Does Worship Prevent Commander Damage? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Worship, the enchantment that makes it tough to knock you out when you control a creature, doesn’t directly prevent commander damage. What it does do is ensure that as long as you control a creature, damage cannot reduce your life total to less than 1. However, the crucial thing to remember in Commander is that even if your life total remains stubbornly above zero thanks to Worship, if you’ve accumulated 21 or more combat damage from a single commander, you still lose the game. Worship only affects life loss; it doesn’t stop the game-ending condition imposed by commander damage.
This distinction is vital to understand when building and playing Commander decks. While life total management is key, commander damage is an alternate win condition that circumvents traditional life-based defenses. Now, let’s dive deeper with some frequently asked questions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Commander Damage
Here are 15 common questions about commander damage, answered to help you navigate the intricacies of this exciting game format.
1. What Exactly is Commander Damage?
Commander damage is a unique rule in the Commander (or EDH – Elder Dragon Highlander) format of Magic: The Gathering. If a player is dealt 21 or more combat damage by the same commander throughout the course of a game, that player loses the game, regardless of their current life total. The damage is cumulative; it doesn’t reset at any point unless the game is restarted. It’s a player-specific tracking, meaning you need to track how much commander damage each commander has dealt to you.
2. Can Commander Damage Be Prevented?
Yes, commander damage can be prevented. Standard damage prevention effects, like protection from creatures or spells that prevent damage, are effective against commander damage. However, if an effect states that “damage can’t be prevented,” then you’ll still accumulate commander damage, even if your life total doesn’t change as a result.
3. How Do I Get Rid of Commander Damage?
The short answer is: you usually can’t. Once you’ve taken commander damage, it’s there to stay for the remainder of the game. The only common way to truly “reset” commander damage is with cards like Karn Liberated, which restart the game. Otherwise, you must try to prevent further damage from that commander.
4. Does Protection Stop Commander Damage?
Absolutely! The protection ability (e.g., “Protection from red”) prevents damage, among other things. If a creature has protection from the color of the commander trying to attack it, the damage will be prevented. However, remember that protection doesn’t prevent a commander from targeting you with non-combat damage from an ability or spell.
5. Does Platinum Emperion Stop Commander Damage?
No, Platinum Emperion doesn’t stop commander damage. It simply alters the result of damage, preventing your life total from changing. But, the damage is still considered to have been dealt, and that damage still contributes to the commander damage total. You might not lose life, but you’re still accumulating those game-ending points.
6. Does Phyrexian Unlife Stop Commander Damage?
No, Phyrexian Unlife does not stop commander damage. While it replaces life loss with poison counters, the damage is still dealt. This means that even though you’re gaining poison counters instead of losing life, you are still accumulating commander damage.
7. Does Quietus Spike Contribute to Commander Damage?
No. Quietus Spike causes the player to lose half their life. The life loss is not attributed to the commander; it doesn’t count toward the commander damage rule. Commander damage must come directly from the attacking or damage-dealing commander.
8. If I Copy a Commander, Does That Count as Commander Damage?
No. The rule is that a specific card representing your commander needs to inflict combat damage for it to count as commander damage. A token copy or a creature copying your commander will inflict regular combat damage, but it won’t be tracked as commander damage. Commander-ness is a unique property of the actual card designated as your commander.
9. Can I Deal Commander Damage with a Stolen Commander?
Yes! If you steal control of an opponent’s commander, and it deals combat damage to an opponent, that damage is counted as commander damage dealt by that commander. The damage is attributed to the commander itself, not the original owner.
10. Can I Counter a Commander?
Yes, you can counter a commander spell just like any other spell. However, keep in mind that the commander’s owner can choose to send their commander back to the command zone instead of the graveyard if it would be countered, meaning they can recast it later (for an increased mana cost).
11. If My Commander is Mutated, Does It Still Deal Commander Damage?
Yes! If your commander is part of a mutated creature pile, the entire merged creature is considered to be your commander, and any combat damage it deals is considered commander damage from your commander. The order of the mutation pile doesn’t matter; as long as your commander is part of it, it deals commander damage.
12. Does Angel’s Grace Help Against Commander Damage?
Angel’s Grace stops you from losing the game for a specific turn. This means that, during that turn, you won’t lose the game due to commander damage. However, the commander damage remains. As soon as the turn ends and state-based actions are checked, you’ll immediately lose the game if you still have 21 or more commander damage from a single commander. It only postpones the inevitable, it doesn’t prevent it.
13. What Happens if My Commander is Sent to My Hand?
If your commander would be put into your hand from the battlefield, you have the option to return it to the command zone instead. This is a replacement effect. If you choose to put it into your hand, you can cast it later without paying the “commander tax” (the additional cost for each time you’ve cast your commander from the command zone). However, if it goes to the command zone, the tax will increase the next time you cast it.
14. If a Commander Dies, What Happens?
When your commander dies (or is exiled), it goes to the graveyard (or exile) just like any other creature. However, you can choose to move it to the command zone as a state-based action. This ability triggers when the commander enters the graveyard or exile, meaning that abilities that trigger upon a creature dying or being exiled will still work. This is an important distinction for effects that trigger when a creature leaves the battlefield.
15. Is a Token Copy of a Commander Still Considered a Commander?
No, a token copy (or a creature copying your commander) is not considered a commander. Even if it has the same name and abilities, it doesn’t have the special property of “commanderness”. Damage dealt by a token copy of a commander is just regular combat damage.
Understanding commander damage and how it interacts with various game mechanics is crucial for success in Commander. While effects like Worship can help protect your life total, they don’t prevent the game-ending condition imposed by accumulating 21 or more combat damage from a single commander. Knowing this, you can strategically build your decks and play around the ever-present threat of commander damage to secure victory.
This knowledge can also be applied to other areas. For example, the Games Learning Society investigates how games like Magic: The Gathering can promote learning. The strategic thinking, rule comprehension, and social interaction involved in Commander all contribute to valuable skill development. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to explore more about the educational benefits of gaming.