How Heavy is the Moonlight Greatsword?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Moonlight Greatsword’s weight is a deceptively simple question, yet it plunges us into the fascinating realm of video game logic, lore, and the physics of fantasy. Officially, within the Dark Souls universe and related titles like Elden Ring, the in-game weight of the Moonlight Greatsword hovers around 6 units. Many fans believe these units correspond to pounds, making a ‘realistic’ Moonlight Greatsword weigh approximately 6 lbs (2.7kg). However, whether this weight feels “right” is a matter of debate, considering the sword’s often immense size and magical properties.
The Disconnect: In-Game Weight vs. Real-World Physics
Analyzing Straight Sword Weights
The conclusion that Dark Souls weight units represent pounds stems from the common observation that most straight swords weigh around 3 units. This seems reasonable, aligning with the average weight of a real-world longsword. Consequently, the Moonlight Greatsword’s 6 units appears to be a light weight. The Fume Ultra Greatsword in Dark Souls 3 is called “the heaviest of all ultra greatswords.”
Factors Influencing Perception
Several factors contribute to the perception of the Moonlight Greatsword’s weight as light for a weapon of its size and power. These factors include:
- Game Balance: In-game weight is primarily a mechanic for balancing gameplay. If the Moonlight Greatsword were realistically heavy, it would severely limit player agility and equipment load, potentially making it unplayable for many builds.
- Magical Properties: The Moonlight Greatsword is not just a piece of metal. It’s imbued with magic, often described as being formed from pure light or moonlight. This could imply that the sword’s physical density is less than that of a conventional steel weapon, allowing it to be lighter than it appears.
- Artistic License: Game developers often take liberties with realism to enhance the aesthetic appeal and overall experience. A visually impressive, oversized sword is more appealing than a realistically proportioned one, even if it defies physics.
- Lore Implications: The sword, often associated with royalty or cosmic entities, might possess properties that transcend conventional material science. This is especially true when considering the weapon’s origins in the King’s Field series.
Historical Context: Real-World Greatsword Weights
To further complicate matters, let’s look at real-world greatswords. Historically, European greatswords like the Zweihander, Claymore, Spadone, and Montante, were indeed massive weapons. These swords were typically around a man’s height, with some Zweihanders reaching up to 7 feet in length. Despite their size, these swords generally weighed between 4.5lbs to 7lbs, making them suprisingly lighter than one might expect. Even Guts’ Dragonslayer from Berserk weighing 388 lbs seems absurd. Claymores averaged around 5.5lbs. So, a Moonlight Greatsword at 6 pounds is actually in line with historical greatsword weights.
Gameplay Considerations in Souls-like Games
Build Specialization
In Dark Souls and Elden Ring, weapon weight affects a character’s “equip load,” influencing their movement speed and roll distance. A heavy weapon like the Fume Ultra Greatsword (DS3) requires a significant investment in the Vitality (Dark Souls) or Endurance (Elden Ring) stat to avoid becoming encumbered. The Moonlight Greatsword’s relatively low weight allows players to wield it without sacrificing agility.
Balancing Damage Output
The Moonlight Greatsword typically deals a mix of physical and magical damage, often scaling primarily with Intelligence or Faith. Its damage output is balanced against its weight, moveset, and stat requirements to ensure it’s a viable but not overpowered option. The Dark Moon Greatsword deals 478 damage at 40 intelligence. Each point after 40 intelligence increases the damage by only 2.
Moveset Variety
Greatswords in Souls games have distinct movesets that differentiate them from other weapon types. The Moonlight Greatsword’s moveset often includes unique attacks, such as energy waves or charged strikes, which contribute to its overall effectiveness in combat. The Godslayer Greatsword is faster, but deals less damage.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why is the Moonlight Greatsword in almost every FromSoftware game?
The Moonlight Greatsword is a recurring weapon in FromSoftware’s games, acting as a trademark and homage to their earlier works. It first appeared in King’s Field, where it was essential to the storyline. Its presence in subsequent titles serves as a nod to the studio’s history and a reward for long-time fans.
2. What are the stat requirements for the Moonlight Greatsword in Elden Ring?
In Elden Ring, the Dark Moon Greatsword requires 16 Strength, 11 Dexterity, and 38 Intelligence to wield effectively.
3. Where do I find the Moonlight Greatsword in Elden Ring?
The Dark Moon Greatsword is obtained by completing Ranni’s questline in Elden Ring. It is given to you by Ranni herself as a reward.
4. Is the Moonlight Greatsword considered a legendary weapon?
Yes, the Dark Moon Greatsword in Elden Ring is described as one of the “legendary armaments,” signifying its importance and rarity.
5. What color is the Moonlight Greatsword?
The Moonlight Greatsword is typically depicted as glowing an eerie green or blue. The exact hue can vary slightly between games, but the radiant, otherworldly glow remains consistent.
6. Is the Moonlight Greatsword a skill in Elden Ring?
In Elden Ring, the Moonlight Greatsword is both a weapon and a skill. The weapon itself is the Dark Moon Greatsword, and its unique skill allows players to unleash powerful magical attacks.
7. What makes the Greatsword weapon category so popular in Souls games?
Greatswords in Souls games are favored for their excellent range, high damage output, and versatile movesets. They are effective against a wide range of enemies and bosses, making them a reliable choice for both PvE and PvP combat.
8. Does the Moonlight Greatsword appear in Bloodborne?
Yes, in Bloodborne, the Moonlight Greatsword is called the Holy Moonlight Sword. It is obtained from Ludwig’s head (or Simon).
9. Which Soulsborne game does NOT feature the Moonlight Greatsword?
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is the only Soulsborne game that does not include the Moonlight Greatsword. This is largely due to the game’s fixed protagonist and lack of weapon customization.
10. How does the Moonlight Greatsword scale with stats?
Typically, the Moonlight Greatsword primarily scales with Intelligence or Faith, depending on the game. This scaling enhances its magical damage output, making it ideal for mage or hybrid builds.
11. How does weapon weight affect gameplay in Souls games?
Weapon weight affects a character’s equip load, which influences their movement speed, roll distance, and stamina regeneration. Staying below a certain equip load threshold is crucial for maintaining agility in combat.
12. Is it possible to beat every Souls game using only the Moonlight Greatsword?
Yes, many players have successfully completed challenges where they beat every Souls game using only the Moonlight Greatsword. This demonstrates the weapon’s versatility and effectiveness across different game titles.
13. Can the Moonlight Greatsword shoot projectiles?
Yes, in many games, the Moonlight Greatsword can unleash energy waves or projectiles, typically as part of its charged attacks. This adds to its versatility and range in combat.
14. Is there any educational value in understanding video game mechanics like weapon weight?
Understanding video game mechanics can enhance critical thinking, problem-solving skills, and an appreciation for game design principles. Exploring the nuances of in-game systems, like weapon weight and scaling, can be a fun and engaging way to learn about balancing complex systems. To learn more about the educational aspects of gaming visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
15. Why is it called the Moonlight Greatsword?
The name likely stems from the weapon’s ethereal appearance and magical properties, often associated with moonlight. The blade is often depicted as emitting a soft, ethereal glow, reminiscent of moonlight.
Conclusion
While the “realistic” weight of the Moonlight Greatsword might seem light at 6 lbs, it’s important to consider the game’s design, lore, and the magical properties of the weapon. Ultimately, the Moonlight Greatsword is more than just a weapon; it’s a symbol of FromSoftware’s legacy and a testament to the power of imagination in video game design. Its weight, whether perceived as realistic or not, is just one element that contributes to its iconic status.