Does It Matter What Dark Souls You Play First? A Deep Dive into FromSoftware’s Masterpiece
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer? It depends on what you’re looking for in your Dark Souls experience. While there isn’t a strict, linear narrative that demands sequential play, understanding the nuances, lore, and recurring themes is significantly enhanced by tackling the games in a specific order. Ultimately, the “best” order is subjective and depends on your priorities: story comprehension, difficulty curve, or simply jumping into the newest and flashiest title.
Understanding the Interconnected, Yet Independent, Worlds
The Dark Souls trilogy, along with Demon’s Souls, Bloodborne, and Elden Ring, exists in a unique space within video game lore. They are connected by shared themes of cyclical decay, the burden of power, and the futility of clinging to the past. However, each title tells its own largely self-contained story with new characters, environments, and specific mythologies.
The article mentioned that “Since the Souls games are almost entirely separate entities with very little shared between each game, it weakens the argument for using chronological order.” This is true on a surface level. You can pick up Dark Souls 3 without ever having touched the first two and still enjoy the core gameplay loop: challenging combat, exploration, and boss encounters.
However, this perspective overlooks the subtle but pervasive ways in which the games build upon each other. Dark Souls 3, in particular, is steeped in references to the first game. Locations, characters, and even specific enemy designs are callbacks that resonate far more deeply with players who have experienced the original Dark Souls. Playing in order unlocks a deeper layer of appreciation. As the author of the original text stated, “Dark Souls 3 has a lot of references to dark souls 2 you won’t get if you don’t play it first.”
The Case for Playing in Release Order
For many, starting with Demon’s Souls (the spiritual predecessor) and proceeding through Dark Souls 1, 2, and 3 is the ideal approach. Here’s why:
- Narrative Appreciation: As mentioned earlier, understanding the overarching lore and the fate of characters and locations from previous games significantly enhances the experience of later titles. Dark Souls 3, in particular, is practically a love letter to the original. As stated by the author, “DS3 is practically the sequel of DS1… DS3 story can only be understood by first understanding the story of DS1.”
- Mechanical Evolution: The games’ mechanics have evolved and been refined over time. Starting with Demon’s Souls or Dark Souls 1 exposes you to the simpler, more deliberate combat and design philosophies of the earlier titles. Progressing chronologically allows you to appreciate the refinements and additions introduced in later installments.
- Difficulty Curve (Sort Of): While subjective, many players find that the older games are more punishing in certain ways (e.g., limited fast travel in Dark Souls 1). Starting with these games forces you to learn the core principles of patience, observation, and adaptability that are essential for success in the entire series.
- Avoiding Spoilers: Playing in release order minimizes your exposure to spoilers, ensuring that you experience the twists and turns of each game’s story firsthand.
The Case for Starting with Dark Souls 3 or Elden Ring
Despite the advantages of playing in release order, there are valid reasons to start with a later entry, such as Dark Souls 3 or Elden Ring:
- Accessibility and Polish: Dark Souls 3 and Elden Ring are arguably the most polished and accessible entries in the series. They boast refined combat mechanics, smoother performance, and more forgiving design choices than their predecessors. The author of the original text stated, “Veterans of Dark Souls and hardcore fans will suggest playing the first game, but in reality, it’s perfectly fine to start with Dark Souls 3.”
- Modern Presentation: Newer titles have superior graphics and sound design, which can be a significant factor for players accustomed to modern gaming standards.
- Population and Online Features: Later entries tend to have larger player bases, meaning it’s easier to find co-op partners and engage in PvP activities.
- Instant Gratification: Jumping into a newer, more visually impressive game can be more immediately rewarding and captivating, potentially sparking a deeper interest in the series as a whole.
The Importance of Choosing What Is Right for You
There is no singular “right” way to approach the Dark Souls series. Ultimately, the best starting point depends on your individual preferences and priorities. If you value narrative coherence and a sense of progression, begin with Demon’s Souls or Dark Souls 1. If you prioritize accessibility and visual appeal, Dark Souls 3 or Elden Ring might be a better choice.
No matter where you start, be prepared for a challenging and rewarding experience that will test your skills and patience. The Dark Souls series is more than just a collection of difficult games; it’s a profound exploration of the human condition, told through intricate world-building, challenging combat, and unforgettable boss encounters. You can learn more about the significance of gaming from the Games Learning Society website.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Should I play Demon’s Souls before Dark Souls?
While not essential, playing Demon’s Souls provides valuable context and an understanding of the series’ origins. It’s also slightly easier than the Dark Souls games, making it a good entry point.
2. Is Dark Souls 2 essential to understanding Dark Souls 3?
Not essential, but it enriches the experience. Dark Souls 3 contains references and callbacks to Dark Souls 2, but the main storyline is understandable without prior knowledge.
3. Is Elden Ring a good starting point for Souls-like games?
Yes! Elden Ring is more accessible than many Souls games and provides a great introduction to the genre’s core mechanics.
4. Which Dark Souls game is the easiest?
This is subjective, but many consider Dark Souls 3 or Elden Ring to be the easiest due to their refined mechanics and more forgiving design. As the author of the original text stated, “Many players would say that Dark Souls 2 was the easiest in the series.” However, many more believe Dark Souls 2 to be the hardest.
5. Which Dark Souls game is the hardest?
Again, subjective. Some find Dark Souls 2: Scholar of the First Sin the hardest due to its unique level design and enemy placement. Others believe Dark Souls 1 is the most difficult due to its limited fast travel and unforgiving early game.
6. Does the story connect across all the Dark Souls games?
Loosely. They share a common world and lore but tell distinct stories with different characters and conflicts.
7. Can I skip Dark Souls 1 and go straight to Dark Souls 3?
Yes, but you’ll miss out on many references and the satisfaction of seeing how the world evolved.
8. Is Dark Souls 3 a direct sequel to Dark Souls 1?
Yes, in terms of world and lore. Dark Souls 3 revisits locations and themes from the first game.
9. Is it better to play Dark Souls in chronological order?
For the most comprehensive narrative experience, yes. But it’s not a requirement.
10. Are all the Soulsborne games connected?
The Dark Souls trilogy, Demon’s Souls, Bloodborne, and Elden Ring exist in their own universes but share similar gameplay mechanics and thematic elements.
11. Is Bloodborne harder than Dark Souls?
Many find Bloodborne harder due to its faster combat and emphasis on aggressive play.
12. What makes Dark Souls so difficult?
Challenging combat, unforgiving enemy placement, intricate level design, and a lack of hand-holding.
13. Should I play with a guide on my first Dark Souls playthrough?
It’s a personal choice. Some prefer to explore and discover things on their own, while others find a guide helpful to avoid frustration.
14. Is Dark Souls 2 worth playing?
Despite its criticisms, Dark Souls 2 offers unique gameplay mechanics and a distinct atmosphere. Many appreciate its PvP and unconventional level design.
15. What is the best way to prepare for a Dark Souls game?
Be patient, learn from your mistakes, and don’t be afraid to ask for help. Embrace the challenge and enjoy the journey!
The GamesLearningSociety.org website has a great community that can also help you on your journey.