Trample vs. Indestructible: Crushing the Uncrushable?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, trample does “get over” indestructible, but perhaps not in the way you might initially think. While you can’t destroy an indestructible creature with combat damage, the trample ability allows you to assign enough damage to that creature to meet its lethal threshold, then assign the excess damage to the defending player, planeswalker, or battle. The indestructible creature remains on the battlefield, unharmed, but your opponent still feels the pain.
Let’s dive deeper into the fascinating interplay between these two powerful mechanics in card games like Magic: The Gathering.
Understanding Trample and Indestructible
Before we can fully understand how trample interacts with indestructible, we need to define each ability individually:
-
Trample: This keyword ability modifies how combat damage is assigned. Normally, an attacking creature must assign enough damage to destroy a blocking creature before any damage can be assigned to the defending player or planeswalker. Trample changes this. With trample, you only need to assign enough damage to the blocker to deal lethal damage to it. Any excess damage can then be assigned to the defending player, planeswalker, or battle.
-
Indestructible: This keyword ability means exactly what it sounds like: a permanent with indestructible cannot be destroyed. This applies to destruction effects from spells or abilities and lethal damage. While indestructible creatures can’t be destroyed by damage, they are still subject to other methods of removal, such as exile, sacrifice, or being given negative toughness.
The Interaction: Trample Doesn’t Destroy, It Bypasses
The key to understanding the interaction is realizing that trample doesn’t actually destroy the blocker. Instead, it allows you to bypass the standard damage assignment rules once you’ve assigned “enough” damage to be considered lethal. For an indestructible creature, that “enough” damage is an amount equal to or greater than its toughness.
Consider this scenario:
- You attack with a 5/5 creature with trample.
- Your opponent blocks with a 3/3 creature with indestructible.
You must assign at least 3 damage to the indestructible creature (its toughness). The remaining 2 damage can then be assigned to the defending player. The 3/3 indestructible creature survives combat, but the player still takes 2 damage.
Why It Works This Way
This interaction highlights the important distinction between “lethal damage” and “destroying”. While indestructible creatures are immune to being destroyed, they still need to be assigned enough damage to satisfy the game rules for trample to work. Think of it like this: your creature could have destroyed the blocker, but its indestructible nature prevents it. The game acknowledges that enough damage was present to do the job, so trample proceeds.
This interaction also highlights the importance of understanding how keywords affect the underlying rules of a game. Trample doesn’t rewrite the fundamental rules of combat; it only alters how damage is assigned.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions surrounding the interaction of trample and indestructible:
1. Does trample work against indestructible creatures with higher toughness than the trampler’s power?
No. If your trampler has less power than the indestructible creature’s toughness, you cannot deal any damage to the defending player. You must assign all of your creature’s damage to the blocker.
2. If a creature has both deathtouch and trample, and is blocked by an indestructible creature, how does it work?
Any amount of damage from a creature with deathtouch is considered lethal. Therefore, you only need to assign 1 damage to the indestructible blocker, and the rest tramples over.
3. Can indestructible creatures block creatures with trample indefinitely?
Yes, indestructible creatures can effectively block creatures with trample every turn, preventing all trample damage from reaching the player, as long as the trampler’s power doesn’t exceed the blockers toughness.
4. Does giving a creature -1/-1 until end of turn get around indestructible and trample?
No, this does not inherently get around trample. If the indestructible creature’s toughness is still greater than or equal to 1 after the -1/-1 effect, the trampling creature must still assign damage to the blocking creature.
5. What about -X/-X effects?
This is a case-by-case basis. If the resulting toughness is still equal to one or greater, trample does not inherently overcome the indestructible. If the toughness dips into zero or less, then the indestructible creature is sent to the graveyard, and it is no longer blocking and damage tramples through.
6. Does trample interact differently with creatures that have both indestructible and hexproof?
Hexproof only prevents your opponent from targeting the hexproof permanent with spells or abilities. It doesn’t affect how combat damage is assigned. Trample will still work as described above.
7. Can an indestructible creature be sacrificed to stop trample damage?
Sacrificing the creature removes it from combat, meaning it is no longer blocking. All of the trampling creature’s damage can be assigned to the defending player, planeswalker, or battle. Indestructible does not prevent a creature from being sacrificed.
8. If a creature has double strike and trample, does the first strike damage affect how trample works in the second combat damage step?
Yes. If the indestructible blocker takes damage in the first strike step, that damage is taken into account when assigning damage in the second combat damage step. If lethal damage was dealt in the first strike step, all remaining damage tramples over in the second strike step.
9. What happens if a creature with trample is blocked by multiple indestructible creatures?
You must assign lethal damage to each blocking creature before assigning any damage to the defending player. For each indestructible creature, the damage assigned to each must match or exceed its toughness. If you can’t assign enough damage to satisfy all of the blockers, no damage tramples over.
10. Does regenerate stop trample?
While regenerate can save a creature from being destroyed by damage or deathtouch, it does not stop trample. You still have to assign what would be considered lethal damage to the creature, and the excess tramples over. The regenerated creature remains on the battlefield.
11. What about protection from the attacking creature’s color?
Protection from a color has four components: prevention of damage, being blocked, being targeted, and being equipped/enchanted. Protection would prevent the damage from being assigned to the protected creature, rendering trample ineffectual. All of the damage must be assigned to the protected creature.
12. If I use a spell to reduce an indestructible creature’s toughness to zero or less, does it stop trample?
Yes. A creature with zero or less toughness is put into its owner’s graveyard as a state-based action. It ceases to block, allowing all damage from the trampling creature to be assigned to the defending player, planeswalker, or battle.
13. How does the power of creatures with mutate interact with indestructible and trample?
When creatures mutate, their characteristics are combined. The power and toughness of the resulting creature are determined by the topmost card of the mutated pile. The mutated creature with trample must assign damage equal to or greater than the toughness of the indestructible creature. The excess may be assigned to the defending player.
14. What if a creature has both indestructible and lifelink?
The indestructible creature cannot be destroyed by combat damage or effects that say “destroy”. The lifelink ability simply states that you gain life equal to the amount of damage that creature deals. If the creature with indestructible and lifelink deals combat damage, its controller gains life equal to the amount of damage dealt, even if that damage is dealt to an indestructible creature.
15. Where can I learn more about game mechanics and design?
Understanding game mechanics like trample and indestructible is crucial not just for playing games, but also for designing them. Organizations like the Games Learning Society are dedicated to exploring the intersection of games and learning. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to discover resources, research, and communities focused on the educational power of games.
Conclusion
While indestructible creatures are incredibly resilient, they aren’t immune to the effects of trample. By understanding the subtle nuances of these keywords and their interaction, you can make more informed decisions in combat and leverage trample to your advantage, even against seemingly unkillable foes. Remember, you might not be able to destroy them, but you can still make your opponent feel the pain!