost, Powerstones can contribute towards paying it, provided your Commander is an artifact.
5. If my Commander dies and goes to the graveyard, does the Commander Tax reset?
No. The Commander Tax doesn’t reset when your Commander dies. The Commander Tax increases each time you cast your Commander from the Command Zone during the game, regardless of where it goes afterward. Sending it to the graveyard (or hand, library, etc.) doesn’t erase the record of it being cast.
6. Does Commander Tax apply to both sides of a double-faced Commander?
Yes. The Commander Tax is applicable to the card itself, regardless of which face you cast. Casting either face increases the Commander Tax for subsequent castings of either face.
7. Can you proliferate the Commander Tax to affect opponents?
No. You cannot proliferate the Commander Tax. Proliferate only affects counters on permanents or players. The Commander Tax is an additional cost, not a counter, so it’s not affected by proliferate.
8. Does Leadership Vacuum reset the Commander Tax?
No, Leadership Vacuum does not reset the Commander Tax. The tax increases based on how many times a commander was cast from the command zone, not on how many times it was returned there.
9. What happens if my Commander gets exiled?
If your Commander would be exiled, you can choose to put it into the Command Zone instead. This is a replacement effect, and you can choose to apply it each time your Commander would be exiled or put into your hand, graveyard, or library.
10. Can you counterspell a Commander?
Yes, you can counterspell a Commander spell. If the spell is countered, it will go to the graveyard, unless the owner chooses to return it to the Command Zone instead. If the owner chooses to send it back to the Command Zone, the Commander Tax still applies if they cast it again later.
11. Does Commander Tax apply if I put my Commander onto the battlefield without casting it?
No. The Commander Tax only applies when you cast your Commander from the Command Zone. If you use an effect to put your Commander onto the battlefield without casting it, such as Ninjutsu or Reanimate, you don’t have to pay the Commander Tax, and it doesn’t increase the tax for future castings.
12. Is Commander Tax considered mana?
No, Commander Tax is not mana. It’s an additional cost represented by a generic mana value ({2} for each prior casting from the Command Zone). This distinction is important because some cards interact specifically with mana costs, while others interact with additional costs.
13. If I cast a Commander using a Mutate cost, does Commander Tax apply?
Yes, Commander Tax applies when casting a Commander using its Mutate cost from the command zone. Mutate represents an alternative cost to cast the creature, and the tax is an additional cost that must be paid.
14. Does Command Beacon remove Commander Tax?
Command Beacon allows you to return your commander to your hand, and subsequently cast it from your hand instead of the command zone. By casting your commander from your hand, you will not be required to pay the commander tax.
15. Where can I learn more about the rules of Magic: The Gathering?
There are tons of great resources! For a more relaxed and fun approach to learning board games and potentially finding some tips for MtG, check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org. Their website offers engaging content and resources to enhance your understanding of various games and their complexities.
Conclusion
While Fist of Suns is a powerful card for enabling multi-colored decks, it doesn’t provide a loophole around the Commander Tax. Understanding the difference between alternative costs and additional costs is crucial for navigating the complexities of Commander gameplay. Always remember to factor in the Commander Tax when planning your plays, and you’ll be well on your way to dominating the battlefield!