How Does Dealing Damage Work in MTG? A Comprehensive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers How does dealing damage work in MTG? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

At its core, damage in Magic: The Gathering (MTG) is a fundamental mechanic that dictates how creatures interact in combat, how spells and abilities affect permanents and players, and ultimately, how games are won or lost. Damage, in its simplest form, reduces the toughness of creatures and the life total of players. Understanding how damage works is crucial to mastering the game, allowing players to make informed decisions and execute winning strategies.

Damage in MTG arises from two primary sources:

Combat Damage: Occurs during the combat phase when attacking and blocking creatures deal damage equal to their power.
Damage from Spells and Abilities: Many spells and activated or triggered abilities explicitly deal damage. These usually specify the source of the damage and the target.

The Mechanics of Dealing Damage

The process of dealing damage might seem straightforward, but several intricacies are involved. Here’s a breakdown:

Combat Damage: During the combat damage step, each attacking creature deals damage to the creature blocking it, or the defending player if it’s unblocked. Blocking creatures also deal damage to the creatures they are blocking. The damage is always equal to the creature’s power at that time. If a creature’s power is zero or negative, it does not deal combat damage.
Damage from Spells and Abilities: These specify the source of the damage (which is typically a card) and the target (which can be a player, a creature, or a planeswalker). The text on the card will dictate the amount of damage dealt.
Damage Assignment: If an attacker is blocked by multiple creatures, the attacker’s controller determines a damage assignment order. This means the attacker must assign damage to the blockers according to the order given. Usually all damage will be assigned to the first blocker in the order, unless the first blocker is killed by an earlier damage dealing event, or does not have toughness equal to the attacker’s power.
Lethal Damage: A creature is destroyed if the damage marked on it equals or exceeds its toughness. This damage can be from a single source or multiple sources over time.
Indestructible and Damage: Creatures with Indestructible are not destroyed by damage. They still have damage marked on them, but this damage will not be enough to destroy the creature as it is impervious to such effects.

Special Cases and Interactions

Damage interacts with several other mechanics and rules in MTG. Here are a few key interactions:

Deathtouch: Any amount of damage dealt by a source with Deathtouch to a creature is enough to destroy that creature (unless it has Indestructible). If a creature with deathtouch has zero power, it cannot deal damage and thus cannot destroy any creature by dealing damage. Two instances of Deathtouch against one another will cancel each other out.
First Strike and Double Strike: Creatures with First Strike deal damage in a separate first combat damage step. If this damage is lethal to the creature that would deal damage at the same time, the other damage is not dealt. A creature with Double Strike deals damage in both the first and normal combat damage steps.
Trample: If an attacking creature with Trample deals more damage than a blocking creature’s toughness, the excess damage is dealt to the defending player.
Indestructible vs. Deathtouch: Creatures with Indestructible are unaffected by Deathtouch.
Damage vs. Loss of Life: It’s important to distinguish between damage and life loss. Damage causes loss of life, but not all loss of life is damage. Effects that cause “loss of life” bypass damage prevention, while damage can be reduced or prevented.

Damage and Player Life Total

Damage dealt to a player results in a loss of life. The life total of a player starts at 20 by default and, in most formats, a player loses the game when their life total drops to 0. Spells or abilities that cause the loss of life do not cause damage. Damage from a creature is considered combat damage and can trigger cards that track combat damage, where as a spell that reduces a players life by 5 will not.

Understanding the nuances of damage in MTG will significantly enhance your gameplay. Knowing the rules of damage, the exceptions, and the interactions will give you a tactical advantage and help you navigate complex game situations.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Damage in MTG

Here are some common questions about dealing damage in Magic: The Gathering, along with their answers, to further clarify this crucial mechanic:

Does dealing 0 damage count as dealing damage?

No. While “dealing 0 damage” and “not dealing damage” result in the same outcome of no life loss, a creature with 0 power doesn’t actually deal damage in combat. This distinction is important because it impacts cards that trigger from dealing combat damage. A card like Curiosity won’t trigger from a creature with 0 power dealing combat damage.

Can you deal more damage than toughness?

Yes. Creatures often deal more damage than a blocking creature’s toughness in order to destroy them. A creature is destroyed only if the damage marked on it is equal to or greater than the creature’s toughness.

Is blocking dealing damage in magic?

Yes. Blocking counts as dealing combat damage. Creatures that block will deal their power as damage to the creatures they are blocking during the combat phase. If a card cares about combat damage dealt to a player, damage dealt to a blocking creature does not count.

Can you assign all damage to one blocker?

If one creature is blocking, all damage is assigned to that creature. If an attacking creature is blocked by two or more creatures, then the attacker’s controller chooses the order the defending creatures will be assigned damage. This often allows for damage to be allocated all to the first blocker unless they have less toughness than the attackers power.

Does Deathtouch cancel Deathtouch?

Yes. If two creatures with Deathtouch deal damage to each other, the instances of deathtouch cancel each other out. This means a creature with deathtouch does not deal lethal damage to a creature with deathtouch in combat.

Does First Strike beat Deathtouch?

Yes, often. A creature with First Strike deals its damage before a creature with deathtouch. If the first strike creature deals lethal damage to the deathtouch creature, the deathtouch creature does not deal any damage back.

Does indestructible prevent combat damage?

Indestructible prevents destruction by damage. Creatures with Indestructible still take damage, but that damage is not enough to destroy them. The damage will remain on the creature.

What are the rules for blocking in Magic The Gathering?

A creature must be untapped to block. Each creature can only block a single attacker, but multiple defending creatures can block the same attacker. Players have a chance to cast instants and activate abilities after blockers are declared but before damage is dealt.

What does deal damage mean?

To deal damage is to reduce either the toughness of a creature or the life total of a player. Damage dealt is the amount of damage that occurs, and damage taken is amount of damage that an entity receives.

Is trample excess damage?

Yes. Trample allows an attacking creature to deal excess damage to the defending player if the blocking creature’s toughness is less than the attacker’s power. Trample can also trample over planewalkers and battles.

Is Deathtouch dealing damage?

Deathtouch is a static ability that causes any amount of damage to a creature to be considered lethal damage to that creature. It doesn’t change the amount of damage dealt.

What happens if a creature with Deathtouch deals 0 damage?

If a creature with Deathtouch deals 0 damage, the ability does nothing. A creature needs to deal damage for the ability to have an effect.

Does destroying a creature count as dealing damage?

No. Destroying a creature is a distinct game function. Destroy effects put a permanent directly into the graveyard, whereas damage is a number that is marked on a creature, or causes a player to lose life.

Is losing life considered damage in magic?

No. While damage causes loss of life, spells that cause the loss of life are not damage. This distinction matters for triggered abilities or cards that prevent damage.

What wins indestructible vs Deathtouch?

Indestructible wins against Deathtouch. A creature with Indestructible cannot be destroyed by damage, regardless of whether that damage came from a source with Deathtouch.

By understanding these intricate rules and special cases, you can significantly improve your MTG game. These mechanics provide the framework for combat, spell interactions, and ultimately, your strategy for victory.