Does the SCAR Have Recoil? A Deep Dive into FN’s Combat Rifle
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, the FN SCAR (Special Operations Forces Combat Assault Rifle), like any firearm, has recoil. However, what makes the SCAR noteworthy is its ability to manage and mitigate recoil effectively, especially when compared to other rifles of similar caliber. The degree of felt recoil depends on the specific SCAR variant, caliber, and the ammunition used. This article explores the nuances of SCAR recoil, comparing it to other platforms and addressing common questions.
Understanding Recoil in the SCAR Platform
Recoil is the backward momentum experienced by a shooter when a firearm is discharged. It’s a direct consequence of Newton’s Third Law of Motion: For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. In the context of firearms, the action is the expulsion of the bullet and propellant gases, and the reaction is the recoil felt by the shooter.
The SCAR’s recoil management is a result of several factors:
- Gas Piston Operating System: The SCAR utilizes a short-stroke gas piston system, which is considered superior to the direct impingement system found in many AR-15 variants. This system keeps the action cleaner, reduces heat buildup, and contributes to more consistent and manageable recoil. The system diverts gases to cycle the action which absorbs some of the recoil.
- Weight and Ergonomics: The weight distribution and ergonomic design of the SCAR also play a role. The SCAR platform is designed to distribute recoil more evenly across the shooter’s body, making it more comfortable to handle, particularly in rapid firing scenarios.
- Muzzle Devices: The SCAR often comes equipped with muzzle devices that further reduce recoil and muzzle climb. These devices redirect propellant gases to counteract the backward force of the rifle.
- Variants and Caliber: The SCAR comes in two primary variants: the SCAR-L (light), chambered in 5.56x45mm NATO, and the SCAR-H (heavy), chambered in the more powerful 7.62x51mm NATO. The SCAR-H naturally exhibits more recoil due to the larger and more powerful cartridge. However, even in the 7.62 configuration, many shooters find the recoil manageable due to the rifle’s design.
SCAR vs. M4: A Recoil Comparison
The question of whether the SCAR is better than the M4 often arises, particularly when considering recoil. While both are effective platforms, the SCAR’s gas piston system generally leads to a perceived reduction in recoil compared to the M4’s direct impingement system.
The direct impingement system directs hot gases directly into the bolt carrier group, which can increase felt recoil. The SCAR isolates most of these gases, reducing the felt recoil.
However, the difference in recoil is not always substantial, and many experienced shooters can effectively manage recoil with both platforms. Ultimately, personal preference, training, and the specific mission requirements play a crucial role in determining the preferred rifle.
SCAR 17: Taming the 7.62 Beast
The SCAR 17S is the civilian semi-automatic version of the SCAR-H, chambered in 7.62x51mm NATO. This variant is known for its accuracy and power, but also its potential for significant recoil. However, even with the larger caliber, the SCAR 17S remains manageable due to its design features.
Some points to consider:
- The gas piston system is critical in reducing the recoil.
- The recoil pad helps to distribute recoil across the shooter’s shoulder.
- Aftermarket accessories, such as muzzle brakes and improved recoil pads, can further reduce felt recoil.
The Modular Advantage
The SCAR’s modularity allows for customization to further enhance recoil management. Users can swap out buttstocks, grips, and muzzle devices to tailor the rifle to their specific needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What makes the SCAR easier to shoot accurately?
The SCAR’s gas piston operating system, coupled with its ergonomic design and available muzzle devices, contribute to reduced recoil and muzzle climb. This allows for faster follow-up shots and improved accuracy, even on full auto (for select-fire variants). The weapon has very little recoil even in the 7.62 configuration.
2. Is the SCAR more reliable than the M4?
Admittedly in testing, the SCAR proved to be more reliable, but not substantially so. The M4 series has proven itself a reliable platform, and while the SCAR may have had fewer stoppages in 6,000 rounds, the average firefight isn’t lasting long enough for an on-the-ground operator to see a major difference. However, the SCAR’s gas piston system inherently reduces fouling, which can lead to greater long-term reliability.
3. Why wasn’t the SCAR adopted as the standard US military rifle?
The FN SCAR was adopted by the Special Operations Command (SOCOM). SOCOM ceased procurement of the Mk 16 Mod 0 (SCAR-L) after the initial order because it was felt to give insufficient improvement over the M4A1 (and variants) to justify the cost.
4. What makes the SCAR so modular?
The SCAR was designed with modularity in mind. It features a full-length top rail and multiple side and bottom rails, allowing users to easily attach accessories such as optics, lights, lasers, and foregrips. The ability to quickly swap barrels and other components adds to its versatility.
