How to get Minthara without losing Karlach?
Quick answer
This page answers How to get Minthara without losing Karlach? quickly.
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
▶
To recruit Minthara without losing Karlach, you must avoid completing the Grove vs Goblins quest, which allows you to have both Minthara, Wyll, and Karlach in your party together, by simply skipping the entire goblin grove raid quest and heading straight for Moonrise Towers. This approach enables you to progress through the game without making sacrifices that would normally result in losing certain companions, such as Karlach and Wyll, while still being able to recruit Minthara later on.
Frequently Asked Questions
General Questions
- Can you keep Karlach and get Minthara?: Yes, you can keep Karlach and still recruit Minthara if you skip the Goblin Grove raid quest and head to Moonrise Towers, avoiding the conflict that would cause Karlach and Wyll to leave your party.
- How do you recruit Minthara without killing Druids?: You can recruit Minthara without killing the Druids by stealing the idol to stop the ritual using stealth, which will start a fight between the Tieflings and Druids, allowing you to sneak out and report the Grove’s location to Minthara.
- Can you get Minthara without being evil?: Yes, it is possible to recruit Minthara without committing to an evil playthrough by finding creative loopholes in the game that allow for alternative solutions to the main quests.
Recruitment and Romance
- How to recruit Minthara?: Minthara can become a companion if you decide to take down the Druid Grove and side with the goblins, although this will prevent you from recruiting Halsin.
- Can you romance Minthara?: Yes, Minthara can be romanced if you continue to work with her and follow the storyline that leads to her romance scene, which is relatively easy to access if you’re on the path to recruiting her.
- Can you romance Minthara without killing?: You can romance Minthara without killing by choosing to side with her and avoiding the conflict that would lead to the death of other characters, thus opening up romance threads.
Companions and Party Dynamics
- Who will leave your party if you side with Minthara?: If you side with Minthara and the goblins, Karlach and Wyll will leave your party due to the conflict with the Druid Grove.
- Can you get Minthara without betraying the Grove?: Yes, you can recruit Minthara without betraying the Grove by stealing the idol and reporting the Grove’s location to Minthara, allowing her to take care of the Druid Grove without your direct involvement.
- Does sleeping with Minthara affect companions?: Yes, romancing Minthara can affect your relationships with other companions, potentially leading to the loss of Halsin, Wyll, and Karlach, and earning the disapproval of Gale and Shadowheart.
Gameplay and Bugs
- Is it worth recruiting Minthara?: At release, bugs prevented many of Minthara’s dialogue lines from triggering, making her a less desirable companion, but patches and updates may have addressed these issues.
- Has Minthara’s romance been fixed?: As of the last update, Minthara’s romance was still buggy, with issues regarding flags and end-game cutscenes, though players may still experience the romance scene if they avoid certain bugs.
- Can you revive Minthara after killing her?: No, once Minthara is killed and becomes permanently hostile, there is no resurrection option available for her, similar to other companions who leave or become hostile under specific circumstances.
Alternative Methods and Scenarios
- How to get Minthara without destroying the Grove?: You can recruit Minthara without destroying the Grove by not completing the Grove vs Goblins quest, thus avoiding the conflict that would lead to the Grove’s destruction.
- Can you trick Minthara?: Yes, there are creative ways to trick Minthara or avoid direct conflict, such as using stealth or magic to manipulate situations to your advantage, though these methods may have varying degrees of success and impact on the storyline.
- Can you recruit Minthara and Jaheira?: Yes, you can recruit Minthara and Jaheira, as their recruitment paths are independent of each other, depending on different choices and actions in the game, specifically Jaheira’s recruitment being dependent on your choice about the Nightsong in Act 2.