Extra Attack & Two-Weapon Fighting: A 5E Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Extra Attack and Two-Weapon Fighting (TWF) are two core mechanics in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition that, when combined, can significantly boost a character’s damage output. However, understanding how they interact requires careful attention to the rules.
How does Extra Attack work with Two-Weapon Fighting? Extra Attack grants you multiple attacks when you take the Attack action on your turn. Two-Weapon Fighting allows you to make an additional attack with a light weapon in your off-hand as a bonus action if you’ve already attacked with a light weapon in your main hand as part of your Attack action. So, if you have Extra Attack and use Two-Weapon Fighting, you can make multiple attacks with your main hand weapon as part of the Attack action, and then use your bonus action for a single attack with your off-hand weapon. For instance, with Extra Attack (2 attacks), you attack twice with your main hand weapon and once with your off-hand weapon (total of 3 attacks).
Understanding the Mechanics
Let’s break down each mechanic individually before combining them.
Extra Attack Explained
The Extra Attack feature is granted to many martial classes at level 5, such as Fighters, Paladins, Rangers, and Barbarians. It specifically states: “Beginning at 5th level, you can attack twice, instead of once, whenever you take the Attack action on your turn.” Some classes (like the Fighter) gain even more attacks at higher levels, up to a maximum of four attacks at level 20.
Crucially, Extra Attack only applies when you take the Attack action. This means that if you use your action to do something else, like Cast a Spell, Dodge, or Dash, you don’t get the benefit of Extra Attack that turn. Each attack granted by Extra Attack is treated as a separate attack roll and damage roll. You can even target different creatures with each attack if you wish. Furthermore, Extra Attack imposes no limitation on what you use for the attacks. You can use regular weapons, improvised weapons, unarmed strikes, or a combination of these options for the attacks.
Two-Weapon Fighting Explained
Two-Weapon Fighting is a combat option available to any character, but it’s generally more effective for those with specific feats or class features that enhance it. The core rule is: “When you take the Attack action and attack with a light melee weapon that you’re holding in one hand, you can use a bonus action to attack with a different light melee weapon that you’re holding in the other hand.”
Several key points are essential to understanding TWF:
- Light Weapons: Both weapons must be light melee weapons. Daggers, shortswords, and scimitars are common examples.
- Bonus Action: The off-hand attack requires you to use your bonus action. This means you cannot use your bonus action for anything else on that turn if you choose to make an off-hand attack.
- Ability Modifier: By default, you do not add your ability modifier (Strength or Dexterity) to the damage roll of the off-hand attack, unless that modifier is negative. Some feats and class features, like the Two-Weapon Fighting fighting style (available to Fighters and Rangers), allow you to add your ability modifier to the off-hand attack damage.
- Attack Action Requirement: You must take the Attack Action to trigger TWF.
- Action Economy: Two Weapon Fighting alters the attack economy by allowing the players to spend their bonus action to do an additional attack.
Combining Extra Attack and Two-Weapon Fighting
The synergy between Extra Attack and Two-Weapon Fighting allows for a substantial increase in the number of attacks you can make in a single turn. Let’s illustrate with an example:
A 5th-level Fighter with Extra Attack and the Two-Weapon Fighting style is wielding two shortswords.
- The Fighter takes the Attack action.
- Because of Extra Attack, the Fighter can make two attacks as part of the Attack action, both with their main-hand shortsword. Each attack is a separate roll.
- Because the Fighter took the Attack action and attacked with a light melee weapon, they can use their bonus action to make an additional attack with their off-hand shortsword. They add their ability modifier to the damage of this attack because they have the Two-Weapon Fighting style.
In total, the Fighter makes three attacks in one turn: two with the main-hand weapon and one with the off-hand weapon.
Without Extra Attack, the Fighter would only make two attacks in one turn: One with the main-hand weapon and one with the off-hand weapon.
Optimizing Two-Weapon Fighting
While Two-Weapon Fighting offers extra attacks, it’s not always the most optimal combat style. To make it more effective, consider the following:
- Fighting Style: The Two-Weapon Fighting style is essential for adding your ability modifier to the damage of the off-hand attack.