5. Why is the SCAR 17 so popular despite its cost?
The main reason the SCAR receives the hype that it does is because it has a huge advantage over the M4; it’s extremely modular. This offers lots of practical benefits, and is something that the M4 lacks by comparison. This modularity, combined with its accuracy, reliability, and relatively manageable recoil for a 7.62 rifle, makes it highly desirable.
6. Is the SCAR-L a real gun used by militaries?
Yes, The FN SCAR-L (L for Light) is an assault rifle chambered in 5.56x45mm NATO caliber designed and manufactured by the Belgian firearms manufacturer FN Herstal. The assault rifle 5.56mm FN SCAR-L has been specifically designed to offer users increased portability and adaptability. It is used by various special operations forces around the world.
7. What does SCAR-H stand for?
SCAR-L. The L is for “light,” which is chambered in 5.56x45mm NATO cartridge. Same round as the AR-15/M4/M16. SCAR-H. The H is for “heavy,” which is chambered in 7.62x51mm NATO (.308 Winchester).
8. Is the SCAR a sniper rifle?
Now type-designated as the MK 20 SSR, the FN SCAR® Sniper Support Rifle (SSR) is a tailored design for long-range precision fire applications while also providing capability to fight close in. Based on the FN® MK 17, the SSR is capable of sub-minute of angle accuracy out to and beyond 1,000 yards. While not a dedicated sniper rifle in the traditional sense, the MK 20 SSR (Sniper Support Rifle), a variant of the SCAR-H, is designed for long-range precision fire.
9. Why is the SCAR so expensive?
They’re made in Belgium because FN is located in Herstal, Belgium. It’s a suburb of Liege, about 10 miles from the German border. They’re so expensive because that’s what people (and governments) are willing to pay for them. Which in turn means people (and governments) think they’re worth the money. The SCAR’s advanced design, high-quality materials, and relatively low production volume contribute to its higher price point.
10. What military units use the SCAR?
Developed exclusively for U.S. special operations forces and the demanding environments they operate in, the Mk16 Special Operations Forces Combat Assault Rifle is a gas-piston operated 5.56 carbine that features a modular design to allow the operator to configure the rifle for specific missions. The SCAR was developed for the U.S. Special Operations Command (SOCOM) and is used by various special operations forces worldwide.
11. Is the AK-47 better than the SCAR?
The SCAR is more accurate and has a greater distance capability than a standard AK. 600 yards is easy for a SCAR and 1,000 yard shots are not uncommon. Cost-wise, the AK is your friend. Ammo is significantly less expensive. The SCAR generally offers greater accuracy and modularity. The AK-47 is known for its simplicity, reliability in harsh conditions, and lower cost. The “better” rifle depends on the specific needs and priorities.
12. Is it legal to own a FN SCAR?
A civilian Semi-Automatic version is available (SCAR 17S) and can be picked up in most states through a FFL (Federal Firearms Licensee) transfer assuming a gun shop doesn’t already have one in stock. Treated just like an (expensive) rifle most places except perhaps Kommiefornia and a few other fascist states. Yes, in most US states, it is legal to own a semi-automatic civilian version of the SCAR (SCAR 16S and SCAR 17S), subject to local laws and regulations.
13. How much does a SCAR weigh?
The FN SCAR ® -H STD weights no more than 3.720 kg (without magazine) and does not exceed 721mm in length with folded buttstock. The weight varies depending on the specific model and configuration, but generally ranges from around 7 to 8 pounds unloaded.
14. Is the SCAR full auto?
The FN SCAR ® -H PR are highly accurate semi-auto or selective fire precision rifles for designated marksmen or sniper teams. It is durable yet lightweight, and guarantees rapid and accurate fire at long and close ranges. Military and law enforcement variants of the SCAR are capable of full-automatic fire. The civilian versions are semi-automatic only.
15. Is the FN SCAR powerful?
It is a gas operated, selective fire weapon. There are two baseline models – the SCAR-L (light), chambered for 5.56×45 mm round and the SCAR-H (heavy) chambered for a more powerful 7.62×51 mm ammunition. These were officially designated by the US SOCOM as the Mk. 16 and Mk. The SCAR-H, chambered in 7.62x51mm NATO, is considered a powerful rifle due to the greater energy and range of the cartridge. The SCAR-L, chambered in 5.56x45mm NATO, offers a balance of controllability and effectiveness.
Conclusion
The SCAR is a highly capable and versatile rifle that offers manageable recoil, particularly considering its different caliber options. Its gas piston system, modular design, and ergonomic features contribute to a comfortable and accurate shooting experience. While it may not be the perfect rifle for everyone, its qualities make it a popular choice among military personnel, law enforcement officers, and civilian shooters alike. The Games Learning Society could even use the SCAR platform as inspiration for tactical gameplay in the future. You can check more of our gaming inspiration by going to GamesLearningSociety.org.