Has Anyone Lost a Perfect Game?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, several pitchers have lost a perfect game deep into a contest, sometimes with just one or two outs remaining. This makes the sport of baseball both exhilarating and heartbreaking, as perfection is often fleeting and vulnerable to a single misstep.
The Agony of Almost Perfection: Understanding the Terminology
Before delving into specific instances, let’s clarify what constitutes a perfect game and how losing one differs from simply losing a no-hitter. A perfect game is defined as a game in which a pitcher (or combination of pitchers) pitches a victory that lasts a minimum of nine innings and in which no opposing player reaches base. This means no hits, no walks, no hit batsmen, and no errors that allow a batter to reach base safely. Any of these reaching base ends the possibility of a perfect game. A no-hitter, on the other hand, only prevents hits; a pitcher can still lose a no-hitter by issuing walks, hitting batters, or due to fielding errors.
Losing a perfect game is a particularly excruciating experience because it means the pitcher had achieved complete dominance but then saw that pristine record broken, often in the late innings when the pressure is at its highest. It’s about the near-mythical status of perfection and how close someone can come without achieving the elusive feat.
Famous Examples of Perfect Games Lost
Several near-perfect games haunt the annals of baseball history. Here are some of the most memorable:
Armando Galarraga: The “Almost” Perfect Game
Perhaps the most infamous example is Armando Galarraga’s game on June 2, 2010. Pitching for the Detroit Tigers against the Cleveland Indians, Galarraga retired the first 26 batters. With two outs in the ninth inning, first base umpire Jim Joyce incorrectly called Jason Donald safe at first base on what was clearly an out. Replays showed Donald was out by a significant margin. Despite the blown call and the clear video evidence, the call stood, and Galarraga was forced to settle for a one-hit shutout. The incident sparked widespread controversy and led to discussions about instant replay in baseball. Joyce tearfully apologized to Galarraga after the game, highlighting the human element and the unfortunate role of error in the sport. While not officially a perfect game, many consider it so in spirit. This event serves as a stark reminder that human error can rob a pitcher of baseball immortality.
Max Scherzer: The Hit By Pitch
In 2015, Max Scherzer came within one out of a perfect game while pitching for the Washington Nationals against the Pittsburgh Pirates. After retiring the first 26 batters, he hit Josh Harrison with a pitch. He then recorded the final out, completing a no-hitter, but the hit-by-pitch prevented the perfect game. Scherzer’s reaction was one of disappointment, knowing how close he had come to achieving baseball history. This is a prime example of how even a dominant performance can be spoiled by a single, unexpected event.
Pedro Martinez: The Early Heartbreak
While not in the 9th, Pedro Martinez in 1995 lost a perfect game bid in the 8th inning against the San Diego Padres when Bip Roberts doubled. This early loss still stings as Martinez was quickly becoming a dominant force in baseball.
Dave Stieb: Multiple Near Misses
Dave Stieb, a star pitcher for the Toronto Blue Jays in the 1980s, suffered multiple near misses. He lost a no-hitter with two outs in the ninth inning on three separate occasions, including one game where he lost a perfect game with two outs in the ninth. Stieb’s misfortunes became legendary, highlighting the sheer difficulty of achieving perfection in baseball. His repeated brushes with history cemented his place in baseball lore, even without officially recording a perfect game.
The Psychological Impact
Losing a perfect game, especially late in the contest, can be devastating for a pitcher. The pressure mounts with each passing inning, and the realization that history is within reach can be both exhilarating and nerve-wracking. When that dream is shattered, the emotional impact can be significant. Pitchers often talk about trying to stay focused and avoid thinking about the perfect game, but it’s a difficult task. The disappointment can linger, even after completing a successful no-hitter or shutout.
The Umpire’s Role
The role of umpires is crucial in maintaining the integrity of the game. While human error is inevitable, controversial calls like the one in the Galarraga game underscore the importance of accuracy and the potential for a single decision to alter history. The incident prompted serious discussions about the use of instant replay to correct obvious mistakes, aiming to minimize the impact of human error on the outcome of games.
FAQs about Losing Perfect Games
Here are some frequently asked questions about the rarity and nuances of perfect games and near-perfect games:
1. What is the difference between a perfect game and a no-hitter?
A perfect game requires that no opposing player reaches base. A no-hitter simply requires that no hits are allowed. A pitcher can throw a no-hitter and still allow runners on base via walks, hit batters, or errors.
2. How rare is a perfect game in MLB history?
Perfect games are exceptionally rare. There have only been 24 officially recognized perfect games in Major League Baseball history as of 2024.
3. Who was the last pitcher to throw a perfect game?
The last officially recognized perfect game in MLB history was thrown by Domingo Germán of the New York Yankees on June 28, 2023, against the Oakland Athletics.
4. Why is Armando Galarraga’s game not considered a perfect game?
Despite retiring 27 batters, a controversial call by umpire Jim Joyce on what would have been the final out ruled a runner safe, breaking up the perfect game. Officially, it’s recorded as a one-hit shutout.
5. What is the psychological toll of losing a perfect game?
The psychological toll can be immense. Pitchers often describe feeling crushed, especially if the perfect game is lost late in the contest. The pressure of maintaining perfection, combined with the disappointment of seeing it slip away, can be emotionally draining.
6. Has any pitcher lost multiple perfect games?
While not officially recorded as multiple lost perfect games, Dave Stieb came close multiple times, losing no-hitters with two outs in the ninth on three separate occasions, including one that was a perfect game until that point.
7. What is the significance of a perfect game in a pitcher’s career?
A perfect game is considered one of the highest achievements a pitcher can attain, symbolizing complete dominance and control. It’s a rare and coveted accomplishment that can significantly enhance a pitcher’s legacy.
8. How does instant replay affect the possibility of perfect games being lost?
Instant replay can help correct incorrect calls that might otherwise break up a perfect game. While human error is still a factor, replay technology aims to minimize the impact of bad calls and ensure fairer outcomes.
9. Are perfect games more common in certain eras of baseball?
Perfect games seem to occur sporadically across different eras. There’s no clear indication that they are more common in any particular period, although rule changes and playing styles may influence their frequency.
10. Can a combined effort result in a perfect game?
No, a perfect game must be achieved by one pitcher throwing the entirety of the game (minimum 9 innings). A combined effort, even if no one reaches base, is not considered a perfect game.
11. What happens if a perfect game is broken up by an error?
An error that allows a batter to reach base ends the perfect game bid.
12. Has a perfect game ever been lost in extra innings?
Yes. This is a particularly heartbreaking way to lose a perfect game, as it means the pitcher maintained perfection through the regulation nine innings, only to have it broken up in the extra frame.
13. How do managers and coaches approach a pitcher who is throwing a perfect game?
Managers and coaches often try to avoid talking about the perfect game to the pitcher, as they don’t want to add unnecessary pressure. They focus on maintaining routine and keeping the pitcher focused on each individual batter.
14. What impact do weather conditions have on a pitcher’s chances of throwing a perfect game?
Weather conditions can play a role. For example, extreme heat or cold can affect grip and stamina, while wind can influence the movement of pitches.
15. What is the role of the catcher in helping a pitcher throw a perfect game?
The catcher plays a crucial role by calling the game, providing a target, and keeping the pitcher focused and confident. A strong pitcher-catcher relationship is essential for success, especially when pursuing perfection.
Conclusion
The pursuit of a perfect game is one of baseball’s most captivating narratives. While achieving it is incredibly rare, the near misses and heartbreaking losses serve as reminders of the sport’s unpredictable nature and the human element that makes it so compelling. The quest for perfection continues, adding to the rich tapestry of baseball history.