Decoding the Darkness: Unveiling the Endings of Dark Souls 1

Dark Souls, the legendary action RPG, is renowned for its challenging gameplay, intricate world-building, and ambiguous storytelling. A crucial element of this ambiguity lies in its endings. The simple answer to the question “How many endings are in Dark Souls 1?” is that there are two distinct endings available to players upon defeating Gwyn, Lord of Cinder. However, the ramifications and interpretations of these endings are far from simple. Let’s delve into the details of these endings and explore the mysteries they hold.

The Two Paths: Kindling the Flame or Ushering in the Dark

Upon defeating Gwyn, Lord of Cinder, the player, known as the Chosen Undead, is presented with a critical choice. This choice dictates which ending they will experience.

Linking the Fire: The Age of Fire Continues

If the player interacts with the bonfire at the center of the arena after defeating Gwyn, they will “Link the Fire.” This act sacrifices the Chosen Undead’s soul to rekindle the First Flame, prolonging the Age of Fire. This ending is often presented as the “good” ending, primarily because Kingseeker Frampt advocates for it. He paints a picture of glory and purpose, convincing the player that they are fulfilling their destiny by maintaining the light against the encroaching darkness. However, it’s crucial to note that linking the fire is, at best, a temporary solution. The flame will inevitably fade again, requiring another sacrifice to perpetuate the cycle. This ending essentially resets the world, ensuring the continuation of the existing power structures and the suffering associated with the Undead Curse.

Becoming the Dark Lord: An Age of Humanity

The alternative to linking the fire is to simply walk away from the bonfire. By refusing to sacrifice themselves, the Chosen Undead rejects the established order and chooses to become the Dark Lord. This ending signifies the beginning of the Age of Dark, an era where humanity, the inheritors of the Dark Soul, will rise to prominence. Darkstalker Kaathe champions this path, arguing that the Age of Fire is artificial and oppressive. He believes that humanity should embrace its true nature and usher in a new era of freedom and power. While often seen as the “bad” ending, the Age of Dark is not inherently evil. It’s simply an unknown, a potential for a new world free from the gods’ control. However, its implications are uncertain, and the player must weigh the potential benefits against the unknown dangers that may arise.

The Illusion of Choice: No True “Good” or “Bad”

The brilliance of Dark Souls’ endings lies in their ambiguity. There is no clear-cut “good” or “bad” ending. Both choices have profound consequences, and neither offers a perfect resolution. Linking the fire merely delays the inevitable, while becoming the Dark Lord plunges the world into an uncertain future. This lack of a definitive “happy ending” is a key characteristic of the Dark Souls series, reflecting the themes of futility, cyclical history, and the struggle against overwhelming odds. From Software leaves the interpretation of these endings to the player, forcing them to confront the moral complexities and the limitations of their own agency within the world of Lordran. To enhance your understanding of the importance of games in education, consider exploring the resources available at GamesLearningSociety.org.

FAQs: Unraveling the Mysteries of Dark Souls Endings

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the endings of Dark Souls 1, providing deeper insights into their nuances and implications.

1. Is there a true “canon” ending to Dark Souls 1?

There is no officially designated canon ending to Dark Souls 1. From Software intentionally leaves both endings open to interpretation, allowing players to draw their own conclusions. While Dark Souls 3 suggests that the fire has been linked multiple times throughout history, it doesn’t specify which ending the Chosen Undead ultimately chose.

2. Does choosing one ending affect the gameplay of New Game+?

The ending you choose does not directly affect the gameplay of New Game+ (NG+). NG+ restarts the game with increased difficulty but carries over your character’s level, equipment, and certain items. The world state remains the same regardless of whether you linked the fire or became the Dark Lord.

3. Does one ending lead to a “better” outcome for the world of Dark Souls?

Neither ending guarantees a “better” outcome. Linking the fire extends the Age of Fire but perpetuates the cycle of sacrifice and undead curse. Becoming the Dark Lord ushers in an Age of Dark, the consequences of which are unknown. The perceived “goodness” or “badness” is subjective and depends on the player’s perspective.

4. Does my choice of ending affect my relationship with specific NPCs?

Your ending choice does not directly affect your relationships with NPCs during your current playthrough. However, some NPCs may have dialogue that reflects their preference for one ending over the other. In NG+, you may approach these interactions with a different perspective based on your previous ending.

5. Can I reverse my decision after defeating Gwyn?

No. Once you choose an ending, there is no way to reverse your decision in the current playthrough. You are immediately thrust into NG+. Therefore, it’s essential to consider the implications carefully before making your choice.

6. Does Dark Souls 2 reference either of the endings from Dark Souls 1?

Dark Souls 2 explores the consequences of the cyclical nature of the world established in Dark Souls 1. While it doesn’t directly reference a specific ending chosen by the Chosen Undead, it acknowledges the recurring themes of fire, dark, and the struggle against fate.

7. Is it possible to get both endings in a single playthrough?

No. It is impossible to experience both endings in a single playthrough. You must choose one or the other after defeating Gwyn. To see both endings, you need to complete the game at least twice.

8. Which ending is considered the “true” ending by the community?

There is no consensus within the Dark Souls community regarding which ending is the “true” ending. Both endings are equally valid and contribute to the overall lore and themes of the game. Discussions often revolve around personal interpretations and the philosophical implications of each choice.

9. Does the “Age of Dark” necessarily mean the end of the world?

The “Age of Dark” does not necessarily equate to the end of the world. It simply signifies a shift in power from the gods to humanity. It is a period of unknown potential, filled with both opportunities and dangers.

10. How does the character’s motivation affect the choice of ending?

The Chosen Undead’s motivation heavily influences the choice of ending. Players who believe in upholding tradition and preserving the established order may choose to link the fire. Those who question the status quo and seek to forge their own destiny may opt to become the Dark Lord.

11. What role do Kingseeker Frampt and Darkstalker Kaathe play in influencing the endings?

Kingseeker Frampt and Darkstalker Kaathe act as ideological guides, each advocating for a specific ending. Frampt encourages the player to link the fire, while Kaathe urges them to become the Dark Lord. Their motivations are complex and may not be entirely altruistic.

12. Does the difficulty of the game influence which ending is chosen?

The difficulty of the game can indirectly influence the choice of ending. Players who struggle with the challenges of Lordran may be more inclined to seek a seemingly “easier” solution, such as linking the fire, out of desperation.

13. What is the significance of the bonfire in the final arena?

The bonfire in the final arena represents the First Flame, the source of power and light in the world. Interacting with it symbolizes the act of sacrificing oneself to perpetuate the Age of Fire.

14. How do the themes of sacrifice and free will relate to the endings?

The endings highlight the tension between sacrifice and free will. Linking the fire requires the Chosen Undead to sacrifice themselves for the greater good (or so it seems), while becoming the Dark Lord represents an assertion of individual will and a rejection of predetermined fate.

15. Are there any hidden cutscenes or dialogue variations associated with each ending?

There are no significant hidden cutscenes or dialogue variations associated with each ending. The primary difference lies in the final cinematic sequence, which depicts either the rekindling of the flame or the Chosen Undead ascending to the throne as the Dark Lord. The subtle nuances are primarily conveyed through the overall atmosphere and the player’s understanding of the lore.

In conclusion, the two endings of Dark Souls 1 offer players a profound choice with far-reaching consequences. The ambiguity surrounding these endings is a testament to the game’s masterful storytelling and its ability to challenge players to confront difficult moral questions. Whether you choose to link the fire or embrace the Dark Lord, your decision will shape the destiny of Lordran and leave a lasting impact on your own understanding of this unforgettable game.