Does Solaire Go Hollow? Unraveling the Fate of Dark Souls’ Beloved Sun Bro

▶

Yes, Solaire of Astora can indeed go hollow in Dark Souls. However, his descent into hollowing is conditional and avoidable, making his fate one of the most discussed and emotionally charged aspects of the game’s lore. Whether he succumbs to the darkness depends entirely on the player’s actions, adding a layer of player agency to his already compelling story. If the player does not take certain steps to protect him, Solaire will be found in Lost Izalith, having been driven mad and donning a Sunlight Maggot that he perceives as his “sun.” In this state, he becomes hostile and must be defeated. Preventing this tragic outcome requires careful planning and a significant investment of resources.

The Tragic Allure of Hollowing

Hollowing, in the context of Dark Souls, is more than just a gameplay mechanic; it’s a thematic representation of despair, loss of purpose, and the slow erosion of the self. It’s a fate that befalls many characters in the game, often as a result of unfulfilled goals, profound loss, or the crushing weight of the undead curse. Solaire’s potential hollowing is particularly poignant because he is one of the few consistently optimistic and helpful characters in the game, making his possible descent into madness all the more heartbreaking. Understanding the mechanics of hollowing in Dark Souls is key to understanding Solaire’s potential fate. The cycle of death and rebirth, combined with the lack of a clear purpose, drives many undead to lose their humanity, eventually becoming hollow shells of their former selves.

Understanding Solaire’s Quest

Solaire’s entire motivation for venturing to Lordran is his burning desire to find his own sun. This personal quest drives him forward, giving him a sense of purpose and preventing him from hollowing. However, this also makes him vulnerable. His unwavering focus on this singular goal blinds him to the true nature of his circumstances, making him susceptible to manipulation and deception. The Sunlight Maggot, a parasitic creature that emits a faint glow, preys on this desire. When Solaire encounters it, his desperate search leads him to mistake it for his longed-for sun, resulting in his tragic transformation.

Preventing the Inevitable: Saving Solaire

Fortunately, Solaire’s fate is not sealed. The player can intervene to prevent his hollowing by taking specific actions in the Demon Ruins and Lost Izalith. The key is to unlock a shortcut leading to a chamber containing nine Chaos Bugs, one of which is red-eyed. This red-eyed bug is the Sunlight Maggot that will eventually infect Solaire. By killing this bug before encountering Solaire in Lost Izalith, the player can ensure that he remains sane.

Unlocking this shortcut requires joining the Chaos Servant Covenant and offering 30 humanity to the Fair Lady, Quelaag’s sister. This is a significant investment, requiring players to farm humanity from enemies or rely on cooperative play. However, the reward is well worth the effort, as it not only saves Solaire but also opens up new areas and content within the game.

If the player succeeds in killing the Sunlight Maggot, Solaire will be found in Lost Izalith, still sane and grateful for the player’s help. He will express confusion and relief at not finding his “sun” in that place. This allows him to continue his quest alongside the player, culminating in the option to summon him for the final boss fight against Gwyn, Lord of Cinder.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Solaire’s Fate

Here are some commonly asked questions about Solaire’s journey and the possibility of him going hollow:

1. How do I stop my Solaire from going hollow? The most reliable way is to join the Chaos Servant Covenant, offer 30 humanity to the Fair Lady to open the shortcut in the Demon Ruins, and then kill the red-eyed Sunlight Maggot within that shortcut before you encounter Solaire in Lost Izalith.

2. Can I save Solaire after he goes insane? No, once Solaire is found wearing the Sunlight Maggot in Lost Izalith, he is permanently insane and hostile. The only recourse is to defeat him.

3. What happens to Solaire if I save him? If saved, Solaire remains sane and grateful. He can be summoned for the final boss fight against Gwyn, Lord of Cinder, providing valuable assistance and companionship.

4. What is the canon ending for Solaire? The “canon” ending is subjective, but many believe that Solaire eventually succeeds in linking the First Flame in his own world, potentially explaining the nods to his character in later Dark Souls games. This aligns with the overall theme of hope and perseverance in the face of overwhelming darkness. The Games Learning Society explores these kinds of themes extensively through game design and analysis.

5. Why did Solaire become undead? Solaire became undead of his own volition. He ventured to Lordran in search of his own sun, not as a result of the curse itself, but as a willing participant seeking to fulfill his personal quest.

6. What happens if Solaire dies in a boss fight when summoned as a phantom? If Solaire dies when summoned as a phantom, it does not affect his questline or his ultimate fate. It simply means his phantom is no longer available for that particular fight. His real self is still present in the game world, assuming you have taken steps to protect him from hollowing.

7. How many times can you summon Knight Solaire? Solaire can be summoned for multiple boss fights throughout the game, including the Gargoyles, Ornstein & Smough, and (if saved) Gwyn, Lord of Cinder.

8. Can you get Solaire’s armor without killing him? No, the only way to obtain Solaire’s armor and weapons is by defeating him. This is most often done after he has gone hollow in Lost Izalith, but it is also possible to kill him at any point in his questline.

9. How much humanity does it take to save Solaire? It takes 30 humanity to offer to the Fair Lady, which unlocks the shortcut to kill the Sunlight Maggot.

10. Why does Solaire turn into a worm? This is a common misconception fueled by fan theories. Solaire does not turn into a worm in the established lore. This theory often stems from the existence of the sandworm in the Smouldering Lake, but there’s no concrete evidence to support a connection between it and Solaire.

11. Why is Solaire looking for a sun? Solaire’s search for his own sun is a metaphor for his personal quest for meaning and purpose in the world. It represents his desire to achieve something great and become as “grossly incandescent” as he admires.

12. Did Solaire link the First Flame? Whether Solaire successfully linked the First Flame is not explicitly stated in the game, but it is a popular and widely accepted theory among fans. His influence and legacy can be seen in subsequent Dark Souls games, suggesting that he did indeed achieve his goal.

13. Is Solaire the Nameless King? No, this is another popular fan theory that has been largely debunked by the official lore and information revealed in Dark Souls III.

14. Where does Solaire go crazy? Solaire goes insane in Lost Izalith if the player fails to kill the Sunlight Maggot beforehand. He will be found wearing the maggot and will immediately attack the player.

15. Does killing Solaire break covenant? Killing Solaire will not break any covenants, but it does mean you can no longer summon him for assistance.

The Enduring Legacy of Solaire

Solaire’s character resonates deeply with players due to his unwavering optimism, his helpful nature, and the potential tragedy of his fate. His story serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of hope, purpose, and the bonds of friendship in a world filled with despair. The fact that players have the agency to determine his ultimate destiny adds another layer of complexity to his character and highlights the themes of choice and consequence that are central to the Dark Souls experience. His famous line, “Praise the Sun!” has become an iconic phrase within the gaming community, embodying his spirit of camaraderie and hope.

Whether Solaire ultimately finds his sun or succumbs to the darkness, his impact on the world of Dark Souls and the players who experience it is undeniable. His journey serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of hope and the enduring power of friendship in the face of overwhelming darkness. It is this blend of light and shadow that makes Solaire one of the most beloved and enduring characters in the Dark Souls universe. You can learn more about game design principles and how characters like Solaire impact player experience at GamesLearningSociety.org.