How Did Frisk Become Chara? Unraveling the Narrative of Undertale

▶

The question of how Frisk becomes Chara is a complex one, deeply rooted in the player’s choices within the narrative of Undertale. Frisk, the fallen human, doesn’t inherently “become” Chara. Instead, through the Genocide Route, the player’s relentless pursuit of destruction corrupts Frisk, allowing Chara’s influence to manifest. Chara, the first fallen human, acts as a narrator and a reflection of the player’s actions. The more the player chooses violence and raises their LOVE (Level of Violence), the more Chara’s personality merges with Frisk’s, culminating in Chara taking control and erasing the world at the end of the Genocide Route. Essentially, it’s the player’s choices, not an inherent predisposition in Frisk, that unlocks and empowers Chara’s dormant influence. It is also worth mentioning that determination and LOVE are key parts to bringing Chara back to life, and that this is only during the Genocide Route.

Understanding the Relationship Between Frisk and Chara

The relationship between Frisk and Chara is one of the most debated topics in the Undertale fandom. It’s crucial to understand they are distinct entities, at least initially. Frisk is the player’s avatar, a silent protagonist whose actions are dictated by the player’s choices. Chara, on the other hand, is a character with a history, motivations, and a complex past that is slowly revealed as the player progresses through the game, especially during the Genocide Route.

The Role of Player Choice

The player’s choices are paramount. In a Pacifist Route, Frisk remains a compassionate and forgiving character. However, the Genocide Route transforms Frisk. The constant killing desensitizes Frisk, paving the way for Chara’s influence to emerge. This is visually represented by changes in Frisk’s appearance and, most significantly, by Chara’s narration taking over at the end of the Genocide Route.

Chara’s Perspective

Chara’s narration offers insight into their perspective. They comment on the increasing EXP (Execution Points) and LOVE gained from killing, and at the end, they express a desire to erase the world, deeming it corrupted. This suggests that Chara’s evil is not inherent but is rather fueled by the player’s actions and the world’s state, and the negative feeling associated with this state.

The Mirror of Actions

Ultimately, Frisk becomes a mirror reflecting the player’s choices. If the player chooses mercy and kindness, Frisk remains a force for good. But if the player chooses violence and destruction, Frisk becomes a vessel for Chara’s vengeance. Therefore, the transformation of Frisk into Chara is not a predetermined event but a consequence of the player’s choices.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Frisk and Chara

Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the complex relationship between Frisk and Chara:

1. Is Frisk actually Chara’s body? The theory that Frisk is Chara’s reanimated body is popular but lacks definitive confirmation. The game implies Frisk is a separate individual, influenced by Chara based on the player’s actions. It is worth noting that in the Genocide Route, Chara takes over Frisk’s body and has more control over it.

2. Why are Frisk and Chara so similar in appearance? The similarities in appearance are likely a deliberate design choice by Toby Fox to highlight the connection between the two characters and to emphasize the idea that Frisk can become a reflection of Chara, depending on the player’s choices. This allows Frisk to become a reflection of Chara.

3. Is Frisk the reincarnation of Chara? There’s no direct evidence within the game to support the idea of reincarnation. The more accurate interpretation is that Chara’s spirit or essence lingers and can be awakened or influenced by the player’s actions through Frisk.

4. Why is Flowey scared of Chara? Flowey, having once been Asriel, fears Chara because he witnesses their capacity for ruthless violence. Flowey initially believes Chara would approve of his “kill or be killed” philosophy but ultimately realizes he, too, is not exempt from Chara’s destructive impulses, and that he can also be victim to it.

5. Is Chara evil from the beginning? Chara’s morality is ambiguous. The game leaves room for interpretation, suggesting that their actions in the past were influenced by their circumstances and possibly a desire to free the monsters. The Genocide Route amplifies any negative tendencies due to the player’s actions.

6. Why does Chara only appear in the Genocide Route? Chara’s presence is tied to the player’s LV (Level of Violence) and determination. The constant killing in the Genocide Route fuels Chara’s awakening and allows them to manifest fully. The LOVE and EXP from murdering beings has brought Chara back to life.

7. What happens to Chara’s soul after Asriel dies? It’s implied that Chara’s soul dissipated after Asriel’s death. In the Genocide Route, Chara explicitly states that it was the player’s determination and soul that woke them from death, implying that their own soul was no longer present.

8. Is Chara possessing Kris in Deltarune? The relationship between Chara and Kris in Deltarune is heavily debated. Some believe Kris is possessed by Chara, but others argue that Kris is a separate character influenced by similar themes and narrative devices as Chara and Frisk. The ending scene suggests Kris is taking control, not being possessed.

9. Who is stronger, Frisk or Chara? In the Genocide Route, Chara is portrayed as more powerful than Frisk, particularly in the final confrontation. This power stems from the LOVE and EXP accumulated through the player’s violent actions. It has also been proven that Chara was more powerful than Frisk.

10. Why did Chara turn evil? The reason why Chara turned evil is a highly debated topic. When Chara died, their soul was taken by Asriel and removed from their body, as well as the body being buried under the golden flowers. The soul wasn’t buried so there was no compassion within.

11. Is Chara canonically a girl? Chara’s gender is intentionally left ambiguous by Toby Fox. The game uses they/them pronouns for Chara, making them non-binary canonically.

12. Why is Frisk not in Deltarune? Deltarune is a separate universe from Undertale, as confirmed by Toby Fox. While characters might share visual similarities or thematic parallels, they are distinct individuals with different histories and motivations.

13. Why does Kris look like Frisk? Kris is designed to resemble both Frisk and Chara, creating a sense of familiarity and intrigue for players familiar with Undertale. This visual cue hints at shared thematic elements between the two games.

14. How many endings are in Undertale? Undertale has three primary endings: Pacifist, Neutral, and Genocide. Each ending can have variations depending on specific player choices made throughout the game. It is important to note that some endings will also affect other endings in the game.

15. Why did Asriel turn into Flowey? Asriel transformed into Flowey after his death, due to him releasing the souls of the humans and monsters, as well as losing the ability to feel love. In game, it’s ambiguous as to whether Flowey leaves the Underground with the others, but fan speculation and certain supplemental media suggests that he does.

Understanding Undertale’s narrative complexities requires considering player agency, character motivations, and the power of choice. The connection between Frisk and Chara is a dynamic one, shaped by the player’s actions and offering a thought-provoking exploration of morality and consequence. For more on understanding games and learning, visit the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.