Poisoned Loyalty: How Poison Counters Interact with Planeswalkers in Magic: The Gathering
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Planeswalkers are powerful permanents in Magic: The Gathering, capable of swinging games with their potent abilities. But are they vulnerable to the insidious spread of poison? The short answer is: Planeswalkers are completely unaffected by poison counters. They cannot gain poison counters, and the state-based action that causes a player to lose the game at ten poison counters has no bearing on planeswalkers whatsoever. However, the source of poison – creatures with Infect or triggered abilities that dole out poison counters – can interact with planeswalkers, albeit indirectly. It’s a question of damage, not direct contamination.
Infect creatures don’t give Planeswalkers poison counters. Instead, they deal damage like any other creature and damage causes the Planeswalker to lose loyalty counters. The Planeswalker goes to the graveyard when it has no loyalty counters as a state-based action.
Understanding the Mechanics: Loyalty vs. Poison
To truly grasp this interaction (or lack thereof), we need to differentiate between loyalty counters and poison counters. Loyalty counters are the lifeblood of a planeswalker, determining how long it can remain on the battlefield and utilize its abilities. Planeswalkers enter the battlefield with a specified number of loyalty counters and lose these counters primarily through damage. When a planeswalker’s loyalty reaches zero, it’s sent to the graveyard.
Poison counters, on the other hand, are a completely separate game mechanic, exclusively affecting players. When a player accumulates ten or more poison counters, they immediately lose the game. This alternative win condition is often associated with the Infect keyword and cards that explicitly grant poison counters to players.
The Key Distinction: Damage, Not Direct Poisoning
While planeswalkers are immune to poison counters, they are susceptible to damage. And this is where the connection to infect arises. Creatures with infect deal damage, which, if directed at a planeswalker, results in the removal of loyalty counters. The Infect ability itself doesn’t directly poison the planeswalker, but the damage it inflicts can lead to its demise. It’s crucial to remember that the game treats a planeswalker’s loyalty total as if it were a player’s life total when damage is dealt.
For example, if a creature with infect deals 3 damage to a planeswalker, that planeswalker loses 3 loyalty counters. If this reduces the planeswalker’s loyalty to zero, it is sent to the graveyard. The infect itself never directly places poison counters on the planeswalker.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Poison and Planeswalkers
1. Can a planeswalker gain poison counters?
No. Planeswalkers are specifically coded in the rules of Magic: The Gathering to be immune to poison counters. Attempts to place poison counters on a planeswalker will simply fail.
2. Does Infect deal poison counters to planeswalkers?
No. Infect deals damage to planeswalkers in the form of lost loyalty counters. The Infect ability itself only applies to creatures (putting -1/-1 counters on them) and players (giving them poison counters).
3. If a creature with Infect attacks a planeswalker, what happens?
The creature deals damage to the planeswalker equal to its power. The planeswalker then loses that many loyalty counters. The Infect ability itself doesn’t come into play beyond the source of the damage.
4. Does Deathtouch affect planeswalkers?
Not directly. Deathtouch is a static ability that causes any amount of damage dealt by a source with deathtouch to a creature to be lethal (unless the creature has indestructible). However, planeswalkers are not creatures. Therefore, Deathtouch still has no effect.
5. Can I use a spell or ability that gives poison counters to target a planeswalker?
No. Spells and abilities that explicitly give poison counters can only target players, not planeswalkers. The game rules prevent you from targeting a planeswalker with such an effect.
6. How does damage redirection affect planeswalkers and poison?
If you control a spell or ability that redirects damage from you to a planeswalker you control, and the original damage source had Infect, the planeswalker will lose loyalty counters equal to the damage redirected.
7. Can proliferate add poison counters to a planeswalker?
No. Proliferate allows you to choose any number of permanents and/or players with counters on them, then give each another counter of each kind that’s already there. Because planeswalkers cannot have poison counters on them, you can’t use proliferate to add poison counters to a planeswalker.
8. Does Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider affect the interaction between Infect and planeswalkers?
Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider only affects players. It halves the number of counters an opponent would receive and doubles the number of counters you would receive. Because planeswalkers cannot have poison counters, it has no effect.
9. What happens if a planeswalker becomes a creature and then is dealt damage by a source with Infect?
If a planeswalker becomes a creature (through an effect like that of Gideon planeswalkers), it can then receive -1/-1 counters from sources with Infect. The interaction is now based on creature combat and -1/-1 counters, not loyalty counters and damage.
10. Does Aether Snap remove loyalty counters from planeswalkers?
Yes. Aether Snap removes all counters from permanents, including loyalty counters from planeswalkers. However, it does not affect poison counters on players.
11. If a planeswalker has indestructible, can it still be defeated by damage from Infect?
Yes. Planeswalkers with indestructible will still have loyalty counters removed from them as they are dealt damage. If a planeswalker with indestructible has no loyalty counters, it will still be put into its owner’s graveyard, as the rule that does this doesn’t destroy the planeswalker.
12. Can I use proliferate to add more loyalty counters to a planeswalker?
Yes. Proliferate allows you to add another counter of each type already present on a permanent or player. Since planeswalkers have loyalty counters, you can add more using proliferate.
13. If a creature with deathtouch deals combat damage to a player, does that player get poison counters?
Normally, no. Unless the card giving Deathtouch specifically states it deals poison counters to a player when dealing combat damage. There are very few cards that grant poison counters when dealing combat damage to a player.
14. What happens if a planeswalker is dealt excess damage?
If the planeswalker’s loyalty is reduced to zero, the excess damage does nothing. Damage only matters in the context of reducing loyalty counters.
15. What are some strategies to protect my planeswalkers from Infect decks?
Employing strategies to mitigate damage is key. This includes using creatures with high toughness to block infect creatures, using spells and abilities to prevent damage, and removing infect creatures from the battlefield before they can attack. Cards that boost a planeswalker’s loyalty can also buy you valuable time.
Conclusion: A Game of Inches, Not Contamination
While planeswalkers are immune to the direct effects of poison counters, they are still vulnerable to damage from sources with the Infect ability. Understanding the nuanced difference between damage and poison counters is crucial for effective gameplay and strategic decision-making in Magic: The Gathering. Knowing how to protect your valuable planeswalkers from these threats can be the key to victory, especially in formats where Infect strategies are prevalent.
For more insights into the intricacies of game mechanics and learning through play, explore resources from organizations like the Games Learning Society, dedicated to the study and promotion of educational games. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to discover more.