Does the Empire Win in Skyrim? A Deep Dive into the Civil War
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, the Empire is likely to win the Civil War in Skyrim in the long run, even if the Dragonborn throws their weight behind the Stormcloaks. While player choices drastically impact the immediate outcome of the conflict within the game, several factors suggest Imperial dominance as the more probable scenario in the grand scheme of Elder Scrolls lore. This conclusion hinges on strategic advantages, resource availability, and political realities extending beyond the borders of Skyrim itself.
The Short-Term Effects of Player Choice
The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim empowers players to shape the war’s trajectory. By aligning with either the Imperial Legion or the Stormcloaks, you actively participate in battles, capture forts, and influence Jarls’ allegiances. A Dragonborn dedicated to the Stormcloak cause can indeed secure victory for Ulfric and his rebellion, leading to an independent Skyrim. However, this represents a localized outcome, one that doesn’t necessarily reflect the broader geopolitical landscape.
Immediate Outcomes Based on Faction Choice
- Imperial Victory: If the player joins the Imperial Legion and successfully completes the war questline, the Empire retains control of Skyrim. Pro-Imperial Jarls are reinstated, and Ulfric Stormcloak is defeated.
- Stormcloak Victory: Conversely, siding with the Stormcloaks and winning the war results in Ulfric establishing an independent Skyrim. Imperial-aligned Jarls are replaced, and Skyrim is no longer considered an Imperial province.
Long-Term Lore and the Bigger Picture
Despite the player’s ability to swing the balance, the game’s internal lore, external factors, and the general narrative direction of the Elder Scrolls series point towards a eventual Imperial victory.
Imperial Advantages
- Resources and Manpower: The Empire, despite its weakened state following the Great War with the Aldmeri Dominion, still commands significant resources and manpower throughout Cyrodiil. Skyrim, even united under the Stormcloaks, simply cannot compete with the Empire’s capacity for prolonged warfare.
- Strategic Position: The Empire controls Cyrodiil, a strategically vital province bordering Skyrim. This provides a logistical advantage, allowing them to reinforce their presence and exert influence more effectively than the isolated Stormcloaks.
- The Thalmor Threat: The threat of the Aldmeri Dominion looms large. While Ulfric seeks freedom from the Empire, his actions weaken the only force capable of posing a unified resistance to the Thalmor. A divided Tamriel is exactly what the Thalmor want, and an independent Skyrim plays directly into their hands.
- The Narrative Arc: The Elder Scrolls series traditionally focuses on grand, sweeping narratives. A fragmented Empire, unable to confront the Aldmeri Dominion, doesn’t align with the typical “heroic resistance” theme present throughout the games. It’s more probable that the narrative will focus on the eventual restoration of Imperial power, even if it requires significant reforms.
- Missives and Subtle Clues: In game, depending on which side captures Fort Neugrad, different missives will spawn, subtly hinting at the future direction of the conflict and emphasizing the Imperial’s overall resources.
Stormcloak Weaknesses
- Internal Divisions: Even with Ulfric as High King, Skyrim is likely to face internal divisions. Many Nords, while sympathetic to the cause of religious freedom, may not fully embrace Ulfric’s leadership or the more extreme elements of the Stormcloak ideology.
- Economic Instability: An independent Skyrim would struggle economically. Trade routes with the Empire would be disrupted, and the province would lack the infrastructure and resources necessary to thrive on its own, leading to a destabilized Skyrim.
- Vulnerability to the Aldmeri Dominion: Perhaps the most significant weakness is Skyrim’s vulnerability to the Aldmeri Dominion. Without the protection of the Empire, Skyrim would become an easy target for Thalmor expansion, potentially leading to its conquest or subjugation.
The Most Likely Outcome: A Reconstructed Empire
While the immediate aftermath of the Civil War is determined by player choice, the long-term prognosis points to a resurgence of Imperial power in Skyrim. This might not be a complete restoration of the pre-war status quo; it’s possible the Empire will offer Skyrim greater autonomy or make concessions regarding religious freedom. However, the underlying reality remains: Skyrim is more likely to survive and thrive as part of a united Tamriel, capable of resisting the looming threat of the Aldmeri Dominion. This reflects broader ideas within game-based learning – exploring consequences, strategic thinking, and complex political simulations. Further research can be found at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Whiterun always side with the Empire?
No, Whiterun’s Jarl Balgruuf the Greater attempts to remain neutral initially. However, due to Skyrim being an Imperial province, and because of direct attacks from the Stormcloaks on Whiterun, it generally aligns with the Empire.
2. What happens if the Stormcloaks win the war?
If the Stormcloaks win, Ulfric will place Skyrim’s Holds under the rule of Jarls aligned with the Stormcloak cause. The Empire is driven out, and Skyrim becomes an independent nation.
3. What happens if the Empire wins in Skyrim?
If the Empire wins, Skyrim remains an Imperial province. Imperial-aligned Jarls are reinstated, and the Stormcloak rebellion is crushed.
4. Which side is better in Skyrim?
There’s no objectively “better” side. The choice depends on your character’s values and your desired outcome for Skyrim. The Stormcloaks fight for freedom and tradition, while the Empire seeks unity and stability.
5. Who is supposed to win the civil war in Skyrim?
Lore-wise, the Empire is the more likely victor due to its superior resources and strategic position. However, the player’s choices heavily influence the immediate outcome within the game.
6. Can you betray the Imperials in Skyrim?
Yes, during the “Jagged Crown” quest, you can betray the faction you joined by delivering the crown to the opposing leader.
7. What are the two sides of the war in Skyrim?
The two sides are the Imperial Legion, representing the Empire, and the Stormcloaks, a rebellion led by Ulfric Stormcloak seeking independence for Skyrim.
8. Does the war ever end in Skyrim?
The Civil War questline has a definitive end, determined by the player’s chosen side. However, the underlying tensions and political complexities remain, suggesting potential future conflicts.
9. Who do the Imperials hate in Skyrim?
While they may maintain a facade of cooperation, the Empire deeply resents the Thalmor and their influence over Imperial policy.
10. What is the best ending in Skyrim?
The “best” ending is subjective. Many players find satisfaction in a strong, unified Empire capable of resisting the Aldmeri Dominion. Others prefer an independent Skyrim, free to govern itself according to Nord traditions.
11. Who becomes Jarl of Riften if the Imperials win?
If the Imperials win and you have captured the Rift, Maven Black-Briar replaces Laila Law-Giver as Jarl of Riften.
12. Will I lose my house in Whiterun if I join the Stormcloaks?
No, you will not lose your house in Whiterun regardless of which side you join.
13. Can you become Jarl of Whiterun?
In the vanilla version of Skyrim, you cannot become the Jarl of Whiterun. Mods may allow you to do so unofficially.
14. Which side is really in the right, Stormcloaks or Imperials?
Neither side is inherently “right.” Both have valid arguments and motivations. The Stormcloaks fight for religious freedom and self-determination, while the Empire prioritizes unity and stability in the face of the Aldmeri Dominion. The conflict explores the complexities of political ideology and the costs of freedom versus order.
15. What happens to Ulfric Stormcloak if the Imperials win?
If the Imperials win, Ulfric Stormcloak is typically killed, either in the final battle for Windhelm or executed afterwards. His death signifies the end of the Stormcloak rebellion.
The nuances within the game also offer insightful discussions about the future of learning, and the role of games in education. One can find more on the impact of games and learning at the Games Learning Society webpage.