Grave Pact and Tokens: A Necromantic Nuance
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is yes, Grave Pact’s ability does trigger when tokens are sent to the graveyard. The key is understanding the fleeting existence of tokens in Magic: The Gathering (MTG).
When a creature, token or otherwise, you control dies, Grave Pact triggers, forcing each opponent to sacrifice a creature. The token does briefly enter the graveyard, long enough to satisfy the triggered ability of Grave Pact. State-Based Actions (SBAs) are then checked, and one of these actions causes tokens in the graveyard to cease to exist. It’s a quick in-and-out, but a legally effective one for triggering Grave Pact. Let’s delve deeper into the interactions of tokens and the graveyard with some frequently asked questions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Tokens and the Graveyard
Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate the complex world of tokens and their relationship with the graveyard:
1. Does Grave Betrayal work on tokens?
No, Grave Betrayal does not work on tokens. The timing is crucial. Tokens hit the graveyard, triggering Grave Betrayal. However, State-Based Actions are checked before Grave Betrayal’s delayed triggered ability resolves at the end of the turn. Since tokens cease to exist as an SBA, there’s nothing for Grave Betrayal to bring back. They “poof” out of existence before they can be reanimated.
2. Do tokens go to the graveyard?
Yes, tokens do go to the graveyard. This is a critical point. They don’t skip the graveyard and go straight to oblivion. This brief sojourn is vital for triggering abilities like Grave Pact. After triggering abilities, they immediately cease to exist as a State-Based Action.
3. Can you exile a token from a graveyard?
Technically, you can attempt to target a token in the graveyard with an exile effect. However, you cannot actually exile a token from a graveyard. Tokens cease to exist as a State-Based Action before any exile effect could move it. Rule 110.5g makes it clear: “A token that has left the battlefield can’t move to another zone or come back onto the battlefield.”
4. Does sacrificing a token creature count as it dying?
Yes, absolutely. Sacrificing a token creature counts as it dying. “Dying” in MTG terminology means “being put from the battlefield into the graveyard.” Whether the creature goes there because of damage, destruction, sacrifice, or any other effect, it’s considered to have “died.” Therefore, sacrificing a token triggers any “when a creature dies” abilities.
5. Can you sacrifice a Blood token?
Yes, you can sacrifice a Blood token. Unlike some older token types, Blood tokens are designed to be sacrificed for value. They add versatility to decks, allowing you to trade in unwanted cards for new draws. Remember that Blood tokens typically require tapping before they can be sacrificed, as specified on the token itself.
6. Does sacrificing a Treasure token send it to the graveyard?
Yes, sacrificing a Treasure token does send it to the graveyard. Just like other tokens, they briefly reside there before disappearing. This triggers “enters the graveyard” effects, but importantly, they don’t count as cards in your graveyard for effects that count the number of cards there.
7. Does Profane Memento trigger on tokens?
No, Profane Memento does not trigger on tokens. The card specifically states that it triggers when a nontoken creature an opponent owns dies. Tokens simply don’t count.
8. Does exiling a token destroy it?
Exiling a token doesn’t destroy it; it causes it to cease to exist. Tokens cease to exist immediately after leaving the battlefield, no matter the destination. So, while technically the game attempts to move it to exile, the token vanishes instantly as a State-Based Action.
9. Does Raphael, Fiendish Savior trigger off tokens?
No, Raphael, Fiendish Savior does not trigger off tokens. Raphael specifically cares about creature cards entering the graveyard from anywhere. Tokens aren’t cards.
10. Do tokens ever touch the graveyard?
Yes, tokens absolutely touch the graveyard. It’s a fleeting touch, but it’s real and crucial for triggering abilities. They move to the graveyard and linger just long enough for State-Based Actions to be checked, at which point they vanish.
11. Do tokens come back with Undying?
Tokens can gain Undying, and the Undying ability will trigger when the token is put into the graveyard. However, the token won’t return to the battlefield. Since tokens can’t return to the battlefield once they’ve left it, they cease to exist before the Undying ability would attempt to put them back.
12. Do tokens count for Fraying Sanity?
No, tokens do not count for Fraying Sanity. Fraying Sanity triggers when a card is put into an opponent’s graveyard from anywhere. Tokens aren’t cards, therefore they do not trigger this ability.
13. Do tokens trigger Desecrated Tomb?
No, tokens do not trigger Desecrated Tomb. Desecrated Tomb’s ability triggers when one or more creature cards leave your graveyard. Tokens aren’t cards, so they don’t trigger Desecrated Tomb’s ability when they cease to exist there.
14. Does Marionette Master trigger on tokens?
Yes, Marionette Master can trigger on tokens, but with a specific condition. The trigger depends on artifact tokens being sacrificed or destroyed. Because the Marionette Master’s ability triggers from your artifacts being put into the graveyard, if you control an artifact token that dies, the ability will trigger.
15. Do tokens trigger Thornbite Staff?
Yes, tokens do trigger death effects like Thornbite Staff. The staff cares about a creature dying, and as we discussed, tokens dying satisfy that condition.
Why This Matters: Strategic Implications
Understanding the interaction between tokens and the graveyard, especially concerning cards like Grave Pact, is crucial for strategic gameplay. It allows you to maximize the value of your token-generating strategies, leveraging them to control the board and disrupt your opponents’ plans. Knowing that your tokens will trigger Grave Pact lets you build powerful decks that punish your opponents for playing creatures.
Want to learn more about the intricacies of game design and the educational power of games? Visit the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ to discover fascinating research and resources. Understanding these rules enables more complex strategic decision-making during the game.
This knowledge also empowers you to build more informed decks and execute more effective strategies.