- Feats: The Dual Wielder feat allows you to use non-light weapons (like rapiers) for Two-Weapon Fighting and increases your AC by 1 when wielding a weapon in each hand. It also lets you draw or stow two one-handed weapons when you would normally only be able to draw or stow one.
- Class Features: Some classes, like the Ranger, have subclasses (e.g., Hunter) that provide additional benefits for using multiple attacks.
- Magic Weapons: Equipping two magic weapons can significantly increase your damage output. Look for weapons with effects that trigger on a hit, such as dealing extra damage or inflicting status conditions.
- Action Surge: Fighters can leverage action surge to create two actions in a turn.
FAQs: Extra Attack & Two-Weapon Fighting
1. Does Extra Attack apply to my off-hand attack?
No, Extra Attack is part of the Attack action. Your off-hand attack uses your bonus action.
2. If I have Extra Attack, can I make all my attacks with my off-hand weapon?
No. Extra Attack applies to the Attack action. Two-Weapon Fighting lets you use your Bonus Action to make an attack with a different light weapon. You take the Attack action to attack with one of your weapons and then you can use your bonus action to attack with another weapon.
3. Can I use a heavy weapon with Extra Attack?
Yes. Extra Attack doesn’t restrict the type of weapon you use. The restriction applies to two-weapon fighting where the weapons must be light.
4. Does the Two-Weapon Fighting style let me use non-light weapons?
No. The Two-Weapon Fighting style only adds your ability modifier to the off-hand attack’s damage. To use non-light weapons, you need the Dual Wielder feat.
5. Can I use Two-Weapon Fighting with a ranged weapon?
No. Two-Weapon Fighting requires melee weapons.
6. Can I use Two-Weapon Fighting if I don’t have Extra Attack?
Yes. Any character can use Two-Weapon Fighting as long as they meet the requirements (light weapons, using the Attack action, and having a bonus action available). However, Extra Attack makes it more effective by increasing the number of attacks made with your main hand weapon.
7. If I miss with my first attack from Extra Attack, can I still use my bonus action for the off-hand attack?
Yes. The bonus action attack is independent of whether your attacks made as part of the Attack action hit or miss. As long as you take the Attack action and attack with a light melee weapon, you can make a bonus action attack with a different light melee weapon.
8. Does the off-hand attack get my proficiency bonus?
Yes, the off-hand attack gets your proficiency bonus on the attack roll. It’s only the damage roll that normally doesn’t include your ability modifier.
9. Can I use Two-Weapon Fighting if I only have one weapon?
No. Two-Weapon Fighting requires you to be wielding two different light weapons.
10. Can I throw one of my light weapons and still use Two-Weapon Fighting?
No. To use TWF, both light melee weapons must be in your possession at the time you make both attacks (Attack Action and Bonus Action).
11. If I have a negative Strength modifier, do I apply it to my off-hand attack?
Yes. Even though you don’t normally add positive ability modifiers to the damage of your off-hand attack, you do apply negative modifiers.
12. Can I use a shield and still use Two-Weapon Fighting?
No. Two-Weapon Fighting requires wielding a light melee weapon in each hand.
13. Can I use Action Surge to get another bonus action to make a second off-hand attack?
No. Action Surge grants you an additional action on your turn, not an additional bonus action. You only get one bonus action per turn.
14. Does the Hunter Ranger’s Colossus Slayer ability apply to all my attacks when using Extra Attack and Two-Weapon Fighting?
Yes, if the conditions are met. The Colossus Slayer ability adds extra damage “once per turn, when you hit a creature with a weapon attack that is below its hit point maximum.” Because Extra Attack and TWF both involve separate weapon attacks, you could potentially trigger Colossus Slayer multiple times in a turn if attacking different creatures.
15. How is ATK calculated?
The total ATK formula is: ATK = [ ( ATK Character + ATK Weapon ) × ( 1 + % ATK Bonus ) ] + ATK Flat Bonus
Conclusion
Combining Extra Attack and Two-Weapon Fighting can create a potent offensive strategy in 5th Edition D&D, allowing characters to unleash a flurry of attacks in a single turn. However, it’s essential to understand the rules governing each mechanic to maximize their effectiveness and avoid common pitfalls. By carefully selecting feats, fighting styles, and equipment, players can craft powerful and engaging characters who excel in close-quarters combat.
To learn more about the educational aspects of gaming, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.