Greatsword vs. Greataxe for Barbarians: A Deep Dive into Damage Dealing
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question: for a barbarian, is a greatsword or a greataxe the superior weapon? The short answer: it depends. There’s no universally “better” choice. The optimal weapon hinges on your level, fighting style, racial features, and even your party composition. However, for many situations, Greatswords are better against low AC targets. Greataxes are better against high AC targets. Let’s break down the nuances and explore which weapon reigns supreme in various scenarios.
The Core Difference: Damage Dice and Critical Hits
The fundamental difference lies in the damage dice. A greatsword deals 2d6 damage, averaging 7 damage per hit. A greataxe deals 1d12 damage, averaging 6.5 damage per hit. Straight out of the gate, the greatsword appears to be the winner. The greatsword’s consistent, reliable damage makes it attractive early on.
However, the greataxe’s 1d12 holds latent power, especially when considering critical hits. A critical hit doubles the dice rolled. This is where the greataxe shines.
Level Matters: The Brutal Critical Factor
The Barbarian’s Brutal Critical feature, gained at level 9, significantly impacts the equation. This feature allows you to roll an additional weapon damage die when you score a critical hit. A greatsword would add another 2d6, while a greataxe would add another 1d12. The bigger die of the greataxe yields a higher potential damage spike on a critical hit.
Before level 9, the greatsword generally edges out the greataxe due to its consistent damage. After level 9, the greataxe begins to close the gap, especially if you’re a Half-Orc with the Savage Attacks racial trait, which adds another weapon damage die on a critical hit.
Fighting Styles: Great Weapon Fighting
The Great Weapon Fighting fighting style allows you to reroll 1s and 2s on weapon damage dice. This style benefits the greatsword more than the greataxe. With 2d6, you have two chances to reroll low numbers, improving the consistency of damage output. While it does help with the greataxe, the impact is less pronounced since you only have one die to reroll.
If you choose the Great Weapon Fighting style, the greatsword remains a competitive option, even at higher levels.
Advantage, Accuracy, and Armor Class
Advantage on attack rolls increases your chances of landing a critical hit. If you consistently have advantage (through Reckless Attack or other means), the greataxe’s higher critical damage potential becomes more attractive. A greataxe will be better for the high armor class targets.
Lower AC targets generally favor the greatsword, due to its higher average damage.
Higher AC targets tend to lean toward the greataxe, as the more damage per hit will be more helpful.
Racial Features: Half-Orc Dominance
The Half-Orc’s Savage Attacks feature, as mentioned before, synergizes exceptionally well with the greataxe. Adding an additional 1d12 on a critical hit pushes the greataxe’s damage potential far beyond the greatsword. For Half-Orc Barbarians, the greataxe becomes a clear favorite at level 9 and beyond.
Beyond the Numbers: Flavor and Roleplaying
While optimizing damage is important, don’t forget about flavor and roleplaying. Does your barbarian envision themselves as a precise, calculating warrior wielding a greatsword? Or are they a brutal, rage-fueled berserker smashing enemies with a greataxe? The “best” weapon is also the one that best fits your character’s concept.
The Verdict: A Situational Choice
In conclusion, there is no single “best” weapon.
- Early Levels (1-8): The greatsword offers more consistent damage.
- Levels 9+ (Especially with Savage Attacks): The greataxe becomes increasingly powerful, especially for Half-Orcs and those who consistently gain advantage on attacks.
- Great Weapon Fighting Style: The greatsword retains its viability due to the reroll benefits.
- Always Consider Flavor: Choose the weapon that best fits your character’s personality and backstory.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to your specific build, playstyle, and the challenges your barbarian faces. Experiment with both weapons and see which one feels best and performs best in your campaigns.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further illuminate the greatsword vs. greataxe debate for barbarians:
1. Can a Barbarian use a greatsword?
Yes, Barbarians are proficient with martial weapons, which include both greatswords and greataxes.
2. Does the Great Weapon Master feat change the equation?
Yes. The Great Weapon Master feat allows you to take a -5 penalty to your attack roll for a +10 bonus to damage. This feat favors weapons with higher damage potential. The greataxe benefits more from Great Weapon Master, especially if you have ways to mitigate the attack roll penalty (advantage, bless, etc.). With the Great Weapon Master, you can deal a massive blow.
3. What about a maul? How does it compare?
A maul deals 2d6 bludgeoning damage, the same as a greatsword. Therefore, it offers the same consistent damage profile. The choice between a maul and a greatsword often comes down to flavor preference (slashing vs. bludgeoning) or if you expect to frequently encounter creatures vulnerable to bludgeoning damage.
4. Is a greatsword better than a greataxe against low AC targets?
Generally, yes. The greatsword’s higher average damage is more likely to translate into consistent damage against opponents with low armor class (AC).
5. Is a greataxe better than a greatsword against high AC targets?
Potentially. When targets are harder to hit, the Great Weapon Master feat, as mentioned above, will assist. The greataxe is better for higher AC targets.
6. Does the choice of weapon depend on the Barbarian subclass?
Not significantly for most subclasses. However, certain subclass features might synergize slightly better with one weapon over the other. For example, a subclass that grants additional attacks or critical hit benefits might favor the greataxe’s higher damage potential.
7. How does the Polearm Master feat interact with this decision?
The Polearm Master feat is incompatible with both greatswords and greataxes, as it requires a polearm (glaive, halberd, quarterstaff, or spear).
8. What is the best weapon for a low-level Barbarian?
At low levels (1-4), the greatsword’s consistent damage generally makes it a more reliable choice.
9. What is the best weapon for a high-level Barbarian?
At high levels (13+), the greataxe becomes increasingly attractive, especially for Half-Orcs with Savage Attacks and Barbarians who consistently have advantage on their attack rolls. The greatsword remains viable with the Great Weapon Fighting Style.
10. Does party composition influence the weapon choice?
Yes. If your party provides reliable sources of advantage, the greataxe’s critical hit potential becomes more valuable. If your party struggles to provide advantage, the greatsword’s consistent damage might be more beneficial.
11. What if I want to prioritize roleplaying over optimization?
Always prioritize roleplaying! Choose the weapon that best fits your character’s concept, even if it’s not statistically optimal. A well-played character is more important than a perfectly optimized one.
12. Are there any magical greatswords or greataxes that are particularly good for Barbarians?
Yes, there are many! Look for magical weapons that enhance damage, critical hit chance, or provide other beneficial effects. The specifics will depend on your DM and the campaign setting.
13. How does the “Reckless Attack” feature affect this decision?
The Reckless Attack feature grants you advantage on attack rolls at the cost of granting advantage to enemies attacking you. This advantage greatly enhances the greataxe’s critical hit potential, making it a more attractive option.
14. Can I switch between a greatsword and a greataxe?
Absolutely! There’s no rule preventing you from carrying both weapons and switching between them depending on the situation. This allows you to adapt to different enemy types and combat scenarios.
15. Where can I learn more about game mechanics and design in education?
You can find resources and connect with other educators and researchers interested in game-based learning at the Games Learning Society website. The GamesLearningSociety.org is a great resource to learn more about the world of gaming and learning.
With these considerations in mind, you can confidently choose the best weapon for your Barbarian and unleash their fury upon the battlefield!