How Good is a Longsword?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The longsword is an exceptionally good weapon, standing out for its versatility, effectiveness, and adaptability on the battlefield and in personal combat. Its primary strength lies in its balanced design, allowing for a wide range of techniques including thrusting, cutting, parrying, and even percussive strikes with the hilt. Its effectiveness depends significantly on the skill and training of the wielder, as the longsword is not a weapon of simple brute force, but rather of nuanced technique and tactical application. The longsword’s ability to be wielded with one or two hands gives it an advantage in different combat scenarios, making it a highly respected and formidable weapon in historical contexts.
The Longsword: A Versatile Weapon
The longsword truly shines because of its adaptability. Unlike specialized weapons like the rapier, which excels primarily in thrusting, or the katana, optimized for cutting, the longsword offers a complete combat system. This system encompasses:
- Cutting and Slicing: The longsword’s blade geometry allows for effective cuts against unarmored or lightly armored opponents.
- Thrusting: The pointed tip enables powerful thrusts, capable of penetrating gaps in armor or striking vital areas.
- Parrying and Deflecting: The length of the blade provides excellent leverage for deflecting incoming attacks.
- Half-Swording: Gripping the blade itself allows for precise control in close quarters, turning the sword into a lever or a striking tool.
- Mordhau: Holding the blade and using the hilt as a hammer allows for powerful percussive blows against heavily armored opponents.
This versatility made the longsword a popular choice across various social classes, from knights and soldiers to commoners seeking a reliable self-defense tool. Its adaptability to different combat situations and opponent types is what truly sets it apart.
Longsword vs. Other Weapons
Comparisons to other weapons are inevitable. Let’s examine a few key matchups:
Longsword vs. Katana
The katana, with its curved blade and single edge, excels at cutting and drawing techniques. However, the longsword’s thrusting capabilities and greater defensive potential provide a significant advantage in a wider range of combat scenarios. While the katana might be quicker in certain cutting exchanges, the longsword’s versatility makes it the superior all-around weapon. As the article you provided states, “If you need a fast and agile weapon for cutting and slicing, the katana may be the better choice. However, if you need a weapon that is better suited for thrusting and parrying, the longsword may be the way to go.”
Longsword vs. Rapier
The rapier is a specialized dueling weapon designed for thrusting and quick, precise attacks. While incredibly fast, it lacks the cutting power of the longsword and is less effective against armored opponents. The longsword’s ability to deliver powerful cuts and parry effectively gives it an edge in a broader combat context. Again, as the provided article suggests, “A longsword has way better reach and you can basically smash through any kind of guard that a one handed weapon would put up. A rapier is faster, but longsword techniques are designed to cut through the line of attack, mitigating this advantage.”
Longsword vs. Greatsword
The greatsword is a larger, heavier weapon designed for battlefield use against formations of infantry. While it boasts greater raw power, its size makes it slower and less agile than the longsword. The longsword offers a better balance of power and maneuverability, making it more suitable for individual combat.
The Importance of Training
The longsword is not a weapon that can be picked up and used effectively without proper training. Mastering the longsword requires dedicated practice to develop:
- Proper Stance and Footwork: Essential for maintaining balance and generating power.
- Blade Awareness: Understanding the position and movement of the blade relative to the opponent.
- Timing and Distance: Accurately judging the moment to attack and maintaining a safe distance.
- Controlled Power: Delivering strikes with appropriate force and precision.
Historical fencing manuals, such as those written by Johannes Liechtenauer and Fiore dei Liberi, provide detailed instructions on longsword techniques and tactics. Modern practitioners study these manuals and engage in rigorous training to revive and preserve these fighting arts. The Games Learning Society explores innovative ways to engage with historical materials, which could even include creating games to help learn about historical fighting styles. GamesLearningSociety.org understands the value of games in education and preservation.
FAQs: Longsword Edition
Here are some frequently asked questions about the longsword, offering further insight into its characteristics and capabilities:
1. Was the longsword a primary battlefield weapon?
No, the longsword was generally a secondary weapon, or sidearm. Polearms like spears, halberds, and pikes were the primary weapons used in formations on the battlefield. The longsword served as a backup weapon for close-quarters combat or when the primary weapon was lost or broken.
2. How heavy was a typical longsword?
Most longswords weighed between 2.5 and 4.5 pounds (1.1 to 2 kg). While this may not seem like much, the weight distribution and length of the blade required considerable strength and skill to wield effectively.
3. Could a longsword cut through armor?
While a longsword was unlikely to cleanly cut through plate armor, it could be used to target gaps in the armor, such as the joints of the limbs or the visor of the helmet. The mordhau technique, using the hilt as a hammer, was also effective against armored opponents.
4. Was the longsword only used by knights?
No, the longsword was used by a variety of people, including knights, soldiers, mercenaries, and even civilians seeking self-defense.
5. What is half-swording?
Half-swording is a technique where the wielder grips the blade with one or both hands to gain greater control and precision in close quarters. This allows for thrusting, parrying, and leveraging techniques that are difficult or impossible with a standard grip.
6. What is mordhau?
Mordhau is a technique where the wielder grips the blade and uses the hilt as a hammer to strike the opponent. This was particularly effective against armored opponents.
7. How long was a longsword?
The blade length of a longsword typically ranged from 35 to 47 inches (90 to 120 cm), with an overall length of 43 to 55 inches (110 to 140 cm).
8. What was the longsword made of?
Longswords were typically made of high-carbon steel, which provided a good balance of strength, flexibility, and edge retention.
9. Could a longsword break another sword?
While possible, it was unlikely for a longsword to break another sword in combat. Swords were designed to withstand considerable stress, and breaking them required specific circumstances and a great deal of force. As the original article indicates, the best way to break a traditionally made katana would be to place the tip in a vice and bend it to the side and it would be more likely to bend permanently than break anyways.
10. Was the longsword a “bastard sword”?
The term “bastard sword” is often used to refer to a hand-and-a-half sword, which is slightly shorter than a true longsword but still capable of being wielded with one or two hands. While the terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they are not precisely the same.
11. How was the longsword carried?
The longsword was typically carried in a scabbard worn on the belt or slung over the shoulder.
12. What is Historical European Martial Arts (HEMA)?
HEMA is the study and practice of historical European fighting systems, including longsword combat, based on surviving historical manuals.
13. Were longswords used in tournaments?
Yes, longswords were used in tournaments and duels, often with blunted or rebated blades for safety.
14. How sharp was a longsword?
A well-maintained longsword could be extremely sharp, capable of slicing through flesh and light materials with ease. However, sharpness was balanced against durability, as an overly sharp edge could be easily damaged.
15. Can a longsword cut through bone?
Yes, a sharp longsword wielded with sufficient force can cut through bone. The longer blade provides more leverage in order to cut through heavy targets such as bone.
Conclusion
The longsword is an excellent weapon due to its versatility, effectiveness, and adaptability. Its balanced design and wide range of techniques make it a formidable tool in the hands of a skilled wielder. While not a weapon of simple brute force, the longsword requires nuance, technique, and tactical application. This allows for a greater range of possible attacks and defenses than most other weapons. The historical and martial significance of the longsword continues to be appreciated and studied today through organizations dedicated to HEMA, as well as innovative approaches to education like those used by the Games Learning Society.