How similar is RDR1 to RDR2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
RDR1 and RDR2 share a common Wild West setting, but they differ significantly in gameplay and narrative style, with RDR1 being a more fast-paced and action-oriented experience, while RDR2 is a more immersive and realistic open-world game. The two games also have distinct protagonists, with RDR1 following the story of John Marston and RDR2 focusing on Arthur Morgan, making them unique in their own ways despite being part of the same Red Dead series.
Game Comparison
Both games are set in the American West, but RDR1 takes place in 1911, while RDR2 is a prequel set in 1899. The games have different gameplay mechanics, with RDR1 being more focused on gunfights and outlaw activities, while RDR2 adds more realistic elements like hunting, fishing, and horse care.
Frequently Asked Questions
General Questions
- Is RDR1 easier than RDR2?: Subjectively, RDR1 is easier to play for long periods due to the absence of tedious bits like eating, hunting, and feeding your horse.
- Is Red Dead 1 as good as 2?: For its time, RDR1 was incredible, but RDR2 is more polished and comparable to other open-world games.
- Is Arthur Morgan mentioned in RDR1?: No, Arthur Morgan is not mentioned in RDR1 because the game was developed before RDR2, and the character did not exist at that time.
Game Details
- How much bigger is RDR2 than RDR1?: RDR2’s map is more than double the size of RDR1’s, with a large portion of the original map appearing in the sequel.
- What year is RDR1 set?: The game takes place in 1911, closely after the events of the epilogue of its subsequent prequel.
- Is Blackwater in Red Dead 1?: Yes, Blackwater is a settlement featured in both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2.
Characters and Story
- Is Hosea Matthews in RDR1?: No, Hosea Matthews is a major character in Red Dead Redemption 2, but not in RDR1.
- Should I play RDR2 before 1?: It doesn’t matter, as RDR2 is a prequel, but playing them in release order can provide a non-chronological experience.
- Does RDR1 spoil RDR2?: Yes, playing RDR1 before RDR2 can spoil some characters and events, but it also adds depth to the story.
Gameplay and Replayability
- Is Red Dead replayable?: Yes, the game has amazing secondary characters, missions, and player choices, making it replayable.
- Who is the strongest in RDR?: Arthur Morgan is considered the strongest, with exceptional marksmanship skills.
- Should you 100% RDR2?: While it’s a significant achievement, the rewards may not be worth the effort, except for bragging rights.
Future Games and Settings
- Will there be a RDR3?: Although there’s no official release date, hints and teases from Rockstar Games suggest that a new Red Dead game is possible, potentially set in 1914, following Jack Marston.
- What would RDR3 be about?: A possible prequel could focus on Dutch and Hosea, exploring how they met and founded the Van der Linde gang.
- Is Tumbleweed in RDR1?: Yes, Tumbleweed is a ghost town in RDR1, but it appears as a prosperous town in RDR2, four years prior to John Marston’s story.