Does John Keep Arthur’s Guns in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, John Marston does indeed keep Arthur Morgan’s guns in Red Dead Redemption 2. Upon reaching the epilogue, John automatically retrieves Arthur’s weapons, clothing, and other equipment. This is a crucial element in the storyline that sets the stage for John’s life after Arthur’s death and seamlessly connects the narrative to the original Red Dead Redemption. However, Arthur’s money, food, and consumables do not transfer to John, as this reflects the Marston family’s initial financial struggles. This ensures the gameplay aligns with the narrative, providing a compelling and immersive experience for the player.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About John Marston and Arthur’s Possessions
1. Does John inherit all of Arthur’s belongings?
While John inherits Arthur’s guns, clothing, and some valuable items like jewelry, gold bars, and cigarette cards, he does not receive Arthur’s cash or consumable items. The transfer focuses on essential gear needed for survival and combat, while the financial aspects are addressed through the storyline.
2. What happens to Arthur’s horses?
Unfortunately, Arthur’s horses do not transfer to John. When Arthur dies, he loses all his horses, including any exceptionally rare or well-bonded ones. This is one of the more poignant losses in the game, forcing players to start anew with horse bonding as John.
3. Does Arthur’s cash transfer to John?
No, Arthur’s cash does not transfer to John. This narrative choice underscores the financial hardships that John and his family face early in the epilogue. Players must rebuild their wealth through missions, hunting, and other activities.
4. Does John get to keep Arthur’s outfits and clothes?
Yes, John receives all of Arthur’s outfits and clothes. This allows players to maintain some continuity in their gameplay style and appearance, although some outfits may need to be re-acquired or modified to fit John.
5. What valuable items does John inherit from Arthur?
John inherits valuable items like jewelry, gold bars, and cigarette cards from Arthur. These items can be sold to provide John with a substantial financial boost at the beginning of the epilogue, making the transition somewhat smoother.
6. Can John retrieve Arthur’s lost money from the Aberdeen pig farm?
Yes, if you intentionally left your money at the Aberdeen pig farm as Arthur, you can retrieve it as John in the epilogue. This provides a significant amount of money to alleviate John’s financial struggles.
7. Does John get Arthur’s satchel?
While the game doesn’t explicitly show John inheriting Arthur’s satchel, it is implied that he does. The satchel’s benefits, such as increased inventory capacity, are maintained through the transition, suggesting John receives it with other belongings.
8. Can John tame the White Arabian horse that Arthur had?
Yes, John can re-tame the White Arabian horse at Lake Isabella even if Arthur owned it previously. The White Arabian will respawn, allowing John to acquire this magnificent creature.
9. Does John get the Blackwater money?
While not directly “Blackwater money,” John finds a chest left by Dutch during “American Venom,” which is assumed to be the Blackwater money or at least a portion of it. John splits this money with Charles and Sadie, providing a substantial financial reward.
10. What happens to Arthur’s food and tonics?
Arthur’s food and tonics do not transfer to John. Players need to replenish their supplies as John, reflecting the Marston family’s initial state of hardship.
11. Can John find Dutch’s hidden stash in Beaver Hollow?
Yes, if you chose the honorable option during the final encounter with Dutch and Micah, Dutch’s chest will remain untouched in Beaver Hollow. John can go back and find it, potentially containing valuable items.
12. Does John’s gameplay experience change significantly after inheriting Arthur’s gear?
While John inherits gear, the gameplay dynamics shift. Players must rebuild relationships, re-explore the world, and engage in new storylines. John’s character and motivations provide a fresh perspective on the game, even with Arthur’s equipment.
13. Is there any way to keep Arthur alive?
Unfortunately, there is no way to prevent Arthur from dying. His death is a crucial part of the story, and the game is structured to ensure this outcome. However, players can prolong Arthur’s journey by not progressing through the main story missions and instead enjoying the open world.
14. Why can’t John swim in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Canonically, John Marston never learned how to swim. This is a consistent trait across both Red Dead Redemption games and explains why John struggles in water in RDR2.
15. Why isn’t Arthur mentioned in Red Dead Redemption?
The game developers likely chose not to mention Arthur in RDR1 to avoid overshadowing John’s story. Also, as the article suggests, it may be too painful to recall memories of Arthur. Arthur’s role was created retrospectively to enhance John’s backstory, making his omission in the original game understandable. You might also find interesting content related to games and learning on the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ or GamesLearningSociety.org.
Additional Notes
The transition from Arthur to John is a pivotal moment in Red Dead Redemption 2, marking a shift in narrative focus and gameplay experience. While John inherits essential items and equipment, the loss of other possessions emphasizes the struggles and challenges he faces as he attempts to build a new life for himself and his family. This careful balance between continuity and change contributes to the game’s rich storytelling and emotional impact.