Does Red Dead Redemption 2 Have Multiple Endings? A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, Red Dead Redemption 2 absolutely has multiple endings. While the core storyline remains consistent, the game offers variations based on your honor level and a crucial decision made during the final chapters as Arthur Morgan. These choices dictate the circumstances surrounding Arthur’s demise and provide distinct emotional impacts, solidifying RDR2’s reputation for narrative depth. Let’s explore the nuances of these endings and related questions.
Understanding RDR2’s Endings
RDR2 doesn’t just offer a single conclusion; it provides a spectrum of endings, largely determined by Arthur’s honor and the choices you make. Here’s a breakdown:
Honor System’s Impact
The honor system in RDR2 plays a significant role in shaping Arthur’s story. Engaging in honorable deeds (helping strangers, completing chores, releasing caught fish) increases honor, while dishonorable actions (killing innocents, robbing townsfolk) decrease it.
The Crossroads: Helping John vs. Seeking Revenge
The climax of Arthur’s story presents a critical choice:
- Helping John Marston Escape: Choosing to help John leads to the “good” or honorable ending. Arthur dedicates his final moments to ensuring John and his family have a chance at a better life.
- Seeking Revenge: Opting to go back for the money triggers the “bad” or dishonorable ending. Arthur is driven by greed and vengeance in his last moments.
The Final Confrontation and Arthur’s Death
Regardless of the choice, Arthur ultimately faces Micah Bell. The final showdown and Arthur’s death scene vary depending on his honor.
- High Honor: Arthur succumbs to his tuberculosis (TB) while watching the sunrise, finding peace knowing he did what he could to save John.
- Low Honor: Micah executes Arthur in a brutal and unceremonious manner.
The Epilogue
Following Arthur’s death, the game shifts to an epilogue where you play as John Marston. While the epilogue’s core events remain the same, the emotional weight is impacted by the ending you achieved with Arthur.
Red Dead Redemption 2: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How many endings are in RDR2, not including the secret one?
There are two primary endings tied to Arthur’s choices and honor: the honorable ending (helping John) and the dishonorable ending (seeking revenge). The ending that you achieve will depend on the honor system.
2. Does RDR2 have a secret ending?
Yes, a short “secret” or 100% completion ending exists. After achieving 100% completion of the game, John visits Arthur’s grave. This scene provides a sense of closure and reflects on Arthur’s legacy.
3. What is considered the “best” ending for RDR2?
Most players consider the high-honor ending (helping John) the “best” ending. It aligns with Arthur’s character development, where he strives for redemption and sacrifices himself for the well-being of others.
4. Can you finish RDR2 without Arthur dying?
No. Arthur’s death is a pivotal and unavoidable event in the main story of RDR2. His illness and the narrative arc necessitate his passing. The only way to keep Arthur “alive” is to halt story progression before he contracts TB.
5. Can you cure Arthur’s TB in RDR2?
Sadly, no. There is no cure for tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2. Arthur’s illness is a fixed plot point and a driving force behind his character development.
6. Can you avoid Arthur getting TB altogether?
You cannot completely avoid Arthur contracting tuberculosis. The mission at the Downes Ranch is a mandatory part of the story progression, leading to Arthur’s infection. You can delay his infection by delaying the mission at the Downes Ranch, but there is no escaping it.
7. Will there be a Red Dead Redemption 3 (RDR3)?
While Rockstar Games hasn’t officially announced RDR3, the immense success of the previous games suggests it’s highly likely. Based on the past release patterns, RDR3 could be released around 2026 at the earliest.
8. Who kills Arthur Morgan in each ending?
- High Honor Ending: Arthur succumbs to his tuberculosis, dying peacefully while watching the sunrise.
- Low Honor Ending: Micah Bell executes Arthur.
9. Does John Marston eventually kill Micah in RDR2?
Yes. In the epilogue, playing as John Marston, you eventually track down and kill Micah Bell, avenging Arthur’s death and bringing closure to the story.
10. How did Arthur contract tuberculosis?
Arthur contracts tuberculosis from Thomas Downes at the Downes Ranch. Arthur shook him down for money for the gang, unaware that Downes was afflicted with the disease.
11. Can John inherit Arthur’s money or possessions?
Mechanically, Arthur’s possessions are not directly transferred to John. However, some workarounds and in-game mechanics allow for transferring a significant amount of money to John. Most notably by doing the Aberdeen Pig Farm side mission.
12. Why was Arthur’s death so impactful for players?
Arthur’s character development, his struggle with morality, and his terminal illness created a deep connection with players. His sacrifice and the emotional weight of his passing made his death one of the most memorable and heartbreaking moments in gaming.
13. Did Dutch know that Micah was a rat?
It’s a point of debate. While some argue Dutch suspected Micah, his ego and declining mental state likely prevented him from fully acknowledging the betrayal until it was too late. Dutch shot Micah, in a way, to avenge his friend, Arthur.
14. What year is Red Dead Redemption 2 set in?
Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in 1899, a period marked by the decline of the Wild West and the rise of modern society.
15. Can you prevent the death of other gang members, such as Lenny?
No, the deaths of key gang members like Lenny Summers are scripted and cannot be prevented. They are integral to the narrative and the downfall of the Van der Linde gang. Learning about video games from the Games Learning Society can enhance understanding of narrative structures such as this one. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to find out more about the interplay between games and education.
Conclusion
Red Dead Redemption 2 masterfully weaves together a complex narrative with choices that genuinely matter. The multiple endings, influenced by your actions and honor, contribute significantly to the game’s replayability and emotional depth. While Arthur’s fate is sealed, the manner in which he meets it and the legacy he leaves behind are ultimately shaped by the player. This profound impact on the narrative is a hallmark of RDR2’s brilliance.